Sheepshead Baygels
2095 NJ-35, Holmdel
(732) 706-1266
Customers' Favorites
Pork Roll & Cheese
Breakfast Sandwich
Everything
Specialty Breakfast Sandwiches
Hangover Cure Breakfast Sandwich
Pork roll, bacon, egg, cheese, and hash browns.
The Holmdel Hornet Breakfast Sandwich
Pork roll, egg, cheese, potato, and hot sauce.
The Belly Busta Breakfast Sandwich
Egg, sausage, bacon, pork roll, hash browns, and cheese.
The Ironman Breakfast Sandwich
Egg white, turkey, low fat Swiss, and spinach on a whole wheat wrap.
Da Bada Bing Breakfast Sandwich
Turkey, egg whites, pepper jack cheese, bacon, and hot sauce.
Texas Breakfast Sandwich
Scrambled egg, roast beef, pepper jack, potatoes, and hot sauce.
The Mamma Mia Breakfast Sandwich
Scrambled egg, roasted pepper, tomato, and fresh mozzarella.
Homemade Specialty Cream Cheese Sandwiches
Walnut Raisin
Vegetable
Scallion
Jalapeño Bacon Cheddar
Nova Lox
Home-Made Salads and Spreads
Fresh Nova Lox
1/2 pound. By the pound.
Scallion Cream Cheese
1/2 pound. By the pound.
Vegetable Cream Cheese
1/2 pound. By the pound.
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Nova Lox and Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheeses
Fresh Nova Lox
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese
Macaroni Salad
Potato Salad
Bacon/Jalapeno/Cheddar Cream Cheese
Cole Slaw
Delicious Duos
Sandwich and Cookie
Make the most of your meal - try a delicious duo.
Homemade Salads
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chicken Salad (1 lb)
Tuna Salad (1 lb)
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Egg Salad (1 lb)
White Fish Salad (1 lb)
Egg Salad Sandwich
White Fish Salad Sandwich
Bagels
Plain
French Toast
Everything
Egg
Sesame
Cinnamon Raisin
Salt
Poppy
Pumpernickel
Mini Bagels
Onion
Whole Wheat
Bagel Twists
Bialys
Garlic
On a Bagel
Nutella
Butter
Cream Cheese
Fresh Lox and Cream Cheese
Cream Cheese and Jelly
Butter and Jelly
Peanut Butter and Jelly
Create Your Own Omelette
Create Your Own Omelette
Choose any two toppings.
From the Grill
Potato and Egg
Egg, Meat and Cheese
Hash Browns
Pork Roll and Cheese
Egg and Cheese
BLT
Pork Roll
Egg Breakfast with Choice of Meat
Bacon, sausage, ham, or pork roll.
Egg Whites
Western Omelette
Boar's Head Cold Cuts
Deluxe Ham Cold Cut Sandwich
Deluxe Ham Cold Cut (1 lb)
Honey Maple Turkey Cold Cut Sandwich
Honey Maple Turkey Cold Cut (1 lb)
Ovengold Turkey Cold Cut Sandwich
Cracked Pepper Mill Turkey Cold Cut (1 lb)
American Cheese (1 lb)
Cracked Pepper Mill Turkey Cold Cut Sandwich
Roast Beef Cold Cut Sandwich
Genoa Salami Cold Cut (1 lb)
Roast Beef Cold Cut (1 lb)
Ever Roast Chicken Cold Cut (1 lb)
Pastrami Cold Cut (1 lb)
Maple Glaze Ham Cold Cut (1 lb)
Provolone (1 lb)
Genoa Salami Cold Cut Sandwich
Bologna Cold Cut (1 lb)
Muenster (1 lb)
Buffalo Chicken Cold Cut (1 lb)
Ovengold Ham Cold Cut (1 lb)
Alpine Lace (1 lb)
Maple Glaze Ham Cold Cut Sandwich
EverRoast Chicken Cold Cut Sandwich
Gold Label Switzerland Swiss (1 lb)
Pastrami Cold Cut Sandwich
Cheddar (1 lb)
Fresh Mozzarella (1 lb)
Buffalo Chicken Cold Cut Sandwich
Cappy Turkey Cold Cut (1 lb)
Bologna Cold Cut Sandwich
Sweet Capocollo Cold Cut (1 lb)
Pepperoni Cold Cut (1 lb)
Prosciutto Cold Cut (1 lb)
Sweet Soppressata Cold Cut (1 lb)
Pepper Jack (1 lb)
Prosciutto Cold Cut Sandwich
Pepperoni Cold Cut Sandwich
Hot Soppressata Cold Cut Sandwich
Cappy Ham Cold Cut Sandwich
Sweet Capocollo Cold Cut Sandwich
Hot Soppressata Cold Cut (1 lb)
Sweet Soppressata Cold Cut Sandwich
Beverages
Iced Coffee (24 oz)
Coffee (16 oz)
Tropicana (14 oz)
Snapple
Nesquik
Chocolate milk, strawberry milk, and vanilla milk.
Tropicana (32 oz)
Orange, apple, or cranberry.
Soda (20 oz)
Gatorade (20 oz)
Tropicana OJ (59 oz)
Coffee (20 oz)
Red Bull (12 oz)
Poland Spring (1.5 L)
Coffee (12 oz)
Red Bull (8 oz)
Poland Spring (1 liter)
Poland Spring (24 oz sport)
Poland Spring (16 oz)
Bakery Items
Carrot Cream Cheese Muffin
Home Baked Jumbo Cookies
Chocolate chunk or oatmeal.
Chocolate Chip Muffin
Double Chocolate Chip Muffin
Blueberry Muffin
Crumb Cake
Banana Nut Muffin
Corn Muffin
Black and White Cookie
Cranberry-Orange Muffin
Bran-Apple Muffin
Home Baked Cookies
Chocolate chip or oatmeal.
Photos
+25 photos
+24 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
These are the best bagels outside of Brooklyn! The place has been in business since the '70s and when you try one of bagels you understand why. They have super fresh and really good homemade cream cheese as well as a selection of sandwiches and other goodies. The atmosphere is welcoming and patriotic, and the staff is very friendly and entertaining lol. We love coming here and highly recommend this establishment!
July 2025
A very old timey looking place off the highway, but what a gem! The staff is kind and the parking lot just enough. It is CASH ONLY, but have an ATM inside. The registers are old, but that adds to the personality of the place. The owner was so kind and mindful of my religious restrictions that he washed the grill for me without my requesting it! I highly recommend stopping by for one of the fresh made bagels or a nice egg & cheese on a roll.
May 2025
Small bagels.. ordered a bagel with cream cheese.. BARELY any cream cheese. My husband ordered a Taylor ham and egg.. two thin slices of Taylor ham.. with an OJ 14$ save your money.. take the drive and go to bagel hut or bagel mania
November 2024
You May Also Like
Dunkin' - 2055 NJ-35
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Donuts, Coffee
It's Just Wings - 2105 NJ-35 Suite #101
![]()
Chicken Wings
Chili's Grill & Bar - 2105 NJ-35 Suite #101
![]()
Tex-Mex, American, Bar, Vegetarian