Custard Castle

137 US-9, Marmora
(609) 840-9313

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Eowyn Crowley

Awesome ice cream and awesome service. Love going there every year

Don Ciancarelli

Over priced. Not worth it.

Mark B

If you ever find yourself in the Ocean City or Mamora area and are in the mood for homemade water ice or ice cream, this is the place to go. Their banana ice cream is exceptional, and the staff is incredibly friendly. The owner is also an amazing individual and always available. So, please visit this establishment and support a local business.

Kevin Hansbury

This is a great ice cream place (and I managed an ice cream place in my younger days). Their menu is extensive, they have anything anyone could want. The service is always very friendly, professional and efficient. The owner is very personable and a nice guy. TO ALL OC VACATIONERS: I’ve lived in OC a long time and vacationed here all my life. If you want to take the family for ice cream this is well worth hopping over the 34th street bridge. The prices are SO MUCH more affordable than anywhere on the island. Go to the Custard Castle!

edward hitner

Great Ice Cream & Great Prices
🍦🍧🍨👍👍🇺🇸

Shannon Scarberry

I think it was opening day. It was 4pm on Saturday may 17, and we were the only ones there. There was an older gentleman in there and he was training the young girls that were working. Both girls were pleasant and friendly. My husband ordered a banana split and I ordered the brownie sundea. The soft serve they put in the banana split was melted by the time we got to the table(see photo) , and my husband said it had a funny taste. As for a banana split, it was missing the pineapple, choc syrup, and chopped nuts toppings. I asked for peanut butter cup hard scoop. But it was just peanutbutter, no peanut butter cups in it. It was good hard scoop ice cream. There were 3 small brownies in it which were also very tasty and soft. There wasn't any hot fudge in my sundea though, which that was in the brownie sundea description. The price was in line with all the other shore ice cream shops. $20.22 for the 2 sundeas.

Kevin Johnson

Last season this place was king of the hill. Now it’s expensive and cheap. Get a banana split and it has one lil strawberry and one little pineapple. They have to weigh everything and to price doesn’t meet the expectations. Ruins the whole experience. If it’s so tight to make a buck that you have to charge inflated prices and you get so much less. What’s the point. Ben and Jerry’s don’t hurt your eye looking for the goodies in it. I love supporting my local businesses but this is out of hand. Hyper Tourist Prices and under whelming products. So disappointing.

Daven Henry

#Snacks

Nicole Dalrymple

Good ice cream. Freshly made. Excellent service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

B G

Nothing special here. Machine was broken for the flavor I wanted. Expensive comparing other local places. Asked for a certain topping and received something different.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Bob Herman

Best Ice Cream In Ocean City, NJ!!! Only 2 mins from OCNJ, this place makes their own homemade ice cream. It's truly unbelievably delicious!! The Best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dean Foulks

GET THE CRUNCHCOAT
This doesn't exist above NJ's Mason Dixon line. It's amazing. The ice cream is delicious and well made. The people are friendly and helpful. But the crunchcoat!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Death by Chocolate

Emilia Minhondo

I enjoy supporting local businesses and this is one of my favorites. The service was great and quick. They had so many delicious ice cream flavors, it was hard to choose just one. We ended up going twice in one weekend. Great place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwich, Coffee Toffee

Antonietta Renteria

Best ice cream in town!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salted Caramel

Marc Drabkoski

I just love this place. Even though I just whipped a U turn through the lot. Apologies, I didn’t realize you were open, not that it makes it ok. Won’t happen again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mint Chocolate Chip, Salted Caramel

Loading...