Fig & Tomato Italian European Eatery

100 Park Ave, Hillsdale
(201) 722-8880

Recent Reviews

Jacob Strosberg

Good food and friendly staff. Drunken chicken and pasta. Would recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari

Alexis Rasquinha

We celebrated our daughter’s baptism reception at Fig & Tomato and couldn’t have been happier. All our guests loved the food, service and ambiance. Annie, their event coordinator, was especially wonderful to work with! Thank you to their whole team for the core memories!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Connie Dietel

Loved the food and our server Jodi was fantastic! She was friendly, accommodating, and fun.We were a party of ten and everyone enjoyed all the appetizers and entrees. I especially liked the seafood salad and calamari Rosario. The mussels in white wine sauce were tender and delicious. The portions were huge and we will definitely keep this place in our rotation.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Calamari Rosario, Chicken Milanese

Rebecca Moretto

Anne and her team did an incredible job with our mother’s 60th birthday. They handled everything and were super flexible and accommodating even with a few of our guests that had specific dining requests/dietary restrictions.Just show up and have a good time! Highly recommend Fig and Tomato. The food is excellent and the experience takes it over the top!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

pete del rosso

escarole and bean soup had lemon in it server confirm that. requested no peppers in chicken dish that came out with peppers. requested stringbeans be cooked soft but came out hard. chicken dish came out with a lemon taste and when I asked server she said it was a lemon wine sauce but menu says garlic and wine sauce

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Noreen Dowling

Just had my mom’s 85th Surprise Birthday Party here. Both the service & food was outstanding. Nice as this is a bring your own wine place. Everyone was chatting about how great the food was and surprised that they had not known it was here. We had a private room to the left that holds 36 people. We were close to capacity and not overcrowded. This restaurant is a gem ? Thank you Annie for making moms party a memorable one

Elizabeth Garis

Large portions excellent food. Shrimp Parmigiana and chicken franchise fantastic as well as the fried calamari as appetizer. The waiter was warm, friendly, and made sure we had a positive experience. Definitely going back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

librarydesigner

We had a res and we were a bit early but they said the table was ready. I don't know what it is but 9 out of 10 Open Table reservations we make we end up by the bathrooms or the kitchen. So first off we got the table right by the kitchen so that was annoying. Server was just ok, seemed uninterested. They would not let us order an appi without ordering our dinner, I can't stand when dinner comes out quickly after the appi is set. So we ordered the Burrata, pepper, prosciutto appi - it was delicious and a large serving. Soon after, our dinners came. I ordered the Shrimp Amalfi which was huge and delicious. My Mom ordered the Shrimp Scampi which was huge and delicious but she found a 3” piece of clear plastic in her dinner !! I showed it to our server who showed it to the manager who came and apologized - couldn't really explain how something like that ended up in her bowl and then DID NOT comp her meal. I think that is absolutely terrible. We weren't asked if we wanted dessert or coffee. So we just asked for the check. Shame because the food was delicious.

Kimberly Chiandusse

This experience was the biggest disappointment in an eatery I have ever had. The service was atrocious. We could not find our server and the bus person told us it was always like that. The food took a ridiculously unacceptable amount of time (45 min for the appetizer) to get to our table and was sub par at best. The calamari was rubbery and obviously not a fresh item. The salad was not fresh looking either with wilted lettuce and old looking vegetables. We didn't even get to the main course because the owner/manager heard us complaining to our server and came to our table, literally picked up a piece of Calamari from our plate, said it was the best Calamari and threw it (yes, I said threw it) onto the dish. He was inappropriately aggressive and very angry, way angrier than he should have been for the situation. A truly horrible experience. The only upside is the owner/manager comped our meals but this was because he wanted us out of his restaurant. I would not recommend this place under any circumstances.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Maggie O'Sullivan

We hosted our daughter’s bridal shower at Fig and Tomato and we couldn’t have been treated better anywhere else. The environment, the staff, the food….. are top notch! We live out of state but Annie made everything seamless. Jody and Annie took care of us all day. I wouldn’t walk, I’d run back to host another event at Fig and Tomato!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari

The food is fantastic! Our service was phenomenal! My only complaint is the bus boys tend to rush. It's nice to rest a bit before finishing your meal, but many times they came over to take our plates. Maybe it's just a personal thing, but it really bothers me when the table is cleared while others are still eating.

TimOLimo

We were a party of 4, we all had ravioli, mushroom ravioli, short rib ravioli and I had a made to order short rib with a pesto sauce. Well one was better than the next. We had salads and it came focaccia bread with pesto dipping sauce. Desserts were chocolate mousse cake, carrot cake, with cream cheese frosting and a toasted coconut topping! All service was steady, not rushed, excellent evening

Elizabeth Trass

This is the second time my family booked an event with Fig & Tomato and it just keeps getting better. My mom and MIL held my baby shower here this past week and it could not have gone better. The food was amazing, the service was outstanding and the private room was a beautiful space to enjoy the party without any onlookers. We had multiple LARGE family style courses that were all equally delicious. They were also ready to cater to two people who had dietary restrictions. There is no question I would suggest this place to anyone looking for an event space or for a great Italian meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erika Fleming

I had my baby shower here a few weeks ago. Food was great and plentiful. My guest all seemed to enjoy themselves and have had nothing but great things to say about the shower. Overall, I was very happy with my experience from the food to the staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Ballante

We had our daughter’s Sprinkle here and it was excellent. Food was delicious! Debbie’s and Annie’s outstanding service gave all an awesome dining experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More

Fig & Tomato Italian European Eatery

100 Park Ave, Hillsdale, NJ 07642
(201) 722-8880