I don’t think I’ve had worse pizza in Hoboken. My boyfriend called to order for pickup and we walked with the pizza 5 minutes tops before eating. The plain pie was ridiculously floppy and so bland. The Sicilian pepperoni slice was so chewy it was hard to eat. The cherry on top was that these two pies cost $78. Ridiculous. Will not be returning.
Food: 1
Lissandra
Over Priced and Over Cooked I was so disappointed. When getting to the crust which usually my fav part i couldnt even eat it because of how burnt it was. Pizza was just not as tasty as you think it would be due to the price. Just save yourself an extra $15 and go to another place in hoboken.
Food: 1
Abigail Houttekier
I wish I could give 0. Service took way too long. Came on a Saturday a little after 3 and there was not many people. Seems like I caught in a good time. Was excited to try for the first time but instead waited over an hour for one classic plain cheese pizza and didn’t get anything. When the table of 10 next to us showed up 30 minutes after us and got pizza first someone finally came by and we asked what was a status update. They totally forgot about us. We ended up leaving because we were starving having to wait over an hour.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Christopher Manning
Service was subpar. Ordered a margarita pizza. Might as well ordered a cheese pizza. No flavor. With the hype I was hoping for much better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Renato Fava
Long wait, nothing special about their pizza
Joseph Fairley (Home Account)
We had the place booked out for a lunch event! First; the staff was amazing! The whole street lost power and the staff did not miss a beat!
Awesome pizza and appetizers! If I was giving it the best out of ten; this is a strong 8.8! (I’m a tough grader; so this is excellent!)
A must-return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer V
Brought our family here who are from out of town to try what used to be our favorite pizza spot. We waited over 90 minutes for our margherita pizza to come out and then another 15 minutes for the pictured pizza to come out. The peppers were freezing cold and clearly placed on top of the pie after it was already cooked. Not sure if they forgot them and then decided to add them on? But when we asked they said they always put the peppers directly from the fridge on top of the pizza. This was never the case before as they were always cooked with the pizza/under the cheese. Anyway, service was horrible on top of the cold pepper pizza. Flavor is there though.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Majid Ramezani
We waited almost an hour for just one pizza and ended up leaving without ever getting it. I can’t comment on the food because we never got to try it, but the service—and especially how they responded when we expressed concern—deserves zero stars.
Instead of apologizing, they told us this was just their “regular process.” This was on a Thursday night. Either they’re seriously understaffed or completely unorganized.
If you're going just to BYOB and sit around, maybe it's fine. But if you’re actually hungry and want a pizza in a reasonable time, this place is a complete waste of time. One of the worst restaurant experiences I’ve had.
Service: 1
Behnoosh Golchinfar
We waited over an hour for a simple pizza — with a 20-month-old child. The staff saw us sitting there with a toddler the entire time and completely ignored us. No updates, no apologies, no basic courtesy. We had to flag someone down multiple times, and even then, nothing happened. When we finally asked to speak to the manager, a waiter casually showed up pretending to be in charge. That alone speaks volumes about how seriously they take customer concerns.
No sense of urgency, no empathy, not even basic hospitality. Dining out with a child is already a challenge — being dismissed and disregarded like this was infuriating.
If you have a family or care about being treated with respect, avoid this place.
Doug Bryson
Pizza was good, not great. Although the pizza is cooked to be well done, about a quarter of the pizza was burned underneath and inedible. For the prices they charge, I definitely expected much more.
I can understand the mixed reviews. But overall we had a pleasant experience. The pizza was good, not great - I’d go high 7s on the portnoy pizza scale. Had the tenth street pizza chicken which I thought was pretty good. Meatballs were tender but lacked flavor (maybe needed more salt). Dined in, and it’s a pretty cool, vibey space. Service resembles more of a pizza shop (which it is) with restaurant prizes. A couple odd things - plastic cups only, and they don’t provide tap water which I can’t remember ever seeing in the states. BYOB though so that’s a plus. Worth a visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Kristen Mancinelli
Their pizza is really great. The space is loud, but I can get past that for good pizza. My main gripe with them is that I asked for a cup of tapwater and they wouldn’t give it to me. I had to ask for the manager and then he came over and told me that they only have hot water running through their tap, and so they cannot give me a cup of water. That’s obviously a lie. It just felt really disrespectful so I got up and left.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Anthony Licata
Ordered only one pie which took around an hour to come out which was extra surprising given that the pie was very very thin. It was way over cooked, which does not pair well with an extremely thin crust as the pizza was like eating crackers. Some slices were inedible because of how over cooked they were. I'm saying this as someone who prefers pizza on the well done side.
