Oatmeal cookies and chocolate chip cookies were very yummy. We also got the chocolate chip cookie bar. So happy to have found this place. Will definitely be back!
Robert Tully
Jersey cookie girl. – Delicious & Nut-Free! 🍪
I've been to Jersey Girl Cookie twice now, and both times were a total win. The cookies are absolutely delicious — soft, flavorful, and baked just right. What really makes them stand out for me is that they are tree nut and peanut free, which is a huge deal for anyone with allergies (or loved ones with them).
It’s so rare to find a place that takes food allergies seriously and delivers amazing desserts, but Jersey Girl does both. Everything I’ve tried has been full of flavor and clearly made with care. It’s obvious they’re passionate about what they do — and it shows in every bite.
If you're looking for a safe, sweet treat without sacrificing taste, definitely check them out. Can’t wait to go back
Dana Ian Farley
Had a great experience and the owners personality alone is enough to make me want to go back. Beautiful work and a pleasant staff! Highly recommend
Yvonne Pepe
Nicole did an amazing job for my son’s first birthday party!!! 10/10 will recommend to everyone
Robert Tully
Really glad I found this nut-free spot in Red Bank. As someone with a nut allergy, it’s not easy finding places where I don’t have to second guess everything — but here, everything’s 100% nut-free and clearly labeled.
Their cookies and snacks are awesome. Super fresh, great flavor, and no weird allergy-friendly aftertaste like some places have. Just legit good stuff that happens to be safe.
Staff is great , the place is clean, and it’s just nice having a go-to spot where I don’t have to worry. Definitely worth checking out if you’re in the area.
Jackie Rogers
HEAVENLY DELICIOUS!!! Her lemon blueberry cookie might be my favorite thing I’ve ever eaten!!!
Liz L
Nicole was amazing to work with and did a fabulous job for my daughter’s engagement. She followed the theme perfectly. Cookies were delicious and were a hit. Don’t hesitate to go there for any occasion. I fully recommend her.
Johnny F
I’ve used Jersey Cookie Girl several times now. I’ve ordered traditional cookies and ordered custom promotional cookies with business logos, school mascots, wedding hashtags, etc. Both the traditional cookies and promo cookies look and taste amazing. I can’t wait to visit their new location in Red Bank. Highly recommend the oatmeal chocolate chip.
nic rojas
Nicole was super sweet, helped us out when we lost our cookie! Awesome little stand, super cute selection of handmade treats. We met her at Trenton Punk Rock Flea Market, be sure to support her business!
sips ateaa
Super delicious cookies and excellent customer service, Nicole was amazing! She is such a sweet woman, met her at the Trenton Punk Rock Flea Market and she was such a doll, really recommend ordering from here. You will not regret it!!! 🩷☺️☺️☺️
Best cookies i’ve ever had. I’m celiac so i can’t have gluten and her gluten free cookies were just to die for. Easily became a returning customer!
Maria Colon-Torres
Nicole, Just wanted to reach out and share that we all had an amazing time hosting Gerardo's friends at his graduation party! Your Jersey Cookies were amazing, both festive and tasteful!! The combination of stethoscopes, white coats, Rutgers and Kessler designs were the talk amongst the upcoming residents & off course perfectly crunchy & beautifully designed 🥰 thank you so very much for making my son’s Medical School Graduation Party a very special day!
Jennifer Mezzino
Nicole was absolutely wonderful to work with! She helped me with my bridesmaid proposals and they came out perfect. Cookies were cute, delicious, and even the ones that were shipped delivered without issue. She was super quick and easy to work with. Will definitely be ordering more in the future
Nicholas Montani
Nicole at Jersey Cookie Girl is an absolute artist! Her custom cookies !are not only stunning to look at but also incredibly delicious
From the ordering process to the final presentation, Nicole is professional, creative, and so easy to work with. You can tell she puts her heart into every batch—these cookies are truly a work of art.
Highly recommend Nicole and Jersey Cookie Girl for anyone looking to impress with custom treats that taste as amazing as they look!
