Got a couple plain slices. Crispy on the bottom without burning the cheese. Just the way I like it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
JoeyD
Order the chicken parm sandwich yes it was very reasonable price but they toasted the bread try to hide that it was stale bread could not even eat the bread it was so hard and still very disappointed
Food: 2
Service: 3
peter elz
Great family owned business that doesn't price gouge it's patrons! A hidden Gem.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aidan Russo
They served me bad food, and had the bare minimum decency to refund the bad sandwich. Unfortunately, his service before and after his mistake was terrible, and even the food that wasn’t rancid, still was not good. Counter worker made me wait for him to count his tips out when I first came in and then told me “half the sandwich is gone” when two bites of the sour and disgusting eggplant were missing, and the second bite was only to verify it was inedible. I would have gone back again, as brothers is my local pizza place, but it’s definitely worth going out of my way from now on.
Food: 1
Service: 2
Tracey Kersznowski
My Aunt booked a reception here after my dad's funeral services today. The food was fantastic and service was good. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kimberly S.
I'm never one to complain. I've been ordering from Brother's Pizza for over 20yrs along with everywhere else around here. The past couple of times I've ordered a stromboli from Brothers the dough has been raw. Disgustingly raw. Last night my kids ordered a $25 stromboli, called me and told me they didn't know what was wrong with it but it was nasty so I had to order them food from somewhere else. Another $35. I get home check the stromboli and it was the same thing as the month before when I ordered one. RAW. Brothers had just closed so I couldn't say anything so I took a video of the RAW DOUGH and figured I'd give them a call tonight. I called and got screamed at by THE OWNER for complaining. I was kind and explained the situation, let him know I threw the stromboli out but I had the video to show how RAW the dough was. I am 43yrs old and Italian at that. This man really tried to gas light me like I never ate a stromboli before , he insisted it wasn't RAW (btw the owner, he's also the cook), then he had the nerve to tell me it's supposed to be raw and because it's folded dough it would never be cooked fully through. I've been eating strombolis my whole life, I even make them at home. He would not accept any fault. All I asked for in return for 2 raw strombolis ($50) was a large pie ($13). He screamed at me, refused to do ANYTHING to right his wrong. Refused to let me send him the video to see the raw dough and hung up on me. I am disgusted and appalled. I have money, I'm not trying to get free food. A $13 pie at that?!? To treat and scream at someone who has been a loyal customer since their Cheese steak meat was folded and not chopped ( those who know, know lol) is incredibly disheartening. And considering he refused to look at the video, instead chose to scream and hang up on me I'll let you fine people see it. I will NEVER be ordering ANYTHING from them EVER AGAIN. I think they forget that WE ARE THE ONES WHO KEEP THEM OPEN . So disrespectful. For some reason it won't let me upload the video but anyone curious can hit me up and I'll gladly send it to you. EDIT: Video in comments. And the ambiance is disgusting as well. Decor has basically been the same since I can remember. If I could give a minus 10 instead of a 1 I would!!!!?
Gianna K.
Horrible burnt food, terrible customer service. This wasn't the first time being disappointed. Thought I would give them a second chance. They've lost me as a customer.
Itz. Jules
I really love the pizza it's really
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Jenna Bitow
The best thin crust pizza!!
Crystal Boyer
Has been my go to takeout place as of late until today when I ordered and they took a half hour later then stated would which wouldve been fine if the food had arrived hot and fresh however when receieved the fries were cold and soggy the pizza slices and spaghetti i also ordered were ice cold and only item with any heat to it wasthe sub that was lukewarm, when contacted they insisted they delivered it right as soon as done and was hot and they dont believe me, that being said i will no longer be ordering from here again
So, my girlfriend has been telling me that pizza is different in NJ. I generally enjoy Deep Dish or Chicago style pizza too, which she would tell me does not count as pizza. Well, when we were in NJ, she told me that we had to stop here. I was ready to have a good pizza, but I wasn't ready to be wowed. Well, I was wowed. That pizza did hit differently here. Those tomatoes and that garlic were freaking amazing. Holy cow it was good. So, after the pizza, I ate a ton of humble pie. Eating humble pie while dating a gal from NJ means that I will probably never live it down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Johnny Lyric
Cant understand broken English, go
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Frank m Lopez
Had cheese steak hoagie with hot peppers. ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jo Ann Wilson
We always order and have it delivered. Every single thing we have gotten is delicious! Pizza, wings, pasta, chicken Caesar salad, chicken franchise, I can go on and on. Fantastic food and always delivered quicker than the time they give. The slice app is perfect to order on. I would give more than 5 stars!! Thank you for your amazing food and quick delivery!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zachary Cestaro
The owner was very disrespectful, he told me not to speak Italian but to speak English, he wouldn’t even tell me his name, he was rude and arrogant, and I would not recommend this place by any means necessary whatsoever. I’m an Italian myself, and he was out right rude, I did not appreciate his obnoxious behavior.
