By FAR the best pizza around.Well worth an extra drive to pick up from here!And from what I understand they also deliver.Me and my wife moved to this area when our NYC lease ended as we felt safer here from covid. When I first got here I started trying a few pizza places that neighbors recommended to me.I was very disappointed at how bad the pizza has been around here. Everything from very chewy dough I barely could cut with a steak knife, to extremely dirty ovens creating a layer of charred flower dust coating under the pizza making it taste and feel like eating the type of charcoal I use for my grill. Very unpleasant.What truly boggles my mind is how no one mentionedthis beautiful place called – BELLA NONNA!Wow, what an experience. They are always very pleasant on the phone and as I get there the kitchen is clean and tidy and they have plenty of pizzas by the slice on display.Now to the pizza. The crust around the edges is fluffy and has a very nice crunch to it that you easily break apart with your fingers. The pizza is very well made and generously layered with beautiful small pepperonis that has cupped perfectly in the oven, still holding small pools of delicious pizza juices. The tomato sauce has definitely some effort put in to it. In some bites you stumble upon a fresh herb that is a nice break of flavor.The pizza crust is what really stands this one out as the best pizza I’ve tried in NJ.I am now eating pizza a couple of times a week and I urge everyone to get their pizza from here.I will recommend it to everyone.5/5.See you soon Bella Nonna!
Mike S Smith
Really good pizza and friendly staff..the owner Peter answers the phone a lot and is very friendly and willing to make your food the way you want it.
Tina Forcino
This is the second time we ordered from here. First time was a Sicilian (square) pie which was on point. Second was two chicken dishes; chicken parm and grilled chicken topped with spinach, mushrooms and mozz. Delicious. The place is very clean and the people are nice. Highly recommend.
Larry Salvador
I was passing thru and stopped for a quick slice and it was very good! Would definitely come back if I pass thru the area again.
Rushini Jayawardena
Had a BBQ chicken slice-Great flavor, and crust! Antonio was friendly and took his time in telling us about all the different slices they had toOffer. Definitely recommend them!
Boris Shkuta
Tried several different slices and they were all really good - the Buffalo chicken stood out but even just the plain slice was exceptional. It also helped that the gentlemen helping us was extremely nice and helpful. Overall great experience and looking forward to this becoming a go-to pizza spot in the area!
Paige Caragliano
Best pizza in Matawan! Great staff, everyone is friendly:) The food tastes like it’s coming straight out of Brooklyn! The buffalo chicken slice is to die for.
Andrew
Best pizza in the area!! Friendly staff, quality food, and if you want great food stop by here
Doug Ward
Stopped here on Friday night after work.The staff was very friendly & patient. Took me a few minutes to decide. I ordered the grilled chicken w/ mozzarella and broccoli, very good ?. I also grabbed a granny slice also very good ?. Definitely worth a look, you won't regret it ?.
Heather Maloney
What a wonderful experience!!! Fabulous employees, delicious food, reasonable prices and wide variety!!! Highly recommend the desserts-chocolate covered canolli and zeppolis. Our family ordered pizza- half meatball/half plain, garlic knots, dinners-pasta with broccoli, garlic and oil, penne vodka & rigatoni marinara that came with side salad. Thousand Island dressing, one of many choices, was scrumptious! My oldest daughter absolutely loved her cheese calzone. My son wants his birthday party here. They treated him like he was a part of the family. He is only 7 and loved the entire experience here. He stood on the side and was able to watch the chef prepare his pizza. Overall, perfect evening!
Excellent food, nice people, & cleanMeatballs, Rice balls & pizza all very good ? ?? ?
anthony santos
I’ve had better pizza from Shoprite.I wouldn’t recommend this place to anybody.
Tarik P
Great service and good is delicious. So by and enjoy some good eating.
