I have ordered here and stopped in multiple times since opening! I am always beyond impressed by the work they do, especially when they made me custom UGG cookies for my job! Even the in-store product is amazing & the Disney themed items are my favorite. I will continue to order again and again!!! Thanks Michelle & Torre!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcake
Anthony Prentice
Ordered a birthday cake for my 1 yo's birthday party. Went strictly based on the reviews, and was not disappointed. The party was s'mores theme'd, and we were a little nervous with the recommendation on filling with marshmellow and chocolate ganache, if that would be something everyone would like. Well everyone raved about it. The whole thing was amazing and so were the party themed cookies we ordered. Will definitely be back!Kid-friendliness: Fun cookies on display and different cake bars in glass display
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Margaret M.
There is little to say here, other than OUT OF THIS WORLD!!! From the taste of the cake to the design- sheer perfection! I have not had such a delicious cake in a very long time. Torre and Michelle- thank you for making this engagement cake so lovely! My daughter and her fiancé were in love with it! We will be back, and will be highly recommending you to our friends!
Veronica
Michelle and Torre always go above and beyond to exceed my expectations! Each of their creations are tastier than the next! Some of my personal favorite goodies are the chocolate covered marshmallows (being Mickey shaped gives it’s an additional point ?), ganache bites, and of course their royal icing sugar cookies!! Custom designed orders are to be made ahead of time, but all of these treats can be purchased in the store too! They are super accommodating to work with, respond to inquires in record time, and their attention to detail shouldn’t go unnoticed because they hit it out of the park. Every. Single. Time. They make the tastiest goodies for all of my events and their masterpieces are the talk of all parties!
Veronica Shortino
Michelle and Torre always go above and beyond to exceed my expectations! Each of their creations are tastier than the next! Some of my personal favorite goodies are the chocolate covered marshmallows (being Mickey shaped gives it’s an additional point ?), ganache bites, and of course their royal icing sugar cookies!! Custom designed orders are to be made ahead of time, but all of these treats can be purchased in the store too! They are super accommodating to work with, respond to inquires in record time, and their attention to detail shouldn’t go unnoticed because they hit it out of the park. Every. Single. Time. They make the tastiest goodies for all of my events and their masterpieces are the talk of all parties!
Stephanie Romero
Not only are their cookies GORGEOUS, they also taste AMAZING! My family and friends only trust Michelle and Torre to help add that special detail for all our events!
Lori Talarico
Customization and Attention to Detail:Wish Upon a Pastry Shop truly understands the importance of personalization. The engagement party cookies they crafted for a Charleston wedding were a true testament to their skill and attention to detail. Each cookie was meticulously customized to match the theme and aesthetic of the future event. From intricate designs and delicate piping to vibrant colors and precise lettering, the cookies were a work of art that captured the essence of the celebration.
tara apgar
I have ordered from Wish Upon A Pastry a few times and I can honestly say I am never disappointed. Torre and Michelle are extremely accommodating and a pleasure to work with. I recently ordered custom cookies and a custom cake for my daughter's graduation from Saddle Brook High School and acceptance to Sacred Heart University. I wasn't sure what I was looking for and they made recommendations and suggestions and everything came out perfect. Not only did the cookies and cake look amazing, they were delicious. Thank you Torre and Michelle for our amazing desserts.
Natalie Foy
Michelle and Torre are incredibly talented and run the best bakery in the area. I have been in a few times to pick up desserts for various occasions from their display case and it has all been amazing. This past weekend I ordered a custom cake and cupcakes for my daughter’s first birthday and they were not only adorable but so delicious! I just sent them a few pictures of decorations that went along with the theme and they were able to create something even cuter than I had envisioned. They were so easy to work with and extremely responsive throughout the whole process. I can’t wait for our next occasion to order from them!
Matt DePaolera
Torre and Michelle have done my sons baptism and birthday cookies and nailed it every time. The cookies are beautiful and taste amazing. Highly recommend.
Had an absolutely amazing experience with Wish Upon a Pastry, for my sons 3rd birthday. Not only was Michelle responsive and attentive to details, the cake and rice crispy treats came out beautifully, and tasted even better than they looked. My son is obsessed with monster trucks and could not believe how cool his cake was! Honestly for a special occasion it doesn’t get better than Wish Upon, and I cannot wait to use them again.
Alyssa C.
Top to bottom amazing experience with Wish Upon. The customer service was awesome, they were so attentive to detail and prompt at replying and the treats came out so beautifully. My son was so happy to see his favorite monster truck atop his 3rd birthday cake, Wish Upon really helped make our celebration special. And the best part- everything tasted even better than it looked! Will absolutely be using this bakery going forward and cannot recommend enough.
Lisa Ryan
Amazing custom cookies! We worked with Michelle to create a custom design pulling pieces together from a few different photos. She went above and beyond to make them perfect for our day. They were *almost* too beautiful to eat, but thankfully we had a few extra after our event to enjoy and they were delicious! Can’t wait to order again soon.
Lisa L.
Amazing custom cookies! We worked with Michelle to create a custom design pulling pieces together from a few different photos. She went above and beyond to make them perfect for our day. They were *almost* too beautiful to eat, but thankfully we had a few extra after our event to enjoy and they were delicious! Can't wait to order again soon.
