We went for the Easter brunch buffet. It was spectacular!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Salvatore Belardo
Good pizza last time out for dinner service wasn't up to par, but overall top notch spot also some of the best round slice bread i have had since Colonial bakery in the burg.
therese stella
We were a party of 11 for the Easter brunch at 10 a.m. (in 2024). We had a wonderful time. From the first greeting by the host/hostess, to the servers, and the buffet workers, to the good bye ~ everyone we dealt with was pleasant and professional.The food selection was varied, delicious, plentiful, and temperature appropriate. Matt, our server, kept on top of monitoring our drinks; mimosas, coffee, soda etc., empty plates were taken away and not thank you for making our Easter brunch a wonderful family gathering left on our table for very long.We could not have been more pleased to come to Amalfi's, our first visit, but definitely not our last.The ONLY negative was it was a bit chilly in the room.I'm sure for the next seating it was a little warmer.Highly recommend Amalfi's. We thank them all fees for making our family gathering a wonderful memory.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Ansaldo
Jersey's cozy spot,Classic pasta, friendly smiles,A taste of Amalfi.
I live out of state and this is a must visit restaurant every time I visit my family. The food is delicious, the service is top notch, and the atmosphere is just what every family needs for a great night out!There has not been a time in the last 5 years that we have not come to Amalfis for dinner every time I visit! Love this restaurant, always look forward to eating here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Roman Caesar Salad, Vodka Rigatoni, Chicken Tartufo, Salad, Appetizers, Personal, Lobster Ravioli, Main, Truffle Fries
Karl M.
This establishment has many advantages. good food , lots of space, amazing bar service from Jess. BUT. the wait staff....too young, too green , too inexperienced. Michael for example, Matt, totally indifferent.
Vince S.
This one got by me.... We brought my uncle here Memorial Day weekend last year, and I've got the photos to prove it. We chose this restaurant based on a local who felt they had improved a lot from years ago. I may have been here before but the fog of time does not allow me to recall. But a few months removed I do recall a very nice experience the 4 of us had. We sat outside on a warm spring Saturday and enjoyed well prepared if not well served fare. We chalked the poor service up to the holiday weekend, but even so, business was slow so it really could have been better. But when not in a hurry, these things can be overlooked occasionally. I had to try a pie, the personal size Margherita with garlic was perfect. Crispy crust that held steady when hoisted. robust sauce and plenty of fresh mozzarella. My cousins both got huge entree salads that looked great, fog again here..., and my uncle a pasta dish that he enjoyed and had 2 more meals from. I finished with my fav chicken sand of the year. Very good brioche roll, nicely fried chicken breast with well thought out toppings and very good fries. We all agreed that we would come back, and the person who recommended this has been and to similar good experiences. I had just recommended this to a coworker when I noticed that I forgot to post a review last year. I hear there is music on the weekends too, sadly NOT byob though. Even so, I'll return...
Angie Casciano
Always a great time while at Amalfis!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Mahon DeCavalcante
I absolutely love the bolognese at amalfis.. its even better if you ask for it over rigatoni or penne. Pear & Prosciutto salad is another fan fave.. on a more casual note the Fig n Pig never disappoints. FYI you can enjoy some amazing wings even if you are gluten free! Hosted a birthday party in the back that everyone enjoyed. This really is a great family run business and I swear the service gets better by the day! Highly recommend for date night or a casual night out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Amalfi Wedding Soup
Jackie B
As always, dinner was delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Roman Caesar Salad, Vodka Rigatoni, Brooklyn Pizza, Amalfi Wedding Soup, Lobster Ravioli
We live nearby and go to Almalfis often. On Friday we took friends for their first visit. They loved the food! Service is always the best! We are lucky to have Almalfis in our town!
Christopher Kranz
I have lunch here about once a month and the food is very good. I can recommend the personal pizzas, sandwiches, and salads. Bring your appetite as the portions are generous. Lastly, if you don't want to pay a credit card fee, bring cash.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Kathleen R.