Michael Thives
Born and raised Brooklyn NY and for the first time in my life I can say New Jersey FINALLY has pizza that tastes like it came from Brooklyn!! The fresh ingredients and tasty sauce are phenomenal but the magic really happens in the crust. Absolutely the tastiest pizza in the area and we have tried them all!! And 1 Bite of those ZEPPOLI’s and you will feel just like a kid again, hands down the best in NJ
Jillian Napoletano
My fiancé and I have ordered from here a few times. The regular pizza is SO GOOD! Ordered the tortellini carbonara tonight, it was delicious! The drivers are always friendly and the food arrives hot and fresh. Overall, a really great place! (Photo is of the margherita pizza)
By FAR the best pizza around.Well worth an extra drive to pick up from here!And from what I understand they also deliver.Me and my wife moved to this area when our NYC lease ended as we felt safer here from covid. When I first got here I started trying a few pizza places that neighbors recommended to me.I was very disappointed at how bad the pizza has been around here. Everything from very chewy dough I barely could cut with a steak knife, to extremely dirty ovens creating a layer of charred flower dust coating under the pizza making it taste and feel like eating the type of charcoal I use for my grill. Very unpleasant.What truly boggles my mind is how no one mentionedthis beautiful place called – BELLA NONNA!Wow, what an experience. They are always very pleasant on the phone and as I get there the kitchen is clean and tidy and they have plenty of pizzas by the slice on display.Now to the pizza. The crust around the edges is fluffy and has a very nice crunch to it that you easily break apart with your fingers. The pizza is very well made and generously layered with beautiful small pepperonis that has cupped perfectly in the oven, still holding small pools of delicious pizza juices. The tomato sauce has definitely some effort put in to it. In some bites you stumble upon a fresh herb that is a nice break of flavor.The pizza crust is what really stands this one out as the best pizza I’ve tried in NJ.I am now eating pizza a couple of times a week and I urge everyone to get their pizza from here.I will recommend it to everyone.5/5.See you soon Bella Nonna!
Really good pizza and friendly staff..the owner Peter answers the phone a lot and is very friendly and willing to make your food the way you want it.
This is the second time we ordered from here. First time was a Sicilian (square) pie which was on point. Second was two chicken dishes; chicken parm and grilled chicken topped with spinach, mushrooms and mozz. Delicious. The place is very clean and the people are nice. Highly recommend.
I was passing thru and stopped for a quick slice and it was very good! Would definitely come back if I pass thru the area again.
Had a BBQ chicken slice-Great flavor, and crust! Antonio was friendly and took his time in telling us about all the different slices they had toOffer. Definitely recommend them!
Tried several different slices and they were all really good - the Buffalo chicken stood out but even just the plain slice was exceptional. It also helped that the gentlemen helping us was extremely nice and helpful. Overall great experience and looking forward to this becoming a go-to pizza spot in the area!
Best pizza in Matawan! Great staff, everyone is friendly:) The food tastes like it’s coming straight out of Brooklyn! The buffalo chicken slice is to die for.
Best pizza in the area!! Friendly staff, quality food, and if you want great food stop by here
Stopped here on Friday night after work.The staff was very friendly & patient. Took me a few minutes to decide. I ordered the grilled chicken w/ mozzarella and broccoli, very good ?. I also grabbed a granny slice also very good ?. Definitely worth a look, you won't regret it ?.
What a wonderful experience!!! Fabulous employees, delicious food, reasonable prices and wide variety!!! Highly recommend the desserts-chocolate covered canolli and zeppolis. Our family ordered pizza- half meatball/half plain, garlic knots, dinners-pasta with broccoli, garlic and oil, penne vodka & rigatoni marinara that came with side salad. Thousand Island dressing, one of many choices, was scrumptious! My oldest daughter absolutely loved her cheese calzone. My son wants his birthday party here. They treated him like he was a part of the family. He is only 7 and loved the entire experience here. He stood on the side and was able to watch the chef prepare his pizza. Overall, perfect evening!
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent food, nice people, & cleanMeatballs, Rice balls & pizza all very good ? ?? ?
I’ve had better pizza from Shoprite.I wouldn’t recommend this place to anybody.
Great service and good is delicious. So by and enjoy some good eating.
Born and raised Brooklyn NY and for the first time in my life I can say New Jersey FINALLY has pizza that tastes like it came from Brooklyn!! The fresh ingredients and tasty sauce are phenomenal but the magic really happens in the crust. Absolutely the tastiest pizza in the area and we have tried them all!! And 1 Bite of those ZEPPOLI’s and you will feel just like a kid again, hands down the best in NJ
My fiancé and I have ordered from here a few times. The regular pizza is SO GOOD! Ordered the tortellini carbonara tonight, it was delicious! The drivers are always friendly and the food arrives hot and fresh. Overall, a really great place! (Photo is of the margherita pizza)
Loading...