San Carlo
620 Stuyvesant Ave, Lyndhurst
(201) 933-3400
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
The food was mediocre at best. I have been going to this place my whole life but things have changed.
I would like to express my heartfelt thanks to Jodi and her wonderful team for hosting an unforgettable celebration for my family. Everything was truly spectacular—beautifully organized, with incredible food, and outstanding bar and waitstaff service. I didn’t have to worry about a thing and was able to simply enjoy my daughter’s graduation.
Thank you so much for everything. I can’t wait for the next opportunity to work with you again! I highly recommend this venue for any special occasion. They offer multiple rooms, and the food is consistently excellent.
Once again, thank you for making my daughter’s graduation such a memorable and special moment.
I went to a 95th birthday celebration at the San Carlos restaurant. The food was terrific, the staff was attentive, and our DJ was lively. Our room had large dance floor and the seating and table were quite comfortable. It’s a wonderful venue for your next affair.
The place is beautiful well kept. Servers are very pleasant and Food looks delicious. My only thing is ...if you are a decorator ,you will only have 90minutes To set up and less than 30 minutes to breakdown. They will rush you out . So take it in consideration when booking and planning, because you will need extra hand to do it quickly. So charge accordingly for that extra help to do your decoration set up/breakdown.
The place needs a lot of TLC it's a little outdated and under maintained
Went for a repass luncheon food delicious
Beautiful gorgeous great environment
I recently hosted my daughter's first birthday party here and was very pleased with the food and service. The staff were amazing—friendly, attentive, and accommodating to all our needs both during setup and throughout the event. They truly impressed me with their dedication and professionalism. The food was top-tier, and the beverage selection, which included beer, wine, and sangria, was perfect for the adult guests.
However, I’m giving this venue three stars due to my experience with the Banquet Manager, Jodi Guzzardo. As someone with nearly 20 years in the hospitality industry, I found her behavior to be shockingly rude and unprofessional. When my mother-in-law and aunt visited the space for a scheduled appointment, she was dismissive and unhelpful toward them. During the event, her attitude continued to be an issue; she was disrespectful to the service staff and disregarded customer feedback, even contradicting me when I communicated specific requests through the staff because I preferred not to deal with her directly.
The overall experience was overshadowed by her demeanor, which is unfortunate given the quality of the food and the efforts of the service team.
Last night I was at an event at San Carlo and I can’t thank enough the staff for their amazing and professional approach. Very knowledgeable, great vibe, willing to help and overcome challenges in the most professional manner. Thank you Olga and Angela for being the most fantastic hosts.
Jodi, the Banquest Manager is easy to work with. Our 60th Class Reunion was a great success. All enjoyed the excellent food and professional staff. Would definitely recommend if you are considering an event.
Restaurantji Recommends
Awesome food , great staff
Great food, well done .
Every occasion I came to San Carlos was pleasant and the food was always good! This had been this way for over 35 years that I’ve been coming
Lousy experience,one star negative ..stay away
Had my baby shower here & it was great! Delicious food and plenty of space. Staff was kind and attentive, as well.
Loading...