I have only ever tried their gluten and dairy free cookies, but they are amazing the chocolate ones are okay tbh. But the almond horns (I get the dipped in chocolate ones) and the peanutbutter ones are amazing. I can only imagine the rest of their cookies being incredible if these are amazing with the dietary restrictions implemented. Also the own is so nice, welcoming and friendly everytime you go in!
Steve McLaughlin
Very friendly and helpful! Excellent cookies!
Susan Ennis
I ordered cookies from Cookie Maven for my daughter’s Baby Sprinkle this past weekend and they were so amazing! The guests loved both the sprinkled (confetti) and chocolate chip cookies so much and wanted to know where I got them. So happy I didn’t opt for buying less costly cookies somewhere else since they were well worth the money. Please support local small business and treat yourself to delicious cookies at Cookie Maven 😊
Dan H
My favorites are the Almond Horn, Apricot Almond Thumbprint, and the Cranberry Orange Shortbread. But, you honestly can’t wrong with any cookie you pick!
Chris Wheeler
Excellent cookies. Great assortment. The Cranberry Orange Shortbreads are amazing. My wife said their Pecan Sandies are the best she's had. Ginger Molasses and Oatmeal are also excellent.
Christine Szemborski
Great cookies and great service. Very easy to work with for pre-orders.
Michael Michael
Another 5 star review! Wow are these cookies good. Lady and Gentlemen behind the counter were wonderful also. Skip places like Crumbl and hit up Cookie Maven the next time you want something sweet.
Crystal Holcli
****Edited*** happened to be picking up dinner next door right as they were closing tonight. Instead of a sigh due to a late customer , I was greeted by Gerry, a lovely woman with a bright smile! Not sure if she is the owner but she was kind enough to share that everything is homemade and done so in house. My husband and I got a few different cookies to try and they were super delicious! Quite a few GF options were available as well if that’s more up your alley! Would highly recommend.
ash
Delicious, soft cookies at a very reasonable price and great customer service! You can’t ask for anything better in a business!
Connor Mcgeary
This was so good my mom said this was the best crumb cake she’s had!
Oh my goodness these cookies are AMAZING! Right next to a local great taco joint, top off with a sweet treat! Alice was so friendly and bubbly we will definitely be back thanks to her!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Craig MacFarlane Jr
This place is something else, brought to a party and everyone raved about these cookies. As someone who travels for work and tries many places, I am seriously impressed, Great work! Word of advice is get there early as they sell out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bob Priester
Never been there either
Sarah Flynn
The best cookie I’ve ever had! Tried their confetti cookie at a craft fair and immediately ordered two dozen for my daughter’s birthday party. They were a huge hit! Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth Bond
If you're like me, a very serious cookie connoisseur, you're always on the search for others who care about what they put into their concoctions. Look no further thank Cookie Maven!!! Toby, married to Mrs. Maven herself, greeted us while folding boxes for such a wide variety, I was at a loss for our 12... fully admitting to Toby we'd have to return before we leave in 4 days... so you can take your *way too sweet and grotesquely packaged mass produced cookie-wanabees... I am sticking with the Maven and Toby!!!
Dietary restrictions: They have GF options that are as good if not better than those with gluten... who knew?!?!
Kid-friendliness: Charming little spot, kids will love coming for a treat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Giant Cookies 3 Pack, Classic Cookies 12 Pack, Specialty Cookies 12 Pack, Lemon Bars with Shortbread Crust, Gluten-Free Cookies 6 Pack, Specialty Cookies 6 Pack
I have only ever tried their gluten and dairy free cookies, but they are amazing the chocolate ones are okay tbh. But the almond horns (I get the dipped in chocolate ones) and the peanutbutter ones are amazing. I can only imagine the rest of their cookies being incredible if these are amazing with the dietary restrictions implemented. Also the own is so nice, welcoming and friendly everytime you go in!
Very friendly and helpful! Excellent cookies!
I ordered cookies from Cookie Maven for my daughter’s Baby Sprinkle this past weekend and they were so amazing! The guests loved both the sprinkled (confetti) and chocolate chip cookies so much and wanted to know where I got them. So happy I didn’t opt for buying less costly cookies somewhere else since they were well worth the money. Please support local small business and treat yourself to delicious cookies at Cookie Maven 😊
My favorites are the Almond Horn, Apricot Almond Thumbprint, and the Cranberry Orange Shortbread. But, you honestly can’t wrong with any cookie you pick!
Excellent cookies. Great assortment. The Cranberry Orange Shortbreads are amazing. My wife said their Pecan Sandies are the best she's had. Ginger Molasses and Oatmeal are also excellent.
Great cookies and great service. Very easy to work with for pre-orders.
Another 5 star review! Wow are these cookies good. Lady and Gentlemen behind the counter were wonderful also. Skip places like Crumbl and hit up Cookie Maven the next time you want something sweet.
****Edited***
happened to be picking up dinner next door right as they were closing tonight. Instead of a sigh due to a late customer , I was greeted by Gerry, a lovely woman with a bright smile! Not sure if she is the owner but she was kind enough to share that everything is homemade and done so in house. My husband and I got a few different cookies to try and they were super delicious! Quite a few GF options were available as well if that’s more up your alley! Would highly recommend.
Delicious, soft cookies at a very reasonable price and great customer service! You can’t ask for anything better in a business!
This was so good my mom said this was the best crumb cake she’s had!
Restaurantji Recommends
Oh my goodness these cookies are AMAZING! Right next to a local great taco joint, top off with a sweet treat! Alice was so friendly and bubbly we will definitely be back thanks to her!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is something else, brought to a party and everyone raved about these cookies. As someone who travels for work and tries many places, I am seriously impressed, Great work! Word of advice is get there early as they sell out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Never been there either
The best cookie I’ve ever had! Tried their confetti cookie at a craft fair and immediately ordered two dozen for my daughter’s birthday party. They were a huge hit! Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you're like me, a very serious cookie connoisseur, you're always on the search for others who care about what they put into their concoctions.
Look no further thank Cookie Maven!!!
Toby, married to Mrs. Maven herself, greeted us while folding boxes for such a wide variety, I was at a loss for our 12... fully admitting to Toby we'd have to return before we leave in 4 days... so you can take your *way too sweet and grotesquely packaged mass produced cookie-wanabees... I am sticking with the Maven and Toby!!!
Dietary restrictions: They have GF options that are as good if not better than those with gluten... who knew?!?!
Kid-friendliness: Charming little spot, kids will love coming for a treat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Giant Cookies 3 Pack, Classic Cookies 12 Pack, Specialty Cookies 12 Pack, Lemon Bars with Shortbread Crust, Gluten-Free Cookies 6 Pack, Specialty Cookies 6 Pack
Loading...