Polkadot Cake Shop

137 Stuyvesant Ave, Lyndhurst
(551) 333-3195

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lindsay Ryder

I just ordered about 8 dozens cupcakes for my son's first birthday in varying flavors and they were incredible! It was very easy to work with Arlene and figure out what we wanted to move forward with, and they even offer delivery. I was really happy with the entire process, and even happier with how they turned out. 10/10!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zeke Perez

Arlene was wonderful to work with. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake

Jillian Priaulx

I reached out to Polkadot Cake Shop to create a surprise groom's cake for my husband on our wedding day. I was recommend to use them for this special idea I had, and I could not be happier that I did!

I enlisted them for a Jurassic Park themed cake (my husband's favorite film) and I sent them an extremelyyy rough sketch of how I envisioned the cake. They took what I sent/provided them in terms of dino props and created a masterpiece. I couldn't believe how amazing it looked! My husband loved the cake SO much and so did all of our guests.

Highly recommend Polkadot Cake Shop if you're looking for a custom cake!!

Mark Martinelli

Arlene of Polka Dot Cakes designed and made the cake & donuts for our daughter Jaclyn's bridal shower. The communication process with her was great, the cake was both elegant and delicious and the donuts scrumptious. Overall the perfect sweet accent to a perfect day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Podesta

We ordered 40th surprise birthday cookies from Arlene and they were delicious and everyone was raving about them! Thank you!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sonia Hernandez

Ordered by son's birthday party cake and 2-dozen sugar cookies from Polkadot Cake Shop. The cake was fresh and I received many, many compliments especially on the Oreo cream filling. I let the cake sit out at room temp for about 5 hours before serving and it was perfect. My son was very happy. Cake and cookies were relatively expensive but the flavor and communication (all via email) was very good!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cookies

Nicole L

Arlene and her team were such a pleasure to work with. She made our dreams come true and her work is just stunning! The dessert table was the highlight of my party with multiple guests telling me they were the best cupcakes they have ever had. Cannot recommend highly enough and will definitely be using her again in the future! Thank you!! ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stacey Kaplan

Wow best cupcakes ever! We got a bunch for our wedding & they were absolutely delicious & beautiful. There was nobody on the dance floor for 30mins after the cupcakes came out because people could not put them down. Our guests are still raving about them! From start to finish, the ordering & delivery process was seamless & easy. Couldn’t recommend Polkadot any higher!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcake

Heather Matthews

I was initially impressed by the timeliness of Arlenes response to my enquiry and her communication skills. She immediately seemed to grasp my ideas and vision of the cake I had in mind for my husband's retirement party. I sent her photos and an idea of the cake style I had in mind and then I left her to her own creative juices. For this occasion it was important to me that the cake looked classy and not juvenile. Everyone especially my husband, was amazed at the cake! My husband was the star of his retirement party, but Arlene's cake definitely came in a close second. Her attention to detail and the decorations was incredible! Not only did its appearance far exceed my expectations, but it was also delicious ‐ so moist and tasty. I chose the vanilla sponge with raspberry sauce and lemon cream filling. I would highly recommend Polkadot Cake Shop to anyone searching for a unique cake. Thank you again Arlene!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake

Adrienne Sozansky

We worked with Polkadot for our wedding - they brought their trailer to our venue and set up the most beautiful and most delicious dessert service. Highly, highly recommend!

Patrizia Trento

Thank you for providing the most delicious treats for my daughters Sweet 16 dessert table. The kids loved them!! I appreciate that you matched our theme and decor exactly how we wanted it!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Renee Monchak

This cake was an absolute masterpiece!! All three tiers were a different flavor, one even better than the next….my personal favorite was the coconut cake. Planning a wedding is so overwhelming and there are so many decisions to be made. Polkadot Cake Shop was well organized, quick to respond and so easy to work with. Also loved being able to support a business local to me. Thank you so much!!!

Renee Greenemeier

This cake was an absolute masterpiece!! All three tiers were a different flavor, one even better than the next….my personal favorite was the coconut cake. Planning a wedding is so overwhelming and there are so many decisions to be made. Polkadot Cake Shop was well organized, quick to respond and so easy to work with. Also loved being able to support a business local to me. Thank you so much!!!

Adrienne S

We worked with Polkadot for our wedding - they brought their trailer to our venue and set up the most beautiful and most delicious dessert service. Highly, highly recommend!

Jacqueline Gibney

Highly recommend! I had a great experience working with Polkadot Cake Shop. They were extremely professional, the cake came out beautifully and was very very tasty!

Loading...