Captain Obadiah's Seafood Market

Great sea food to eat there or take home. Very fresh and a large selection. Staff was wonderful.

Great food

Usually great, almost always get the shrimp po boy. The last time on Labor Day Weekend 2025 the amount of shrimp was very meager compared to every other time. Still delicious but a bit disappointed in the amount of shrimp in the po boy.

Hands down the worst food we've had in an area not known for good food. Lobster roll was shredded lobster which seemed more likely to be imitation lobster salad on a bun. A far cry from a lobster roll. Ahi tuna steak was two small medallions coated in a smoky orange marinade and though rare, it was tough as if cooked to be well done. We couldn't determine what the issue was but it did not taste like Ahi tuna at all. We assumed it would be good as owned by Deauville & Yesterday's owners. They serve lobster rolls multiple ways at Deauville and they're good. Tuna at Deauville is good. This place was totally horrible.

I am a local. The food quality has gone down hill. Numerous experiences in 2025. Twice shrimp by the pound was not cooked through. The lobster roll was tasteless and somehow… shredded? I’ve eaten lobster rolls from a dozen diff places and never had a shredded bland mess. Crab cakes, 100% shredded. Save yourself a ton of $ and skip this place. It’s beyond disappointing.

We just left - off season Thursday night. Excellent. The guy that was working was so attentive - food perfect! I will definitely be back.

Been going here since Campbell’s closed (20+ years). It was excellent up to this year. Got takeout last night and I could have done better with frozen fish out of a box at Acme. Spent $173.00 for what tasted like $20.00 of microwaved frozen fish. I won’t be back.

Our favorite seafood restaurant in the OCNJ area. Food is always fresh and prepared quickly. Service great. Food is delicious. We love sitting on the deck to eat, especially after a day enjoying the sun.

Great food great service this is our go to spot when we don’t have a reservation anywhere

Amazing food, friendly staff! Perfect spot to stop for a quick bite on our travels

If you like seafood go here. A lot of choices and all we tried were excellent. Take out style with seating on the porch benchs. Very friendly staff.

Great fresh seafood. You cook it at home. But they have some stuff they can cook there.

Delicious food, great low key location and super friendly staff. Lobster bisque is amazing.

Over priced by long shot

I am not a big seafood person but my the rest of my family is. That said the food here is great. I love the chowder, the clams and the crab cake. The lobster roll and just about everything on the menu is really good. This is our go to place for family seafood night