Pete’s Old Fashion Tomato Pies
2919 US-206, Columbus
(609) 267-0166
Customers' Favorites
Large Cheese Pizza
Tomato Pie Petes
Sicilian Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Slice
Petey Pez
Menu
Photos
+37 photos
+36 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
100/100 every single time! Every week while selling as a vendor here at the flea market, I can’t help but grab a pie. Even as I’m leaving the place people stop to ask where I got it because it smells so good. Once you start going you won’t be able to stop! Only pizza I’ve eaten since losing over 100 pounds over a year ago because it’s light, not greasy and not filling to the point where you won’t be able to finish the pie yourself. Best pizza on the planet. They nail...
So so good! ❤️ We take a 35 minute drive to the Columbus Market just for their pizza & red cream soda. We take a look around just cuz we’re there but we are mostly there for the pizza 🤗
I traveled an hour up and back for this pizza . I can’t believe the negative comments. I love this pizza . I think it is delicious. The soft and fluffy Sicilian style dough the sauce is on top and the cheese underneath for all of those saying they have no cheese . I would suggest that you ask for light sauce if you don’t want to much sauce . As far as the service maybe say hi or a smile to people giving you business goes a long way . But the pizza to me is really good .
You May Also Like
Stoltzfus BBQ - 2919 US-206
![]()
Barbecue, Barbeque, Chicken Wings, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly
Kate & Al's Pizza - 2919 US-206 #104
![]()
Pizza, Vegetarian