Elaine Bastedo
Just had cookies made for my daughters bridal shower and I am so happy with the way they turned out! They were perfect and taste was exceptional!!
Oatmeal cookies and chocolate chip cookies were very yummy. We also got the chocolate chip cookie bar. So happy to have found this place. Will definitely be back!
Jersey cookie girl. – Delicious & Nut-Free! 🍪
I've been to Jersey Girl Cookie twice now, and both times were a total win. The cookies are absolutely delicious — soft, flavorful, and baked just right. What really makes them stand out for me is that they are tree nut and peanut free, which is a huge deal for anyone with allergies (or loved ones with them).
It’s so rare to find a place that takes food allergies seriously and delivers amazing desserts, but Jersey Girl does both. Everything I’ve tried has been full of flavor and clearly made with care. It’s obvious they’re passionate about what they do — and it shows in every bite.
If you're looking for a safe, sweet treat without sacrificing taste, definitely check them out. Can’t wait to go back
Had a great experience and the owners personality alone is enough to make me want to go back. Beautiful work and a pleasant staff! Highly recommend
Nicole did an amazing job for my son’s first birthday party!!! 10/10 will recommend to everyone
Really glad I found this nut-free spot in Red Bank. As someone with a nut allergy, it’s not easy finding places where I don’t have to second guess everything — but here, everything’s 100% nut-free and clearly labeled. Their cookies and snacks are awesome. Super fresh, great flavor, and no weird allergy-friendly aftertaste like some places have. Just legit good stuff that happens to be safe. Staff is great , the place is clean, and it’s just nice having a go-to spot where I don’t have to worry. Definitely worth checking out if you’re in the area.
HEAVENLY DELICIOUS!!! Her lemon blueberry cookie might be my favorite thing I’ve ever eaten!!!
Nicole was amazing to work with and did a fabulous job for my daughter’s engagement. She followed the theme perfectly. Cookies were delicious and were a hit. Don’t hesitate to go there for any occasion. I fully recommend her.
I’ve used Jersey Cookie Girl several times now. I’ve ordered traditional cookies and ordered custom promotional cookies with business logos, school mascots, wedding hashtags, etc. Both the traditional cookies and promo cookies look and taste amazing. I can’t wait to visit their new location in Red Bank. Highly recommend the oatmeal chocolate chip.
Nicole was super sweet, helped us out when we lost our cookie! Awesome little stand, super cute selection of handmade treats. We met her at Trenton Punk Rock Flea Market, be sure to support her business!
Super delicious cookies and excellent customer service, Nicole was amazing! She is such a sweet woman, met her at the Trenton Punk Rock Flea Market and she was such a doll, really recommend ordering from here. You will not regret it!!! 🩷☺️☺️☺️
Restaurantji Recommends
Best cookies i’ve ever had. I’m celiac so i can’t have gluten and her gluten free cookies were just to die for. Easily became a returning customer!
Nicole, Just wanted to reach out and share that we all had an amazing time hosting Gerardo's friends at his graduation party! Your Jersey Cookies were amazing, both festive and tasteful!! The combination of stethoscopes, white coats, Rutgers and Kessler designs were the talk amongst the upcoming residents & off course perfectly crunchy & beautifully designed 🥰 thank you so very much for making my son’s Medical School Graduation Party a very special day!
Nicole was absolutely wonderful to work with! She helped me with my bridesmaid proposals and they came out perfect. Cookies were cute, delicious, and even the ones that were shipped delivered without issue. She was super quick and easy to work with. Will definitely be ordering more in the future
Nicole at Jersey Cookie Girl is an absolute artist! Her custom cookies !are not only stunning to look at but also incredibly delicious
From the ordering process to the final presentation, Nicole is professional, creative, and so easy to work with. You can tell she puts her heart into every batch—these cookies are truly a work of art.
Highly recommend Nicole and Jersey Cookie Girl for anyone looking to impress with custom treats that taste as amazing as they look!
Just had cookies made for my daughters bridal shower and I am so happy with the way they turned out! They were perfect and taste was exceptional!!
Loading...