Cohoot's

624 Lincoln Boulevard, Middlesex
(732) 469-3455

Recent Reviews

Mark P.

Do not pass this place up! I stopped by for a quick lunch and the good is on point (phenomenal burgers and steak) and the service is outstanding. Will definitely be back with more people

Rebecca A.

Many people rave about the food here... I've always wanted to check it out. The hubby and I brought our kids tonight and I have to say I was not impressed. I typically don't write reviews but our waitress was one of the worst I have ever had. We left a tip because that's just how we are. It took 30 minutes just to get drinks, throughout our meal she never asked if we needed refills, and when we asked her... she never even came back with them. It took another 30 minutes for our waitress to take our order. When the food came out, the crab soup had imitation crab meat, the flavor was good, but the texture not so much. My step-sons hamburger was very dry and the stuffing in my founder was soggy breadcrumbs and onions - no crab meat. I usually don't bring up issues like this either, but happened to notice we were the only Hispanic family in the restaurant. People that came after us got much better service. It could have been a coincidence, but just felt some kind of way. Our waitress wouldn't even look us in our face and she was extremely unfriendly. I could have dealt with the food not being what I expected... but I was very upset with how my family was treated. I would never go back here.

Chuck E.

PSA The restaurant no longer does "take out" orders for their prime rib or steaks... Very disappointing!

barbara

great food, very clean place, fine service. we hit the prime rib special day (lower prices) on wednesday and it was delicious! don't let the outside fool you.

Marvin S.

Heard about this place from a friend so I had to go try it . I ordered two appetizers; Mozzarella sticks and Jalapeño Poppers . Both were good no issues there . For my main course, I ordered the Prime Rib ( King's Cut) which came with a option for a soup or salad. I ended up opting for the salad, which came dresses with hard boiled eggs and baby shrimp. As I go to take a bite though, I noticed that they didn't remove the p*** line from the shrimps which grossed me out a lot. I tried to eat around it but it was no good I just couldn't do it . The Prime Rib though was very tasty . Cooked to my liking. It was a very thick cut of meat which I ended up taking home the sweet potato fries were very good pairing as well. . All and all, the salad was the main thing that turned me off about the place . The service was nice but really couldn't stomach the uncleaned shrimp . (P.S. if anyone gets the salad make sure you check if they cleaned the p*** line on the back )

BRUCE Neely

Wasn't to sure what to expect when we got there. I had heard about it from someone that I work with. It seemed kinda closed. We walked in, and the smell of the lobster tails that someone was eating was out of this world. I had the king cut prime rib that I could not finish there, it was huge, and my wife had the stuffed flounder that had real crab stuffing, the salads came with chopped egg, and shrimp, and were fresh.Try this place for a great meal.

Peter Bednarz

Tried it and liked it...will be back. Service was fast and with a smile. Very happy we stopped by.

Pat O.

Best hamburger in town staff is friendly. Now open 7 days a week great place to catch the game and grab some awesome food

jeff k

Delicious food friendly staff a real home town favorite

Melodie Pellegrino

Under new ownership. They kept alot of what they are known for. Salad with small shrimp and eggs. Service was wonderful and we were a party of 11

Bill Fekete

Must have passed this place a million times and didn't notice it. Went on a recommendation from a friend and wasn't disappointed. Clearly a gem in Middlesex. Food was great and the staff was fast and friendly. Will definitely be on my return list.

bella genova

the food is always amazing and the service is always good. a good place to go that always tastes the same over the years and never disappoints!

Trish Shannon

My brother Tommy told me about this place before he passed away. I was skeptical as from outside it looks just like the neighborhood bar. Nothing fancy on the inside but the people are friendly the place is clean and the food is excellent. I will definately be back.

christina c

Dinner was dry and atmosphere wasn't great. Not impressed for first time. Definitely more of an appetizers and burger spot

Dotty “Dotty”

Nice casual place, bartender is so efficient, making drinks, shucking clams,taking orders,dispensing take out orders , tasty food, enjoyed our meals & other meals going out looked pretty good too

Load More