Gencarellis Of Lyndhurst

552 New York Ave, Lyndhurst
(201) 672-0104

Recent Reviews

Rachel Freites

Wonderful service from the staff and delicious food. ? recommended ??.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari, Pasta Combo, Chicken Parmigiana, Slice of Pizza, Plain Pizza Slice

Liane O.

Food was very good. The portions are large! Waitresses have been doing it a long time very attentive. They know what they're doing and will make suggestions if asked. Nothing fancy but a local hidden gem.

Marcos Hernandez

I went for pizza I enjoyed

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

G K

Pickup service is very slow always??????????

Kristin Brown

Ordered via Uber Eats. One of four dishes was incorrect. Agree with other reviewer, food was OK. Added grilled chicken onto ziti with vodka sauce. Grilled chicken was just dumped on top and the vodka sauce was too thick (not creamy) to be able to mix the chicken in, so I wound up eating dry grilled chicken (which was not great quality chicken either - it had that "woody" texture and I had to throw a few pieces away). The mozzarella sticks had too much batter and the side marinara sauce was very watery. The spaghetti with clam sauce had real clams but sadly I ordered red sauce and we were erroneously given white wine sauce (which I don't eat). The marinara sauce on the pasta combo was again, same as the dipping sauce for the mozzarella sticks, very watery & the entre itself was one dish with different noodles in three sections covered in burnt cheese. Not what I envisioned. So disappointed. Will not be ordering again. To be honest, we have been having a really hard time finding a good Italian food restaurant. Maybe it's because we are Italian and grew up with good Italian meals?

Food: 3

Juan Carlos Rodriguez

Ordered through slice app. Ordered a “pie with half pepperoni “ I get there and the pie looks like it’s in a box for 2 slices. I confirmed the order and the girl said I ordered a personal. If I wanted the regular pie I should’ve ordered the xtra large pie. this mini personal was 15 dollars plus 3 dollars for pepperoni on half. I know it’s tough out there but that’s crazy. If I wanted the regular Xtra large it’s 7.00 dollars more. I don’t mind paying over for good food but that’s insane and much better pizza out there . Either price gouging or manipulation so you order more… either way, terrible experience

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Paige S.

Hands down the best Italian food in we have ever had. Staff was engaging and kind. Great food at a great price. If we didn't live 16 hours away we would eat here every week.

Derek Gaters

Ordered chicken parm with spaghetti, chicken parm wasn't good but the spaghetti and sauce was great. Waitress wasn't nice and had a dry approach, won't say racist but I didn't feel welcome and I won't be back. Really

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

MScott Karsanbas

I ordered one of the most beautiful hand carved large Buffalo + classic white ricotta mozzarella garlic, thin crust well crispy crunchy PIE , OUT OFFF THE WORLDInclude pizza counter and dining employees, thank you, Well donethank youParking: Comfortable

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Pizza Slice

Jacqueli Concepcion

Always good the Philly cheesesteak is amazing a must have

Joe Tomaszewski

Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari, Chicken Parmigiana

Betty B

Love this placeUpdate 10/2023. I used to love this place during the last year or so I have been disappointed. Asked to hold when I called to order,phone left on the counter for 20 minutes.I would say in the last year my order was incorrect in some way 70% of the time. Don't know what's happened and hope it gets back to what it once waa.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

MONIQUE C

Great service & really good pizza! It’s rare to find people who are interested in interacting with their customers these days! My family and I were comfortable asking questions while ordering and were guided to get the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Plain Cheese Pizza

Antonio Lopez

Amazing food and portions are Mega satisfactory. Mo CONTENDERS PERIOD.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JOYCE YAMASAKI

The food here is absolutely delicious. The dinners are

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More