Avery & Jay's Handcrafted Ice Cream

Delicious ice cream

Avery & Jay’s Handcrafted Ice Cream in Liberty Commons is basically a mitzvah and a nisayon in one place. You walk in “just to look,” and two minutes later you’re holding a towering sundae like you just got a shtikel nachas from Shamayim.
First of all, the place is mamash classy—clean, bright, and everything looks fresh and made b’kavod. You can tell they take the “handcrafted” part seriously, not just a nice word they put on the sign. The ice cream is smooth, rich, and legit “wow” from the first bite. And if you’re into Italian ice / soft serve / sundaes / waffles—they’ve got the whole sugya, with plenty of options to make you rethink your entire diet plan.
Now here’s the best part: you start simple—“one scoop, a regular cup.” Then you see toppings. Then you see the sundaes. Then your yetzer hara puts on a bekishe and starts giving you svaros:
“Take whipped cream—It’s basically air.”
“Sprinkles? That’s just simcha.”
“Waffle cone? That’s a kli, not a ta’ava.” 😄
And the staff? Sweet, patient, and helpful, even when you’re standing there like you’re choosing a shidduch: “Is this one more creamy? How’s this one? What’s the difference between these two?” They don’t rush you—very menschlich.
Perfect stop after errands in Liberty Commons, a family outing, or when you just need a quick pick-me-up that turns into a full-on “okay, we’re celebrating something now” moment.
Bottom line: If you’re anywhere near Jackson, do yourself a favor and go. Just don’t tell yourself “I’m only getting a small.” That’s not how this place works. 😉

ENOUGH OF THE DUBAI CHOCOLATE!! ENOUGH WITH THE GASHMIYUS!!

The best Ice Cream in the world! Made by the best people in the world!!!

This place is dangerously amazing!

The best ice cream in nj! Great service! Its a must!

Ordered food on too good to go, showed up at the right time, then come to find the employees have all left 30 minutes early and I never got my food. Waste of time, waste of money.

Staff was uncaring, unmotivated, and uneducated about work ethics. 2 half scoops for a large milkshake. Mostly milk. Not worth the price (over priced portions), Not worth the trip. Don't have any good expectations

Really good (sundae’s!!!)

Literally had the most positive experience I ever had at an ice cream store! Our servers kristyl and Lucero outdid themselves. They were so patient and accommodating! The seating was clean and spacious and a wide variety of flavors that were absolutely delicious!
Most amazing customer service and highly recommend!

I have been in this store and always enjoyed. But I was really disappointed today- I ordered a package from To Good To Go which was promised to be a $21 value, when i picked it up i was given a quart of ices and a half of a cup of ice cream. When i asked the worker how much its worth and she said about $15 but is unauthorized to give me anything more. I feel cheated...

A nice and elegant place to enjoy ice cream with the family. They also make homemade waffles and serve them with ice cream. The ice cream I had was absolutely delicious ( cappuccino and chocolate hazelnut). Thank you Avery&Jay’s Handcrafted ice Cream Family.

I got the Lotus Sundae. Very yummy! 😋

Frappuccino was great

We went to watch the other kinderlach eat ice cream!

Delicious non-dairy options