Benedetta's Pizza & Restaurant

39 Mill Rd, Matawan
(732) 970-8300

Recent Reviews

Mitchell Nelson

It is now called Bella Noona. We had a veggie pie and Sicilian Pie...both out of this world! New owner Peter takes pride in all the food and personally makes sure everything is to your liking!

daryac2021

We love their pizza, especially the white pies! Everything is freshly made. We stick with the pizza here. The service is quick and friendly. Give them a try!

Peter Cafaro

Bella nonna is great food I s amazing

Lara Coates

Great place to relax and have a night out with friends.So cool place.

heidi dame

The pizza here is really good! Nice and crunchy crust but doesn't fall apart.

Chris Quartararo

Supurb. Penne Vodka is to die for.

Courtney Godfrey

Always love their food, atmosphere, and attention to the customer.

tara g.

Upon walking in to this pizza place i witnessed a worker carry a cooled pizza with his bare hands NO gloves and slap it on the table to be served. My chicken bruschetta wrap was terrible. No balsamic and no cheese the chicken was rock hard. The Caesar salad had browned lettuce covered with croutons and the dressing was terrible. I will never eat here again.

Gabrielle W.

Just had the worst experience. WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE EVER! Or I should say NONE! Took two hours and 40 minutes to get our food. Originally ordered through grub hub and cancelled it to go pick it up ourselves after 2 hours. Checked on our order 3 different times and each time was "be ready in 15 minutes ". Went to go pick it up was told "15 minutes" meanwhile our food wasn't even put in the oven yet. My husband was inside patiently waiting. My husband asks again and the guy behind the counter tried saying we ordered at a time that we didn't and then said "yea that is a long time to wait,next time order from me directly". Don't promote grub hub then if you don't want people to use it. 40 minutes later my husband comes out with the food. I check the order and notice we are missing a 2L Coke. Husband goes back in and some guy behind the counter was giving everyone an attitude and told him we don't have a 2L take two cans. My husband then tells the lady behind the counter he's taking 4 because that doesn't even equal 2L. She says no problem. The guy behind the counter then proceeds to come outside and starts yelling and raising his voice at my husband. After waiting 2 hours and 40 minutes, the least you can do is spare two cans of soda especially if you don't have what we ordered. The guy is still outside ranting on at my husband,I then myself got of the car to give the food back bc this was pure b******** The lady told me to just keep it because then they'll have to throw it out. I've worked in the restaurant business for 15 years. Never in my life have I ever been treated like this or treated my paying customers this. It was truly embarrassing! We will never order from here again.

Craig Marsh

The spot is great and broad, the food was delightful and the prices were very affordable. fast, productive service and very welcoming staff. Recommended.

Nicholas Urso

This place is my favored. I go to a lot of restaurants but to this place I go the most. The stuff is very friendly and the cooking they offer is so appetizing. I never miss an opportunity to have a nice dinner here. I recommend this place with pleasure.

Taylor L.

This is the second time I have tried to order the Pizza Bianca Sicilian pizza. Both times I have gotten a call stating that they don't have the ingredients which is confusing because it is cheese and pizza dough.....at a pizza place.... either way, if it is never in stock, please just remove it from your menu!

Timothy Touhey

Best pizza on the shore. Chicken Parmesan, white pie, plain pie etc. I have never gotten anything less than perfect. Nestled behind the Carvel in Matawan on rt 34.Don't miss it.

Ellie Q.

I don't have enough nice things to say about Benedettas. The food speaks for itself. It's amazing and flavorful and large portions but more than that is the hospitality. I've always be accommodated and feel so at home wether eating in or delivering. I will NEVER order from anywhere else! My personal favorites are the veal and chicken francese but honestly everything is good!

Colleen K.

I can't say enough. Had 2 speciality pies from them. Cheeseteak and parmigiana which was basically a chic pam pizza. Sooooo good and well run.

Load More

Benedetta's Pizza & Restaurant

39 Mill Rd, Matawan, NJ 07747
(732) 970-8300