I think you are the best food around!! Always delicious! ? Ordering food for my daughter’s graduation party. I cannot wait to try new things! Really really nice portions prices too! Oops so sorry I give u 5 stars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dee Daponte
we have been eating at an ordering/catering for years! The food is always amazing! The owner John and his staff especially Mike are always so welcoming! Chicken parm and penne vodka are the best! Also, always so charitable catering our sporting events at our local school events!
Louise 0malley
I can't recommend this restaurant enough! The food is absolutely delicious, with generous portions that leave you feeling satisfied. Not only are the prices fair, but the service is incredibly friendly and welcoming.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melissa Mednick
Absolutely delicious. Never disappoints. Great food, great service. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Father Vincent Rumain
It was a diamond hidden in the Michael’s/ Earth Treasures set of stores which I discovered by accident about two years ago. The Brooklyn pizza caught my attention which was a “taste of heaven”. Since then I’ve come to know the owner Johnny who is gracious as well as generous with the high quality portions of food served at both his restaurants not only in Eatontown but also in Little Silver. It gives me great joy to have found a family oriented, friendly place with excellent food reasonably priced. If google allowed I would give 10 stars!Dietary restrictions: Olivia’s offers vegan as well as gluten free.Parking: There is plenty of free parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Marsala, Cannolis, Chicken Parm, Slice of Pizza
Alfonse Saverino
Best pizza in the area...always fresh and hot. Love the pepperoni and honey one. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erica Silvestre
Amazing food! Great pizza & Fresh Salads!! One of the best spots
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe O.
I was craving Italian food tonight and someone recommended Olivia's! I am so glad I took their advice bc my angel hair with meatballs and extra sauce and rigatoni w broccoli rabe and sausage were delicious. My husband and I couldn't choose which we liked better bc they were both delicious. Also tried the pasta fagioli soup and it was also delicious! We will definitely be ordering from there again!!
Brendan Yavoski
Honey Bomb Pizza is 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anna Schneider
Placed an order today & the person did not even know what was on their online menu. She kept asking me to repeat the order. I finally asked her to read me back the order for my office lunch but they still got the order wrong. Very disorganized. Food was OK, not great.
I was a bit conflicted on this one so I think 4 star is probably right in the grand scheme of things. We came in after 8 on a Saturday night to get some take out. We both ordered subs. They had a grilled chicken sub and I asked what was on it. I was told salt and pepper. I asked if I could get it with sauce and cheese on it, basically like a chicken parm without the fry. The person working the counter rang it up with those notes on the order. We sat and waited (for over 20 minutes) for our subs to come out. With only one other family in the restaurant already eating and 2 more folks came in 10 min after we ordered, it was odd that it took that long to get our subs. After leaving and getting back and opening our subs, I was disappointed that my sub had lettuce, tomato and mayo on it, no cheese no pasta sauce. Now that all said, my son's chicken parm sub was great, chicken was tender, subs were enormous and my grilled sub, while not what I wanted was still good, it was just a little annoying that what was on the order isn't what I got, but man...great tasting subs.
AngelxChic (AngelxChic)
Mike was very attentive and friendly! We had the ensalada Italia and honey bomb pizza. Sauce was flavorful, crust crisp and tender, and the combo of pepperoni and honey was a perfect play of sweet, salty with a touch of heat.Atmosphere only gets 3 stars coz it's very casual, your neighborhood pizza joint..
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dorothy Kurzydlowski
This place was my “go to” for take out for years. As of late it has been a constant disappointment. Half the time they deliver the wrong order and when you call, they act like you’re the idiot. I always like to give things another chance, so we ordered tonight & I went with my ole faithful, chicken marsala. What has happened to a dish that was once delicious? Slimy, unseasoned chicken & if there was a drop of Marsala in this dish, one could never tell. The tomato sauce in another dish tasted like a pound of sugar, rather than tomatoes. Very disappointing. Go back to your original recipes and do better. Giving this place 2 stars is coming from a place of kindness.
Food: 2
Service: 1
John I.
Olivia's has the best pizza in Monmouth county and I've had them all. As far a plain pie goes you can't beat it. The secrets out a little though as it gets pretty busy most weekend nights. The penne vodka with chicken and other dishes are banging. -Cleo
Kristen D.