I have ordered here and stopped in multiple times since opening! I am always beyond impressed by the work they do, especially when they made me custom UGG cookies for my job! Even the in-store product is amazing & the Disney themed items are my favorite. I will continue to order again and again!!! Thanks Michelle & Torre!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcake
Ordered a birthday cake for my 1 yo's birthday party. Went strictly based on the reviews, and was not disappointed. The party was s'mores theme'd, and we were a little nervous with the recommendation on filling with marshmellow and chocolate ganache, if that would be something everyone would like. Well everyone raved about it. The whole thing was amazing and so were the party themed cookies we ordered. Will definitely be back!Kid-friendliness: Fun cookies on display and different cake bars in glass display
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
There is little to say here, other than OUT OF THIS WORLD!!! From the taste of the cake to the design- sheer perfection! I have not had such a delicious cake in a very long time. Torre and Michelle- thank you for making this engagement cake so lovely! My daughter and her fiancé were in love with it! We will be back, and will be highly recommending you to our friends!
Michelle and Torre always go above and beyond to exceed my expectations! Each of their creations are tastier than the next! Some of my personal favorite goodies are the chocolate covered marshmallows (being Mickey shaped gives it’s an additional point ?), ganache bites, and of course their royal icing sugar cookies!! Custom designed orders are to be made ahead of time, but all of these treats can be purchased in the store too! They are super accommodating to work with, respond to inquires in record time, and their attention to detail shouldn’t go unnoticed because they hit it out of the park. Every. Single. Time. They make the tastiest goodies for all of my events and their masterpieces are the talk of all parties!
Michelle and Torre always go above and beyond to exceed my expectations! Each of their creations are tastier than the next! Some of my personal favorite goodies are the chocolate covered marshmallows (being Mickey shaped gives it’s an additional point ?), ganache bites, and of course their royal icing sugar cookies!! Custom designed orders are to be made ahead of time, but all of these treats can be purchased in the store too! They are super accommodating to work with, respond to inquires in record time, and their attention to detail shouldn’t go unnoticed because they hit it out of the park. Every. Single. Time. They make the tastiest goodies for all of my events and their masterpieces are the talk of all parties!
Not only are their cookies GORGEOUS, they also taste AMAZING! My family and friends only trust Michelle and Torre to help add that special detail for all our events!
Customization and Attention to Detail:Wish Upon a Pastry Shop truly understands the importance of personalization. The engagement party cookies they crafted for a Charleston wedding were a true testament to their skill and attention to detail. Each cookie was meticulously customized to match the theme and aesthetic of the future event. From intricate designs and delicate piping to vibrant colors and precise lettering, the cookies were a work of art that captured the essence of the celebration.
I have ordered from Wish Upon A Pastry a few times and I can honestly say I am never disappointed. Torre and Michelle are extremely accommodating and a pleasure to work with. I recently ordered custom cookies and a custom cake for my daughter's graduation from Saddle Brook High School and acceptance to Sacred Heart University. I wasn't sure what I was looking for and they made recommendations and suggestions and everything came out perfect. Not only did the cookies and cake look amazing, they were delicious. Thank you Torre and Michelle for our amazing desserts.
Michelle and Torre are incredibly talented and run the best bakery in the area. I have been in a few times to pick up desserts for various occasions from their display case and it has all been amazing. This past weekend I ordered a custom cake and cupcakes for my daughter’s first birthday and they were not only adorable but so delicious! I just sent them a few pictures of decorations that went along with the theme and they were able to create something even cuter than I had envisioned. They were so easy to work with and extremely responsive throughout the whole process. I can’t wait for our next occasion to order from them!
Torre and Michelle have done my sons baptism and birthday cookies and nailed it every time. The cookies are beautiful and taste amazing. Highly recommend.
Restaurantji Recommends
Love there stuff. Great people.
Had an absolutely amazing experience with Wish Upon a Pastry, for my sons 3rd birthday. Not only was Michelle responsive and attentive to details, the cake and rice crispy treats came out beautifully, and tasted even better than they looked. My son is obsessed with monster trucks and could not believe how cool his cake was! Honestly for a special occasion it doesn’t get better than Wish Upon, and I cannot wait to use them again.
Top to bottom amazing experience with Wish Upon. The customer service was awesome, they were so attentive to detail and prompt at replying and the treats came out so beautifully. My son was so happy to see his favorite monster truck atop his 3rd birthday cake, Wish Upon really helped make our celebration special. And the best part- everything tasted even better than it looked! Will absolutely be using this bakery going forward and cannot recommend enough.
Amazing custom cookies! We worked with Michelle to create a custom design pulling pieces together from a few different photos. She went above and beyond to make them perfect for our day. They were *almost* too beautiful to eat, but thankfully we had a few extra after our event to enjoy and they were delicious! Can’t wait to order again soon.
Amazing custom cookies! We worked with Michelle to create a custom design pulling pieces together from a few different photos. She went above and beyond to make them perfect for our day. They were *almost* too beautiful to eat, but thankfully we had a few extra after our event to enjoy and they were delicious! Can't wait to order again soon.