Custard Castle

137 US-9, Marmora
(609) 390-4432

Recent Reviews

Heather Clerico

10/10 love this place.

Allen Carter

Great ice Cream and good prices.

Sandi Cornatzer

Not the best custard I ever had, small for a high price. The man that was waiting on us was less then friendly, a bit condescending. Won't go there again!

Mindy Lucas

Friendly people. Very small portions for the price. Small sundae for $6. It was more like a baby cup.

Robyn George

Nice selection and they even had a doggie sundae for our pups. Vanilla soft serve and two biscuits. Dogs and parents were very happy.

Ed S.

Have been coming here for years. First with our kids and now with our grandkids. Owner is one of the nicest people I have ever met! Great service and great products. Five stars for sure!!!

Tom Dintaman

Custard Castle had a nice outdoor seating area and large selection of water ice, soft serve, and hand dipped ice cream. got a gelati. One positive remark of others with me is the faint smell of disinfectant from their windows. they keep the place clean. offer drive through service too.

74christinam

Arrived right before closing and who, I believe was the owner was more than happy to serve us with a smile. Ice cream was excellent!

Keira Mac

Me and my boyfriend found this place and rlly liked it. So I took my little brother. I was craving peanut butter ice cream and was so happy to see they had it. Asked if we could try it and they said no. So I got it anyway. Was absolutely nasty. Tasted nothing like peanut butter. Let my mom try it w/o telling her what it was and she had no clue what it was. And my mom is obsessed with peanut butter. My little brother got the orange flavor. She said it tasted like the orange on the board walk. Tasted nothing like that. The comparison was insulting to the board walk ice cream ? definitely won’t be coming back.

Al Crowley

Tasty soft serve ice cream and home made water ice. Highly recommend the water ice. Staff is very friendly.

SJT Tripoli

This is my go to place. Love the hard ice cream which is homemade.

Jessica Baldini

Been coming here ever since I was a little girl. I remember being so little I always had to come here with my parents/grandparents whenever we were on vacation, but now I’m married and now my husband and I come here together whenever we’re in the area! The ice cream is delicious, the owner is always so friendly. I hope this place is here forever because I would love to bring my future kids here!! So nostalgic for me.

Malissa B.

Great milkshakes & excellent service. Walk up or use the convenient drive thru. Perfect ending to a hot day!

Brian M.

This place effs hard. The drive thru is clutch as eff ! Definitely hit this place up ! I go all the time it's great! The peeps are cool peoples and the ice cream is great. They do hard and soft shizz !

Sherry B

The Chocolate & Vanilla Swirl in a Waffle Cone was AMAZING!!!!The gentleman that waited on us was so nice. We will be back!

Load More