Unfortunately after years of ordering from this establishment and going in to eat, including going here for special events and for other meals, I need to stop giving my business to this restaurant. I’ve had a few food execution issues with takeout that I’ve ordered through GrubHub over the last few months. My family had a few issues on 12/26/23. On one occasion in the last few months I ordered calamari that was completely inedible. I still continue to order from them because I figured that when I came in person next that I could address the issue that I had. Even though there had been more than one occasion that there was an issue with the takeout, I only addressed the one with the calamari. I showed a picture of the calamari that proves that it was so overdone that you could not even chew it. I asked to speak to a manager and I truly believe that they would make right on it even my giving us a soup or doing something. The manager despite seeing that the order was clearly from Amalfi‘s from the Grubhub receipt and the photo from the same day tried to tell me that this calamari did not even look like it was from his restaurant. He also tried to say that there are occasions where people complain about food and it wasn’t even from the restaurant. He said who knows where Grubhub gets the food from and if it was really from them. He literally did nothing to offer anything when we had come there and spent several hundred dollars and I’ve spent several hundred dollars or more in the last few years that I have been a customer. I can’t even understand his response to me when obviously there are situations when people make mistakes and believe they order from them but to say that GrubHub would somehow go to a different restaurant and that this food was not from this restaurant it’s just really bizarre and defies logic. I have thought about this for a few weeks because this happened on December 26 and ultimately his experience is such that I won’t be returning. It is not the first issue that I’ve had and I have let all the other ones go. I had a girlfriend who had an issue with them and also stopped going to this restaurant some years back. I really do think the food is generally very good but the lack of accountability and customer service leaves me unwilling to continue being a customer of theirs. It’s truly a shame. Giving us a five dollar soup and apologizing would’ve solve this issue for me instead of insulting my intelligence by making a claim that is just completely ridiculous and doing nothing to make it right.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
LKPA
Great food and service for our table of nine. Table was immediately available at time of reservation. Lots of food and beverage choices, creative dishes and all prepared with excellent quality. Service was attentive and anticipated needs. Great all around.
We went for the Easter brunch buffet. It was spectacular!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza last time out for dinner service wasn't up to par, but overall top notch spot also some of the best round slice bread i have had since Colonial bakery in the burg.
We were a party of 11 for the Easter brunch at 10 a.m. (in 2024). We had a wonderful time. From the first greeting by the host/hostess, to the servers, and the buffet workers, to the good bye ~ everyone we dealt with was pleasant and professional.The food selection was varied, delicious, plentiful, and temperature appropriate. Matt, our server, kept on top of monitoring our drinks; mimosas, coffee, soda etc., empty plates were taken away and not thank you for making our Easter brunch a wonderful family gathering left on our table for very long.We could not have been more pleased to come to Amalfi's, our first visit, but definitely not our last.The ONLY negative was it was a bit chilly in the room.I'm sure for the next seating it was a little warmer.Highly recommend Amalfi's. We thank them all fees for making our family gathering a wonderful memory.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jersey's cozy spot,Classic pasta, friendly smiles,A taste of Amalfi.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vodka Rigatoni, Salad, Appetizers, Calamari, Stuffed Salmon Polenta, Lobster Ravioli, Chicken Wings, Fried Chicken Sandwich, Mushroom Gnocchi, Traditional Pizza, Truffle Fries
I live out of state and this is a must visit restaurant every time I visit my family. The food is delicious, the service is top notch, and the atmosphere is just what every family needs for a great night out!There has not been a time in the last 5 years that we have not come to Amalfis for dinner every time I visit! Love this restaurant, always look forward to eating here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Roman Caesar Salad, Vodka Rigatoni, Chicken Tartufo, Salad, Appetizers, Personal, Lobster Ravioli, Main, Truffle Fries
This establishment has many advantages. good food , lots of space, amazing bar service from Jess. BUT. the wait staff....too young, too green , too inexperienced. Michael for example, Matt, totally indifferent.
