Four Boys Ice Cream

85 Washington Ave, Milltown
(732) 641-2837

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Linda Wingo Giacobbe

Love there canoli ice cream. Home made

nikki ballou

Delicious ice cream sundaes!! I’ll be returning when I visit NJ again!

Liam Napp

Who is in charge??? It's run by 15 year old girls for crying out loud. They're rude, won't look up from their phones, and are extremely rude to men

The Vio

ice cream was very good, but gotta say...a bit skimpy on the ice cream on the cone. the swirl was loose and not a full cone for $5+, it was sloppy if that makes sense. My first time here and heard such god things... maybe it was just the individual trying to move the line along to quickly, i think but if not rushed, the cone would have been more enjoyable.
I'll have to try them again... maybe another location.

Matthew Souder

Ordered a cone and cup of cookie dough and it was like they scraped melted ice cream off of the side of the bucket to fill them. Couldn't even finish our smalls. Very disappointing

Guillermina Heras

Best Ice cream I've had. The only downside is that's is cash only

Ken B

Seems like every year the amount of ice cream served is less and less than the years before but not the prices.

Len McKinnon

The ice cream is very good. The price is extremely reasonable. The staff are very njce.
It's a walk-up to the stand type of place. They have some tables and benches to sit outnice.
We do not live in Milltown, but we like to visit here when we come to see relatives.

Rhoan Williams

Ice cream is great! Didn’t get a chance to enjoy any today though. The girl at the counter would rather talk to her friends than to deal with customers.

Donna Sisti

Delicious, creamy ice cream. I highly recommend the vanilla peanut butter with hot fudge topping & whipped cream 🍨

Kiana Jay

Such a cute location! The best ice cream shop around. If you’re craving that homemade, family vibe this is the place to go. I couldn’t have waited for spring to come quicker so I can get my weekly fix in 😂🍦

Norma M

Was so good a vanilla ice cream with sprinkles on our way home .what a great treat

Dena Snow

very good ice cream excellent service . open seasonally. there are events held in this parking lot in summer car shows and other

Daniel S

Great hard chocolate

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Heath David Doherty

Great community ice cream shop with good ice cream and variety.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Loading...