The Chubby Pickle

23 Bay Ave, Highlands
(732) 872-7000

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chicken Wings with Choice of Buffalo Honey Chipotle or Thai Ginger Sauce
Deep Fried Dill Pickles
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Seared Cajun Tuna
Chubby Sauce Wings
The Smash Burger
Hand Cut Fries
Chubby Burger
Bacon Burger
Cheeseburger

Menu

Snacks
House Made Assorted Pickles
Chips & Guac
Served with pico de gallo.
Chips & Dips
Wonton chips, with avocado, scallion ginger, and spicy asian sauces.

Appetizers
Frickles
Served with horseradish.
Quesadilla
Flour tortilla, cheddar-jack, pico de gallo, and sour cream.
Nachos
Corn tortilla, cheddar-jack, black beans, lettuce, pico de gallo, jalapeño (add beef, chicken, pork or shrimp for an additional cost).
Street Corn (2 pcs)
Roast corn, chipotle aioli, cotija cheese, and cilantro.
Korean Brussels
Oven roasted brussels, korean chili, and black sesame.
Porkroll Mac-N-Cheese
Pasta, cheddar-jack, pork roll, everything bagel crust.

Wings
Buffalo Wings
Traditional with blue cheese and veggies. Thrice cooked and pan finished.
Spicy General Tso's Wings
Served with wonton chips and spicy asian mayo. Thrice cooked, pan finished.
BBQ Wings
Served with blue cheese and veggies. Thrice cooked, pan finished.
Korean Chili Wings
Served with wonton chips and ginger-scallion aioli. Thrice cooked, pan finished.
Sweet Sesame Wings
Served with wonton chips and spicy asian mayo. Thrice cooked, pan finished.
Orange-Hot Honey Wings
Served with veggies and blue cheese. Thrice cooked, pan finished.
Nashville Hot Wings
Served with white bread and dirty pickles. . Thrice cooked, pan finished.

Tacos
Beef Tacos
Seasoned beef, shredded cheddar-jack, lettuce, pico, jalapeño, tortilla chips. 3 flour or corn tortillas with chips.
Coco-Cali Taco Roll
Coco shrimp or grilled mahi, avocado, cucumber, scallion, spicy asian mayo, sesame seed, wonton chips. 3 flour or corn tortillas with chips.
Grilled Chicken Taco
Citrus marinated grilled chicken, orange, avocado, cilantro, red onion, tomato, aji verde, tortilla chips. 3 flour or corn tortillas with chips.
Smoked Mojo Pork Taco
Apple-jicama slaw, cilantro, tortilla chips. 3 flour or corn tortillas with chips.

Salads
Caesar Salad
Romaine, house Caesar, parm, and garlic-thyme croutns.

Sandwiches
Chubby Sandwich
10 ounces burger, ltop and cheese (American, swiss, cheddar, provolone, mounceszarella). With house fries or side salad, on garlic toasted brioche, unless otherwise stated (add: avocado, bacon, beer onions for an additional cost). .
Smash Burger
Two 5ounces burgers, American, bacon, ltop, 1000 island. With house fries or side salad, on garlic toasted brioche, unless otherwise stated (add: avocado, bacon, beer onions for an additional cost). .
Chicken a L'Orange Sandwich
Fresh fried (or grilled) chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, pickle, orange hot honey and oranges. With house fries or side salad, on garlic toasted brioche, unless otherwise stated (add: avocado, bacon, beer onions for an additional cost). .
Auction Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Russian rye, cheddar, American and swiss, pickled green tomatoes. With house fries or side salad, on garlic toasted brioche, unless otherwise stated (add: avocado, bacon, beer onions for an additional cost).
Smoked Pulled Pork Sandwich
House smoked pork, creamy slaw, bbq sauce. With house fries or side salad, on garlic toasted brioche, unless otherwise stated (add: avocado, bacon, beer onions for an additional cost).
Pastrami Sandwich
House smoked seasoned corned beef (aka pastrami), swiss, sauerkraut, rye, 1000 island, house fries. With house fries or side salad, on garlic toasted brioche, unless otherwise stated (add: avocado, bacon, beer onions for an additional cost).
Avocado Toast Burger
10 ounces burger, garlic toast, avocado, pico de gallo, chipotle mayo (sans burger for an additional cost). With house fries or side salad, on garlic toasted brioche, unless otherwise stated (add: avocado, bacon, beer onions for an additional cost).
Triple B Burger
Bacon, blue cheese and beer onions. With house fries or side salad, on garlic toasted brioche, unless otherwise stated (add: avocado, bacon, beer onions for an additional cost). .
Veggie Burger
Dr. Praeger's kale-veggie patty, lettuce, tomato and onion. With house fries or side salad, on garlic toasted brioche, unless otherwise stated (add: avocado, bacon, beer onions for an additional cost).

Entrées
Steak Frites
Coffee rubbed flat iron steak, fries, and aji verde.
Porkroll Mac-N-Cheese
Pasta, cheddar-jack, pork roll, everything bagel crust.
Pork Chop
Twelve ounces pan roasted chop, roasted root veg hash, laird's applejack'd sauce.

Sides
Beer Battered Onion Rings
Served with horseradish sauce.
Fries
House made, curly, or tater tots.
Sweet Potato Wedges
Homemade apple butter.

Kids
Chicken Nuggets
Served with honey dijon. Twelve and under only. Served with French fries or salad.
Burger (5 oz)
Served with cheese and pickles. Twelve and under only. Served with French fries or salad.
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with marinara. Twelve and under only. Served with French fries or salad.
Grilled Cheese
(American on white) with pickles. Twelve and under only. Served with French fries or salad.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+11 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+10 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Went because it is listed as being on Diners Drive-ins and Dives. Was greeted as soon as we entered by a friendly bartender. All servers and bartenders are fun and pleasant. The food was much better than I thought it was going to be. Two drinks, appetizers and entrees for 2 people and it was under $100!!! Will go again.
October 2025
Visiting from upstate NY. Googled a good place to eat that was inexpensive. 10/10. Food was so good! I LOVE birria tacos and they were soooooooo good! Seems to be a local hangout with a great atmosphere.
September 2025
It’s completely understandable for a bar to cut off the kitchen at a certain time, but it should be made clear on the website in their operating hours are on the menu or somewhere instead of having people sit there for 20 minutes and then finding out that the kitchen is closed
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Off The Hook Restaurant and Bar - 1 NJ-36
American, Seafood, Bar, New American, Vegetarian
Bahrs Landing Famous Seafood Restaurant & Marina - 2 Bay Ave
Seafood, German, Bar, American, Pet Friendly
Moby's Lobster Deck - 2 S Bay Ave
Seafood, American, Pet Friendly, Bar, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

The Chubby Pickle

23 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
(732) 872-7000