Veronica Greydak
Waited an hour for one margarita pie, only for it to come out completely burnt.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Daniel Calderon
Pizza was terrible, shame since this was once a great pizzeria. I don’t know whats worse the pizza or the waiting staff that can’t be bothered. This place needs to clean house and start fresh.
I don’t think I’ve had worse pizza in Hoboken. My boyfriend called to order for pickup and we walked with the pizza 5 minutes tops before eating. The plain pie was ridiculously floppy and so bland. The Sicilian pepperoni slice was so chewy it was hard to eat. The cherry on top was that these two pies cost $78. Ridiculous. Will not be returning.
Food: 1
Over Priced and Over Cooked I was so disappointed. When getting to the crust which usually my fav part i couldnt even eat it because of how burnt it was. Pizza was just not as tasty as you think it would be due to the price. Just save yourself an extra $15 and go to another place in hoboken.
Food: 1
I wish I could give 0. Service took way too long. Came on a Saturday a little after 3 and there was not many people. Seems like I caught in a good time. Was excited to try for the first time but instead waited over an hour for one classic plain cheese pizza and didn’t get anything. When the table of 10 next to us showed up 30 minutes after us and got pizza first someone finally came by and we asked what was a status update. They totally forgot about us. We ended up leaving because we were starving having to wait over an hour.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Service was subpar. Ordered a margarita pizza. Might as well ordered a cheese pizza. No flavor. With the hype I was hoping for much better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Long wait, nothing special about their pizza
We had the place booked out for a lunch event! First; the staff was amazing! The whole street lost power and the staff did not miss a beat!
Awesome pizza and appetizers! If I was giving it the best out of ten; this is a strong 8.8! (I’m a tough grader; so this is excellent!)
A must-return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brought our family here who are from out of town to try what used to be our favorite pizza spot. We waited over 90 minutes for our margherita pizza to come out and then another 15 minutes for the pictured pizza to come out. The peppers were freezing cold and clearly placed on top of the pie after it was already cooked. Not sure if they forgot them and then decided to add them on? But when we asked they said they always put the peppers directly from the fridge on top of the pizza. This was never the case before as they were always cooked with the pizza/under the cheese. Anyway, service was horrible on top of the cold pepper pizza. Flavor is there though.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
We waited almost an hour for just one pizza and ended up leaving without ever getting it. I can’t comment on the food because we never got to try it, but the service—and especially how they responded when we expressed concern—deserves zero stars.
Instead of apologizing, they told us this was just their “regular process.” This was on a Thursday night. Either they’re seriously understaffed or completely unorganized.
If you're going just to BYOB and sit around, maybe it's fine. But if you’re actually hungry and want a pizza in a reasonable time, this place is a complete waste of time. One of the worst restaurant experiences I’ve had.
Service: 1
We waited over an hour for a simple pizza — with a 20-month-old child. The staff saw us sitting there with a toddler the entire time and completely ignored us. No updates, no apologies, no basic courtesy. We had to flag someone down multiple times, and even then, nothing happened. When we finally asked to speak to the manager, a waiter casually showed up pretending to be in charge. That alone speaks volumes about how seriously they take customer concerns.
No sense of urgency, no empathy, not even basic hospitality. Dining out with a child is already a challenge — being dismissed and disregarded like this was infuriating.
If you have a family or care about being treated with respect, avoid this place.
Pizza was good, not great. Although the pizza is cooked to be well done, about a quarter of the pizza was burned underneath and inedible. For the prices they charge, I definitely expected much more.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I can understand the mixed reviews. But overall we had a pleasant experience. The pizza was good, not great - I’d go high 7s on the portnoy pizza scale. Had the tenth street pizza chicken which I thought was pretty good. Meatballs were tender but lacked flavor (maybe needed more salt). Dined in, and it’s a pretty cool, vibey space. Service resembles more of a pizza shop (which it is) with restaurant prizes. A couple odd things - plastic cups only, and they don’t provide tap water which I can’t remember ever seeing in the states. BYOB though so that’s a plus. Worth a visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Their pizza is really great. The space is loud, but I can get past that for good pizza. My main gripe with them is that I asked for a cup of tapwater and they wouldn’t give it to me. I had to ask for the manager and then he came over and told me that they only have hot water running through their tap, and so they cannot give me a cup of water. That’s obviously a lie. It just felt really disrespectful so I got up and left.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Ordered only one pie which took around an hour to come out which was extra surprising given that the pie was very very thin. It was way over cooked, which does not pair well with an extremely thin crust as the pizza was like eating crackers. Some slices were inedible because of how over cooked they were. I'm saying this as someone who prefers pizza on the well done side.
Waited an hour for one margarita pie, only for it to come out completely burnt.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pizza was terrible, shame since this was once a great pizzeria. I don’t know whats worse the pizza or the waiting staff that can’t be bothered. This place needs to clean house and start fresh.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...