My coworker and I come in multiple times a week, food and service is always on point. Nina the bartender is fantastic, remembers our full orders by heart, and is genuine great energy always. Will happily be coming consistently moving forward. Great Restaurant all around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anna Fish
Place was packed. In the middle of our dinner for 2, the manager Lawrence, instead of the water, gave us a check saying that there's a 1,5 hours limit for dinner. That was unpleasant news, nobody gave us a time frame when we booked a table.
Kevin Ryan
Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janey Romeo
Apps were better than entrees
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Stefania Cuppari
The ambiance is phenomenal and the food is great! The drinks are amazing and the service is very good. The coconut cosmo is to die for! The owners are so humble and personable. I love supporting businesses like this! Highly recommend 😊
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aurimas
Great place. Well decorated,nice seating,not too close to other people. Calamari and crab cakes were great and priced out accordingly.we will be back for sure.
shaina
This was our first time eating dinner here in many years and the place looks amazing. We were a little worried when we saw how busy it was but the service was top notch. Our waiter and the staff were very friendly and attentive. We will definitely be back!
Michael Blasi
Place is seriously crowded and loud. Granted this was a Friday night. Started with the French Onion soup and the basket of bread. The French onion soup was very cheesy and flavorful. Unfortunately I was tasting it all night. The basket of bread was odd, as most places give you bread, paying 6 dollars was a shock. The bigger shock was it was all the same bread. Caraway seed and Raisins must be an acquired taste, but a taste I could never acquire. I had the Wagyu burger and my partner had the Steak Friter. I ordered my burger medium and she her steak medium well. The burger came back rare and the steak could have been revived with a defibrillator. Waitress was ultra cool and brought two new plates Burger still not cooked properly but at least edible. Very flavorful burger but tje pretzel bun was very filling so my dogs had wagyu for dinner. Second attempt on the steak was medium not medium well but again edible and flavorful. The server was professional, polite and accommodating. The bus boys are hovering over my table like a vulture . Trying to grab dishes and a beer before completed. The atmosphere was modern and tasteful. But again very loud and tables are closer to each other than I would like. Overall, eventually tasteful food, but a bit overpriced for what you get. Might try it again, but nothing I would be looking to do soon.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Heather
My friend and I went here for dinner Saturday night..I liked the set up of the place especially the bar area. It looked like a good spot to go for a sporting event. We ordered our dinner and my friend ordered a medium well burger. When she took a bite out of it the burger was so pink. She told our waitress who agreed that wasn't the way she asked for it to be cooked so she took it back to the kitchen. It took quite awhile for them to cook it to medium well that I nearly finished my dinner before she got her burger. We thought maybe our waitress would offer some sort of compensation like a free drink, dessert or knock something off the bill but that wasn't the case. Besides that glitch everything else was good.. I would try this place again.
Cynthia
I was generally disappointed with the lack of flavor/seasoning in the dishes that were ordered by my group. The ribs and pineapple rice were under seasoned. The same can be said for the crab cakes and wild rice. I would ditch the rice and offer potatoes. The chicken pot pie lacked flavor and the pieces of chicken were inconsistently cut..some very large pieces with shredded chicken. It could have used more cream sauce. Two people ordered medium hamburgers and received well done. Nice place but the food was not great.
The restaurant was extremely crowded, and the service was slow and not very attentive! Maybe they did not have enough people to work that night. The bottle of wine I ordered was way too warm; it seems as though they do not regulate their wines in a refrigerator that is made for wine. I observed about 3 managers that night, and not one visited any tables to see if everything was okay. Even after I told the waitress to tell the manager about the wine! That to me is key for a well run restaturant!
Wendy
Fabulous night! The food was amazing, table ready when we arrived on a busy Friday night. Our server was the perfect level of attentive, all employees were pleasant. We will definitely be back.
Doris J Crotty
Feb. 2025 Olde Silver Tavern is a very nice place. The place has an abundance of pleasant staff. The guest will be very well serviced. The food is good and the serving size is very large and fresh. The prices are reasonable especially with that kind of service. The have a lovely fireplace which gives to the atmosphere. The decor is inviting and refreshing. The parking plentiful with several handicapped spots. Yet, the restaurant itself is not wheelchair friendly. To get into the restaurant there are 2 minor steps. Would definitely go back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Helena Hagen
Stopped in for dinner and had a wonderful time. Great experience overall. Food was great and our waitress Brianna was wonderful. She greeted us with a smile and was especially attentive, friendly, and made sure we had everything we needed. Will definitely be returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John
Went to Olde Silver Tavern first time on Thursday. Went back the following weekend and brought friends with us. Loved everything about it. Can't wait to go back!
