Our family absolutely LOVES the food here! We order from Supreme at least 2-3 times a month! We frequently order their pasta dishes but opted for Tomato Pie today ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme Pizza, Garlic Knots, Spaghetti with Meatballs, Meatballs
william gross
Food was good but a bit pricey.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Roz H
I always order from Supreme. Don't know what happened today. Pizza was cold. Thick crust was not what I ordered. The pizza had a bad taste to it like the ingredients were old or not fresh. Won't order from them again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Catherine Sharp
Pizza is fantastic Food and prices are excellent. Service is great and extremely friendly. Highly suggestKid-friendliness: Great menu for kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak
Christian and Juliann Ruppenthal
Not sure why the low stars on Yelp. I was reluctant to try based on the low rating but a neighbor recommended to me and I’m glad they did. BEST WINGS - so tasty and always hot. We get the Mild and they are excellent. We also love the Pizza Twisters! Prices are fair and the staff is always friendly! Definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christian R.
Not sure why the low stars here. I was reluctant to try based on the low rating but a neighbor recommended to me and I'm glad they did. BEST WINGS - so tasty and always hot. We get the Mild and they are excellent. We also love the Pizza Twisters! Prices are fair and the staff is always friendly! Definitely recommend.
Ron Filipkowski
Order was wrong, pizza , wings, fries are not at all good. Cheesesteak had a hair. Waste of money, will never order from this place. Would give 0 if I could.Will not give another try, called owner about refund, owner did not care and refused any refund. Avoid this resturant!
Matthew Schleig
I’ve been ordering from Supreme since we moved to Lumberton 4 years ago. The delivery speed is unmatched and the food is always great. They have some of the best wings I’ve ever had.
Jeffrey Vee
Did not give recite, sent wrong size soda, cheese was totally off the pizza and pizza was under cooked. Worst experience ever o do not suggest this place to anyone
Mike Corelli
Hands down best pizza in New Jersey just moved here from ny taste just like home great staff great service
That was the best darn pizza I've had in forever! The sauce was out of this world and all the toppings were right on spot just as I ordered them. The delivery was lightning quick... Marinara on the spaghetti was excellent! I don't know where all these people put bad reviews on here for Supreme Pizza, but let me tell you something... This was my first time ordering with them and I'm going to always use them from now on!
Chris Roy
All the toppings slid over to one half of the pizza in delivery but it didn't really matter because the pizza was disgusting. Got a works and despite the amount of toppings it was flavorless. 2 stars because the mozzarella sticks were ok. Probably the worst pizza I've ever had in Jersey.
Jenn Gooding
Just found hair in the nachos ? Third time ordering. Wings are great. Pizza and cheesesteaks are not. ??
K S
Great food - the wings especially are phenomenal. Great service. They are kind, fast, and friendly.
Ilene S.
We have been ordering from supreme for years and have enjoyed the quality of food. However recently our orders are coming back wrong and the staff are rude and offer no apologizes or discount. The quality has also been going down hill and the prices have skyrocketed. We will not be ordering from them again.
Our family absolutely LOVES the food here! We order from Supreme at least 2-3 times a month! We frequently order their pasta dishes but opted for Tomato Pie today ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Supreme Pizza, Garlic Knots, Spaghetti with Meatballs, Meatballs
Food was good but a bit pricey.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
I always order from Supreme. Don't know what happened today. Pizza was cold. Thick crust was not what I ordered. The pizza had a bad taste to it like the ingredients were old or not fresh. Won't order from them again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pizza is fantastic Food and prices are excellent. Service is great and extremely friendly. Highly suggestKid-friendliness: Great menu for kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak
Not sure why the low stars on Yelp. I was reluctant to try based on the low rating but a neighbor recommended to me and I’m glad they did. BEST WINGS - so tasty and always hot. We get the Mild and they are excellent. We also love the Pizza Twisters! Prices are fair and the staff is always friendly! Definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not sure why the low stars here. I was reluctant to try based on the low rating but a neighbor recommended to me and I'm glad they did. BEST WINGS - so tasty and always hot. We get the Mild and they are excellent. We also love the Pizza Twisters! Prices are fair and the staff is always friendly! Definitely recommend.
Order was wrong, pizza , wings, fries are not at all good. Cheesesteak had a hair. Waste of money, will never order from this place. Would give 0 if I could.Will not give another try, called owner about refund, owner did not care and refused any refund. Avoid this resturant!
I’ve been ordering from Supreme since we moved to Lumberton 4 years ago. The delivery speed is unmatched and the food is always great. They have some of the best wings I’ve ever had.
Did not give recite, sent wrong size soda, cheese was totally off the pizza and pizza was under cooked. Worst experience ever o do not suggest this place to anyone
Hands down best pizza in New Jersey just moved here from ny taste just like home great staff great service
Restaurantji Recommends
That was the best darn pizza I've had in forever! The sauce was out of this world and all the toppings were right on spot just as I ordered them. The delivery was lightning quick... Marinara on the spaghetti was excellent! I don't know where all these people put bad reviews on here for Supreme Pizza, but let me tell you something... This was my first time ordering with them and I'm going to always use them from now on!
All the toppings slid over to one half of the pizza in delivery but it didn't really matter because the pizza was disgusting. Got a works and despite the amount of toppings it was flavorless. 2 stars because the mozzarella sticks were ok. Probably the worst pizza I've ever had in Jersey.
Just found hair in the nachos ? Third time ordering. Wings are great. Pizza and cheesesteaks are not. ??
Great food - the wings especially are phenomenal. Great service. They are kind, fast, and friendly.
We have been ordering from supreme for years and have enjoyed the quality of food. However recently our orders are coming back wrong and the staff are rude and offer no apologizes or discount. The quality has also been going down hill and the prices have skyrocketed. We will not be ordering from them again.