Olde Silver Tavern

149 Freehold Rd, Manalapan
(732) 430-2424

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Agnes Fitzpatrick

Just brought 2 friends there for lunch. My friend and I both had the seafood omelet with fruit and it was outstanding! My other friend had the chicken sandwich and loved that, too. Taylor was our waitress and said she would advise the chef of how much we liked the whole brunch!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eddie Correa

It is a great place for partying watching some football and just having some good old drinks. The food is very good and I love disco night.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie, Grilled Chicken, Chocolate Mousse, Lobster Rolls, Ost Gochujang BBQ Wings, Cherry Pepper Calamari, Onion Rings, Truffle Chicken Dinner, French Onion Soup, Homemade Chips & Dip, Cheesecake, Truffle Fries, French Onion, Prosciutto Pie, Peaches and Cream Pizza, Turkey Club, Shrimp Cocktail, Kung Pao Cauliflower, Margherita Pizza, Chef Elvis' Fried Chicken

Sharon Mechlowitz

I love the transformation. beautiful place.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 4

Norma Mcewan

amazing food, service, ambiance and esthetic !! Definitely becoming a favorite.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thomas Ferullo

Recently went for our first time and everything was really good. Our server Brendan was very fast and helpful.

Will be coming back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nader Boctor

Great sport bar and restaurant

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Giacomo Scuderi

One of the best restaurants in the USA, I discovered it thanks to the advice of friends who are expert travelers and passionate about food and wine. Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paul R.

The service was terrible one watress for a whole section there was large party’s so slow
Food was soso ate there several times was not happy

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 1

Cole Ash

Great happy hour deals at the bar, lots of food options for vegetarians.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathy

Food was good. Nice menu. Ambience beautiful. They did a great job of restoring this old tavern. Nice outdoor area. It's a true sports bar. TVs everywhere, but if you want quiet it's not the place to good. Prices were a bit high. Overall they did a great job.

Allison

From the moment you enter this restaurant you see it's got something for everyone. To the left is the bar with ample tvs for the sports enthusiasts and to the right the dining room which was well lit and huge! The server was great and the food as well. We will definitely be back with friends in tow to this fine establishment!!!

Cheryl

Food was good but kind of plain. Soup was good. Steak was not cooked medium rare - more like rare and was tough. Waiter was very nice but very busy. His helpers were very lax in taking plates away. Guess they are understaffed. Miss the old Old Silver Tavern with the really good food and much, much lower prices.

Lisa

We sat close to where the food is coming out and we listened to a door slamming the entire time with servers going in and out of the kitchen. It was extremely annoying. Lots of screaming crying babies too. Food and service were just ok.

Philip

Had another good meal at the Olde Silver Tavern. Our waiter, Kevin, was friendly and attentive. He began by telling us all about the specials. When I placed my cocktail order, he warned me that the drink I wanted had a strong cucumber flavor, so I switched to the Buffalo Trace Boulevardiare which was very good. My wife and I split a full rack of spare ribs. They were meaty and falling off the bone tender. It came with a side of potato salad and corn on the cob. We ordered a side of cole slaw as well and there was more than enough food for two.

Rick

Second time here, first time in the dining room. Good service from Brendan, even when it got busy and he was getting a few more tables in just a few minutes' time. Lobster roll and ribeye steak were perfectly made. My one issue tonight was that when making the reservation I noted it was my wife's birthday- I wasn't expecting anything but this wasn't even acknowledged with a “happy birthday”. Why ask if it's an occasion if you're not going to say anything...? We'll be back.

Loading...