Four Boys Ice Cream

85 Washington Ave, Milltown
(732) 641-2837

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dena Snow

very good ice cream excellent service . open seasonally. there are events held in this parking lot in summer car shows and other

Daniel S

Great hard chocolate

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Heath David Doherty

Great community ice cream shop with good ice cream and variety.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Dmitri S.

This is our favorite, go-to ice cream shop around EB and Milltown.
Their ice cream is of a very high quality, even for us - self-proclaimed Italian Gelato snobs ? - it is amazingly creamy, flavorful, and rich. We especially like their pistachio, banana and strawberry flavors void of any dough, cookies and similar (unnecessary) additions that are very common in the States.
The Four Boys' shop is located at a quiet and quaint street and has a large parking lot with tables and chairs, to enjoy your ice cream while getting some rest.
The service staff is always extremely friendly and generous with their portions, and the pricing is more than fair! Fun fact - despite the shop's name we have never spotted a boy working there! ??
What is really missing there though - is a sign facing the road - owners, please advise!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

desiderio cardona

Great local spot with the best ice cream. Prices are good for the amount supplied.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great Person

Horrible experience. Arrived when they had a delivery and wouldn’t even bother to acknowledge us and say hey give us a few. Another couple also left when we left. I was with the family and kids got impatient for ice cream so we had to go some where else. Magníficos is down the street. Way better selection and absolutely much nicer and faster service. All we wanted was some ice cream. That’s what happens when you have a much of young kids working and no adults to supervise. Do not recommend coming here. Please take your money somewhere else. They also don’t do credit or debit cards. Cash only.

Jas Singh

For many years I look forward to taking my family for evening ice cream trips at this spot and for the last two summers, the quality and service is not up to par with the previous years. Despite that I went again last Friday with my family and we got the usual two large vanilla soft serves with sprinkles and two servings of mix and match hard ice cream. Needless to say we were all so disappointed and upset with the service and quality of ice cream. Our hard serve ice cream might as well be “soft served” it was melted by the time we walked to the outdoor tables right on the lot. The girls in the parlor was probably over worked specially with the heat. There is no AC and it seems like the ice cream was already melting inside the parlor. We got served slushy runny ice cream instead of hard served we paid for and we got large but our cups were half full. It cost us a pretty penny of over $35. This keeps happening way too often now; the owners need to bring back the great quality ice cream and services they once had.

John W

Fantastic ice cream and friendly service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vanilla and Chocolate Swirl with Rainbow Sprinkles

Marina Cacicia

No soft vanilla? No cherry dip that stays on the ice cream because it's too thin to coat it? According to the attendant the telephone is broken hence the lack of response when calling.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lou Alvarez

Got 2 large vanilla cones tastes like water ice milk got ripped off $10 for 2 large cones look very large but they tasted like water down milk water never go back again

Val Powers

Great ice cream parlor and they have hot fudge. Heads up this is a cash only business, a regular size hot fudge sundae will run you about 15.00 add a tip, hard ice cream takes work to scoop it. Service was friendly and fast. It was excellent I'm thinking for the sundae once a year. All their flavors look great and next visit I'll try something different.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

R R

Located in a dirty parking lot and I don't know what the thick, slimy, gelatinous mess they serve you is, but it is definitely not ice cream.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

demetrius telfaire

They never have what you want ....

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

Anthony Stanaway

Employee maya was extremely rude and told me to get out of line because I “can’t sample every damn thing on the menu”. This was extremely rude and unprofessional I was very displeased with this visit. She also proceeded to sit down on her phone while her coworker Ava was tending to a line of atleast 12 customers. We’ll never return to this establishment again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Greg Pimp

Ice cream was good but service was absolutely terrible. First of all the line took forever and then when it was finally my turn the girl tending to me was terrible. She was shorter had longer brown curly hair and brown eyes. First of all she has no patience and went straight to yelling at me after I asked to try flavors. She also threw my change at me and when I asked for napkins she told me to open my eyes and turn around. Will not be coming back any time soon

Loading...