This one got by me.... We brought my uncle here Memorial Day weekend last year, and I've got the photos to prove it. We chose this restaurant based on a local who felt they had improved a lot from years ago. I may have been here before but the fog of time does not allow me to recall. But a few months removed I do recall a very nice experience the 4 of us had. We sat outside on a warm spring Saturday and enjoyed well prepared if not well served fare. We chalked the poor service up to the holiday weekend, but even so, business was slow so it really could have been better. But when not in a hurry, these things can be overlooked occasionally. I had to try a pie, the personal size Margherita with garlic was perfect. Crispy crust that held steady when hoisted. robust sauce and plenty of fresh mozzarella. My cousins both got huge entree salads that looked great, fog again here..., and my uncle a pasta dish that he enjoyed and had 2 more meals from. I finished with my fav chicken sand of the year. Very good brioche roll, nicely fried chicken breast with well thought out toppings and very good fries. We all agreed that we would come back, and the person who recommended this has been and to similar good experiences. I had just recommended this to a coworker when I noticed that I forgot to post a review last year. I hear there is music on the weekends too, sadly NOT byob though. Even so, I'll return...
Always a great time while at Amalfis!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I absolutely love the bolognese at amalfis.. its even better if you ask for it over rigatoni or penne. Pear & Prosciutto salad is another fan fave.. on a more casual note the Fig n Pig never disappoints. FYI you can enjoy some amazing wings even if you are gluten free! Hosted a birthday party in the back that everyone enjoyed. This really is a great family run business and I swear the service gets better by the day! Highly recommend for date night or a casual night out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Amalfi Wedding Soup
As always, dinner was delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Roman Caesar Salad, Vodka Rigatoni, Brooklyn Pizza, Amalfi Wedding Soup, Lobster Ravioli
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food, great service, very nice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vodka Rigatoni, Calamari
We live nearby and go to Almalfis often. On Friday we took friends for their first visit. They loved the food! Service is always the best! We are lucky to have Almalfis in our town!
I have lunch here about once a month and the food is very good. I can recommend the personal pizzas, sandwiches, and salads. Bring your appetite as the portions are generous. Lastly, if you don't want to pay a credit card fee, bring cash.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Unfortunately after years of ordering from this establishment and going in to eat, including going here for special events and for other meals, I need to stop giving my business to this restaurant. I’ve had a few food execution issues with takeout that I’ve ordered through GrubHub over the last few months. My family had a few issues on 12/26/23. On one occasion in the last few months I ordered calamari that was completely inedible. I still continue to order from them because I figured that when I came in person next that I could address the issue that I had. Even though there had been more than one occasion that there was an issue with the takeout, I only addressed the one with the calamari. I showed a picture of the calamari that proves that it was so overdone that you could not even chew it. I asked to speak to a manager and I truly believe that they would make right on it even my giving us a soup or doing something. The manager despite seeing that the order was clearly from Amalfi‘s from the Grubhub receipt and the photo from the same day tried to tell me that this calamari did not even look like it was from his restaurant. He also tried to say that there are occasions where people complain about food and it wasn’t even from the restaurant. He said who knows where Grubhub gets the food from and if it was really from them. He literally did nothing to offer anything when we had come there and spent several hundred dollars and I’ve spent several hundred dollars or more in the last few years that I have been a customer. I can’t even understand his response to me when obviously there are situations when people make mistakes and believe they order from them but to say that GrubHub would somehow go to a different restaurant and that this food was not from this restaurant it’s just really bizarre and defies logic. I have thought about this for a few weeks because this happened on December 26 and ultimately his experience is such that I won’t be returning. It is not the first issue that I’ve had and I have let all the other ones go. I had a girlfriend who had an issue with them and also stopped going to this restaurant some years back. I really do think the food is generally very good but the lack of accountability and customer service leaves me unwilling to continue being a customer of theirs. It’s truly a shame. Giving us a five dollar soup and apologizing would’ve solve this issue for me instead of insulting my intelligence by making a claim that is just completely ridiculous and doing nothing to make it right.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Great food and service for our table of nine. Table was immediately available at time of reservation. Lots of food and beverage choices, creative dishes and all prepared with excellent quality. Service was attentive and anticipated needs. Great all around.