The most solid Italian spot we've found in the area so far! Lasagna and pizza is great!
I think you are the best food around!! Always delicious! ? Ordering food for my daughter’s graduation party. I cannot wait to try new things! Really really nice portions prices too! Oops so sorry I give u 5 stars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
we have been eating at an ordering/catering for years! The food is always amazing! The owner John and his staff especially Mike are always so welcoming! Chicken parm and penne vodka are the best! Also, always so charitable catering our sporting events at our local school events!
I can't recommend this restaurant enough! The food is absolutely delicious, with generous portions that leave you feeling satisfied. Not only are the prices fair, but the service is incredibly friendly and welcoming.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely delicious. Never disappoints. Great food, great service. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was a diamond hidden in the Michael’s/ Earth Treasures set of stores which I discovered by accident about two years ago. The Brooklyn pizza caught my attention which was a “taste of heaven”. Since then I’ve come to know the owner Johnny who is gracious as well as generous with the high quality portions of food served at both his restaurants not only in Eatontown but also in Little Silver. It gives me great joy to have found a family oriented, friendly place with excellent food reasonably priced. If google allowed I would give 10 stars!Dietary restrictions: Olivia’s offers vegan as well as gluten free.Parking: There is plenty of free parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Marsala, Cannolis, Chicken Parm, Slice of Pizza
Best pizza in the area...always fresh and hot. Love the pepperoni and honey one. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food! Great pizza & Fresh Salads!! One of the best spots
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was craving Italian food tonight and someone recommended Olivia's! I am so glad I took their advice bc my angel hair with meatballs and extra sauce and rigatoni w broccoli rabe and sausage were delicious. My husband and I couldn't choose which we liked better bc they were both delicious. Also tried the pasta fagioli soup and it was also delicious! We will definitely be ordering from there again!!
Honey Bomb Pizza is 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Placed an order today & the person did not even know what was on their online menu. She kept asking me to repeat the order. I finally asked her to read me back the order for my office lunch but they still got the order wrong. Very disorganized. Food was OK, not great.
Restaurantji Recommends
I was a bit conflicted on this one so I think 4 star is probably right in the grand scheme of things. We came in after 8 on a Saturday night to get some take out. We both ordered subs. They had a grilled chicken sub and I asked what was on it. I was told salt and pepper. I asked if I could get it with sauce and cheese on it, basically like a chicken parm without the fry. The person working the counter rang it up with those notes on the order. We sat and waited (for over 20 minutes) for our subs to come out. With only one other family in the restaurant already eating and 2 more folks came in 10 min after we ordered, it was odd that it took that long to get our subs. After leaving and getting back and opening our subs, I was disappointed that my sub had lettuce, tomato and mayo on it, no cheese no pasta sauce. Now that all said, my son's chicken parm sub was great, chicken was tender, subs were enormous and my grilled sub, while not what I wanted was still good, it was just a little annoying that what was on the order isn't what I got, but man...great tasting subs.
Mike was very attentive and friendly! We had the ensalada Italia and honey bomb pizza. Sauce was flavorful, crust crisp and tender, and the combo of pepperoni and honey was a perfect play of sweet, salty with a touch of heat.Atmosphere only gets 3 stars coz it's very casual, your neighborhood pizza joint..
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place was my “go to” for take out for years. As of late it has been a constant disappointment. Half the time they deliver the wrong order and when you call, they act like you’re the idiot. I always like to give things another chance, so we ordered tonight & I went with my ole faithful, chicken marsala. What has happened to a dish that was once delicious? Slimy, unseasoned chicken & if there was a drop of Marsala in this dish, one could never tell. The tomato sauce in another dish tasted like a pound of sugar, rather than tomatoes. Very disappointing. Go back to your original recipes and do better. Giving this place 2 stars is coming from a place of kindness.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Olivia's has the best pizza in Monmouth county and I've had them all. As far a plain pie goes you can't beat it. The secrets out a little though as it gets pretty busy most weekend nights. The penne vodka with chicken and other dishes are banging. -Cleo
The most solid Italian spot we've found in the area so far! Lasagna and pizza is great!