All Star Bagels

665 Bennetts Mills Rd, Jackson
(732) 276-5217

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Crystal Hamilton

Everyone Is Amazing!! Thank you!! My Friday Stop Before My Hike!!

Daniel Giordano

I sat there for 25 minutes waiting for my order I also felt racially profiled sadly

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Vitória Balla

I had a terrible experience at this place and wouldn’t recommend it to anyone. While the first staff member was polite and the food was good, everything else about my visit was awful.

We arrived around 12 PM, and although they close at 1 PM, it took over 10 minutes to prepare two bagels, even though there was only two customers in the store. They got my order wrong and once we started EATING, the girl began mopping the floor and, by 12:20, we were still eating when they turned OFF the lights, although their hours on the door and online say they are open until 1 PM.

This was extremely disrespectful and made the experience unpleasant. I couldn’t even finish my food. I will definitely not be going back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Cori O'Malley

Every time we order from All Star we are missing product. It’s not hard to count bagels going into a bag. Disappointed once again. Won’t be ordering from here anymore.

Food: 2

Service: 1

Anthony Passaretti

Best bagels in jackson. Freindly staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark Butwinski

Server on phone. Possible order but ???

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Riley R

Used to love the bagels until I saw the worker behind the counter use his bare hands to grab my bagel and then use his white towel in his pants/ pocket to wipe the cream cheese off of the knife with the towel he used to wipe the cashier counter prior.

Not clean.

Another good one is that I ordered a bacon egg and cheese to go and there was no cheese…

O1 L

Used to love the bagels until I saw the worker behind the counter use his bare hands to grab my bagel and then use his white towel in his pants/ pocket to wipe the cream cheese off of the knife with the towel he used to wipe the cashier counter prior.

Not clean.

Another good one is that I ordered a bacon egg and cheese to go and there was no cheese…

Chris B

The food is ok its the service! I keep saying I'm not going back but I do and Every. Single. Time. they screw the order up! How hard is it to make pork roll & cheese with ketchup(extra well done pork roll? My wife went in to pick up order & she was waiting well over 25mins for a single sandwich that was called in 15mins prior?‍♂️

People stop giving this place you money!! I'm done!!

Maureen Elizabeth

AMAZING bagels !!! Definitely recommend if you are in this area for nice fresh bagels nice assortment 🤩

Selma Henderson

They have a wide variety of great bagels, great coffee and an outstanding chocolate chunk cookie. They also have bagel sandwiches for breakfast and lunch, but I haven't tried them. I go early in the day before they start running out of bagels.

Parking: Normal for a strip mall, including handicapped.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Half a Dozen Bagels

Boban Tepsic

Love this place. Awesome bagels and service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

J P

18$ for a bacon egg and cheese and bagel with cream cheese with 2 drinks is ridiculous. Will not be back

Angel C

I'm a regular here, and my go-to is the slider. It's a delicious concoction of pork roll, egg, cheese, and a hashbrown. Their coffee is great. There's parking usually unless it's the morning rush on the weekends so get there early so you dont have to wait. Ive tried a few bagels and they are always delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slider

pamela moya

Our favorite place for breakfast on Sundays, the boys are too pure life ??✨ ? 100% recommended!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...