Great, fun and energetic staff. Creative and delicious cookies. What more can you ask for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie Kits, Sugar Cookie
Crystal Guzman
The cookies look amazing and taste even better!! Employees are very pleasant as well. Would recommend this place to anyone!
Food: 5
Reshard Ali
We ordered cookies from Jersey Cookie for our twins party. The cookies were amazing. Sorry girl scouts, Jersey cookie girl got y'all beat. Lol.Parking: Free parkingKid-friendliness: Yes
Nicole is such a gem! She made custom fairytale themed cookies for my bridal shower and they were absolutely perfect. Nicole is so talented, professional, and passionate.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ibby K
SO GOOD
Atasha Jordan
I had a holiday sugar cookie from here as a gift and it was so good I looked this place up. SO GOOD. Kind of pricey tho. But I’d definitely buy some ?
Food: 5
Stephanie Pahountis
Nicole! The cookies were a HIT! Everybody went nuts over them. I can’t wait to share photos from the party.Ever since you did the cookies for my bridal shower, you’re our go to girl! Thank you so much for your patience and creativity!Can’t wait to place our thanksgiving order :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda Kaymakcian
Nicole is so sweet! She made me an order of custom cookies for my brother-in-law! They came out so beautiful! She is so talented! I highly recommend her beautiful, yummy cookies for any occasion! Thank you again!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies
Dayna Platnick
Nicole & her incredibly talented team created cookies for husband's 50th birthday...his 2 favorite things: his motorcycle jacket & baby shih tzu, Susan! Not only were they gorgeous, they were SO delicious! thank you!
Jillian Sacher
We will be repeat customers again and again! Incredible customer service, beautiful talent, and delicious cookies. Could not be any happier with our Jersey Cookie Girl orders!
I ordered 150 cookies for my companies annual BBQ as favors and we couldn’t be happier with how they came out. They did exactly what we wanted for our 70’s theme and even put tags on our cookies for us! I would 100% recommend!
Jennifer Anderer
Jersey Cookie Girl did a great job bringing my vision to life on a cookie. The helped make my daughters high school graduation more special. Everyone loved the look of the cookie and the taste!
Dana Cristino
You won’t be disappointed when ordering from Jersey Cookie Girl. They made my vision come alive and were able to use an old picture of mine into a cookie! Great tasting as well!
Michelle Gago
I Love these cookies!!! I have ordered them as party favors for some graduation and anniversary parties I have hosted and everyone raves about how delicious they are, and they are always beautifully hand crafted. I will defiantly be ordering more cookies again soon.
Daniella Butler
The best cookies for our wedding reception !! Nicole was so easy to work with, professional and so great especially because I was very last minute and needed the cookies done in 1 day !!! The photo on the cookies came out amazing and everyone raved about them ! Would definitely order again!!
Great, fun and energetic staff. Creative and delicious cookies. What more can you ask for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie Kits, Sugar Cookie
The cookies look amazing and taste even better!! Employees are very pleasant as well. Would recommend this place to anyone!
Food: 5
We ordered cookies from Jersey Cookie for our twins party. The cookies were amazing. Sorry girl scouts, Jersey cookie girl got y'all beat. Lol.Parking: Free parkingKid-friendliness: Yes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Orange Creamsicle Cookies, Thanksgiving Cookies, Cookie Kits, Sugar Cookie
Nicole is such a gem! She made custom fairytale themed cookies for my bridal shower and they were absolutely perfect. Nicole is so talented, professional, and passionate.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
SO GOOD
I had a holiday sugar cookie from here as a gift and it was so good I looked this place up. SO GOOD. Kind of pricey tho. But I’d definitely buy some ?
Food: 5
Nicole! The cookies were a HIT! Everybody went nuts over them. I can’t wait to share photos from the party.Ever since you did the cookies for my bridal shower, you’re our go to girl! Thank you so much for your patience and creativity!Can’t wait to place our thanksgiving order :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole is so sweet! She made me an order of custom cookies for my brother-in-law! They came out so beautiful! She is so talented! I highly recommend her beautiful, yummy cookies for any occasion! Thank you again!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookies
Nicole & her incredibly talented team created cookies for husband's 50th birthday...his 2 favorite things: his motorcycle jacket & baby shih tzu, Susan! Not only were they gorgeous, they were SO delicious! thank you!
We will be repeat customers again and again! Incredible customer service, beautiful talent, and delicious cookies. Could not be any happier with our Jersey Cookie Girl orders!
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered 150 cookies for my companies annual BBQ as favors and we couldn’t be happier with how they came out. They did exactly what we wanted for our 70’s theme and even put tags on our cookies for us! I would 100% recommend!
Jersey Cookie Girl did a great job bringing my vision to life on a cookie. The helped make my daughters high school graduation more special. Everyone loved the look of the cookie and the taste!
You won’t be disappointed when ordering from Jersey Cookie Girl. They made my vision come alive and were able to use an old picture of mine into a cookie! Great tasting as well!
I Love these cookies!!! I have ordered them as party favors for some graduation and anniversary parties I have hosted and everyone raves about how delicious they are, and they are always beautifully hand crafted. I will defiantly be ordering more cookies again soon.
The best cookies for our wedding reception !! Nicole was so easy to work with, professional and so great especially because I was very last minute and needed the cookies done in 1 day !!! The photo on the cookies came out amazing and everyone raved about them ! Would definitely order again!!