Got a couple plain slices. Crispy on the bottom without burning the cheese. Just the way I like it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Order the chicken parm sandwich yes it was very reasonable price but they toasted the bread try to hide that it was stale bread could not even eat the bread it was so hard and still very disappointed
Food: 2
Service: 3
Great family owned business that doesn't price gouge it's patrons! A hidden Gem.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They served me bad food, and had the bare minimum decency to refund the bad sandwich. Unfortunately, his service before and after his mistake was terrible, and even the food that wasn’t rancid, still was not good. Counter worker made me wait for him to count his tips out when I first came in and then told me “half the sandwich is gone” when two bites of the sour and disgusting eggplant were missing, and the second bite was only to verify it was inedible. I would have gone back again, as brothers is my local pizza place, but it’s definitely worth going out of my way from now on.
Food: 1
Service: 2
My Aunt booked a reception here after my dad's funeral services today. The food was fantastic and service was good. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm never one to complain. I've been ordering from Brother's Pizza for over 20yrs along with everywhere else around here. The past couple of times I've ordered a stromboli from Brothers the dough has been raw. Disgustingly raw. Last night my kids ordered a $25 stromboli, called me and told me they didn't know what was wrong with it but it was nasty so I had to order them food from somewhere else. Another $35. I get home check the stromboli and it was the same thing as the month before when I ordered one. RAW. Brothers had just closed so I couldn't say anything so I took a video of the RAW DOUGH and figured I'd give them a call tonight. I called and got screamed at by THE OWNER for complaining. I was kind and explained the situation, let him know I threw the stromboli out but I had the video to show how RAW the dough was. I am 43yrs old and Italian at that. This man really tried to gas light me like I never ate a stromboli before , he insisted it wasn't RAW (btw the owner, he's also the cook), then he had the nerve to tell me it's supposed to be raw and because it's folded dough it would never be cooked fully through. I've been eating strombolis my whole life, I even make them at home. He would not accept any fault. All I asked for in return for 2 raw strombolis ($50) was a large pie ($13). He screamed at me, refused to do ANYTHING to right his wrong. Refused to let me send him the video to see the raw dough and hung up on me. I am disgusted and appalled. I have money, I'm not trying to get free food. A $13 pie at that?!? To treat and scream at someone who has been a loyal customer since their Cheese steak meat was folded and not chopped ( those who know, know lol) is incredibly disheartening. And considering he refused to look at the video, instead chose to scream and hang up on me I'll let you fine people see it. I will NEVER be ordering ANYTHING from them EVER AGAIN. I think they forget that WE ARE THE ONES WHO KEEP THEM OPEN . So disrespectful. For some reason it won't let me upload the video but anyone curious can hit me up and I'll gladly send it to you. EDIT: Video in comments. And the ambiance is disgusting as well. Decor has basically been the same since I can remember. If I could give a minus 10 instead of a 1 I would!!!!?
Horrible burnt food, terrible customer service. This wasn't the first time being disappointed. Thought I would give them a second chance. They've lost me as a customer.
I really love the pizza it's really
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
The best thin crust pizza!!
Has been my go to takeout place as of late until today when I ordered and they took a half hour later then stated would which wouldve been fine if the food had arrived hot and fresh however when receieved the fries were cold and soggy the pizza slices and spaghetti i also ordered were ice cold and only item with any heat to it wasthe sub that was lukewarm, when contacted they insisted they delivered it right as soon as done and was hot and they dont believe me, that being said i will no longer be ordering from here again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
So, my girlfriend has been telling me that pizza is different in NJ. I generally enjoy Deep Dish or Chicago style pizza too, which she would tell me does not count as pizza. Well, when we were in NJ, she told me that we had to stop here. I was ready to have a good pizza, but I wasn't ready to be wowed. Well, I was wowed. That pizza did hit differently here. Those tomatoes and that garlic were freaking amazing. Holy cow it was good. So, after the pizza, I ate a ton of humble pie. Eating humble pie while dating a gal from NJ means that I will probably never live it down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cant understand broken English, go
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Had cheese steak hoagie with hot peppers. ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We always order and have it delivered. Every single thing we have gotten is delicious! Pizza, wings, pasta, chicken Caesar salad, chicken franchise, I can go on and on. Fantastic food and always delivered quicker than the time they give. The slice app is perfect to order on. I would give more than 5 stars!! Thank you for your amazing food and quick delivery!
Food: 5
Service: 5
The owner was very disrespectful, he told me not to speak Italian but to speak English, he wouldn’t even tell me his name, he was rude and arrogant, and I would not recommend this place by any means necessary whatsoever. I’m an Italian myself, and he was out right rude, I did not appreciate his obnoxious behavior.
Service: 1