My coworker and I come in multiple times a week, food and service is always on point. Nina the bartender is fantastic, remembers our full orders by heart, and is genuine great energy always. Will happily be coming consistently moving forward. Great Restaurant all around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Place was packed. In the middle of our dinner for 2, the manager Lawrence, instead of the water, gave us a check saying that there's a 1,5 hours limit for dinner. That was unpleasant news, nobody gave us a time frame when we booked a table.
Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Apps were better than entrees
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
The ambiance is phenomenal and the food is great! The drinks are amazing and the service is very good. The coconut cosmo is to die for! The owners are so humble and personable. I love supporting businesses like this! Highly recommend 😊
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place. Well decorated,nice seating,not too close to other people. Calamari and crab cakes were great and priced out accordingly.we will be back for sure.
This was our first time eating dinner here in many years and the place looks amazing. We were a little worried when we saw how busy it was but the service was top notch. Our waiter and the staff were very friendly and attentive. We will definitely be back!
Place is seriously crowded and loud. Granted this was a Friday night.
Started with the French Onion soup and the basket of bread. The French onion soup was very cheesy and flavorful.
Unfortunately I was tasting it all night.
The basket of bread was odd, as most places give you bread, paying 6 dollars was a shock. The bigger shock was it was all the same bread. Caraway seed and Raisins must be an acquired taste, but a taste I could never acquire.
I had the Wagyu burger and my partner had the Steak Friter. I ordered my burger medium and she her steak medium well.
The burger came back rare and the steak could have been revived with a defibrillator.
Waitress was ultra cool and brought two new plates
Burger still not cooked properly but at least edible. Very flavorful burger but tje pretzel bun was very filling so my dogs had wagyu for dinner.
Second attempt on the steak was medium not medium well but again edible and flavorful.
The server was professional, polite and accommodating. The bus boys are hovering over my table like a vulture . Trying to grab dishes and a beer before completed.
The atmosphere was modern and tasteful.
But again very loud and tables are closer to each other than I would like.
Overall, eventually tasteful food, but a bit overpriced for what you get.
Might try it again, but nothing I would be looking to do soon.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
My friend and I went here for dinner Saturday night..I liked the set up of the place especially the bar area. It looked like a good spot to go for a sporting event. We ordered our dinner and my friend ordered a medium well burger. When she took a bite out of it the burger was so pink. She told our waitress who agreed that wasn't the way she asked for it to be cooked so she took it back to the kitchen. It took quite awhile for them to cook it to medium well that I nearly finished my dinner before she got her burger. We thought maybe our waitress would offer some sort of compensation like a free drink, dessert or knock something off the bill but that wasn't the case. Besides that glitch everything else was good.. I would try this place again.
I was generally disappointed with the lack of flavor/seasoning in the dishes that were ordered by my group. The ribs and pineapple rice were under seasoned. The same can be said for the crab cakes and wild rice. I would ditch the rice and offer potatoes. The chicken pot pie lacked flavor and the pieces of chicken were inconsistently cut..some very large pieces with shredded chicken. It could have used more cream sauce. Two people ordered medium hamburgers and received well done. Nice place but the food was not great.
Restaurantji Recommends
The restaurant was extremely crowded, and the service was slow and not very attentive! Maybe they did not have enough people to work that night. The bottle of wine I ordered was way too warm; it seems as though they do not regulate their wines in a refrigerator that is made for wine. I observed about 3 managers that night, and not one visited any tables to see if everything was okay. Even after I told the waitress to tell the manager about the wine! That to me is key for a well run restaturant!
Fabulous night! The food was amazing, table ready when we arrived on a busy Friday night. Our server was the perfect level of attentive, all employees were pleasant. We will definitely be back.
Feb. 2025
Olde Silver Tavern is a very nice place.
The place has an abundance of pleasant staff. The guest will be very well serviced.
The food is good and the serving size is very large and fresh.
The prices are reasonable especially with that kind of service.
The have a lovely fireplace which gives to the atmosphere. The decor is inviting and refreshing.
The parking plentiful with several handicapped spots. Yet, the restaurant itself is not wheelchair friendly. To get into the restaurant there are 2 minor steps.
Would definitely go back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Stopped in for dinner and had a wonderful time. Great experience overall. Food was great and our waitress Brianna was wonderful. She greeted us with a smile and was especially attentive, friendly, and made sure we had everything we needed. Will definitely be returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went to Olde Silver Tavern first time on Thursday. Went back the following weekend and brought friends with us. Loved everything about it. Can't wait to go back!
Loading...