Big red sign above store that says Bagels/ everything bagel and more. Like who could miss it right? The taxi driver couldnt find it because his GPS didnt take him to the door! Ha. They had a variety of bagels, muffins and drinks, with a seated area to dine in. They take credit cards and there is a % fee for use. I found this out after the server asked the workers as she did not know. We met a few customers there from the Taekwondo place a few stores down. They were pleased to allow me to take and place a picture. They noted that the sabom was really good and suggested we stop by and meet him after our breakfast. We did walk over to find the door locked and hours open at 1pm. This noted the review is about the bagel store. The workers were pleasant enough. I could not comment on the other items as I had a blueberry muffin toasted as I had requested and my friend had a scrambled egg on white bread. While we were there they were installing a new TV on the wall. That's nice.
Neha Gautam
Had the most delicious cinnamon raisin toasted bagel with egg and cheese!! Perfect heat and taste!! Very friendly people! Clean and spacious inside. Lots of tables to sit and eat.
Bob H.
You're not gonna find a bagel Store anywhere in the area that is as warm and inviting as Everything bagel and Cafe. They have the best selection of kettle bagels and you will not get a better tasting bagel. anywhere in the area then what you can get at Everything Bagel Cafe. Services impeccable, food is incredible. The owners are on premises every day to ensure their customers are satisfied. You will not be disappointed.
Michael G.
Best bagels in the area by far. I'm from NYC and used to getting good bagels. Moved to NJ and hadnt found any place that was close to comparable until I was recommended this place and most say they are top notch bagels that are like having my normal ny bagels again
debra F
Went here several times because I actually like the taste of the bagels. The issue I have is like other reviewers there is hardly any butter, cream cheese, etc. on the bagel. I was there recently asked to butter it well and it was worse than ever. I guess the skinny tall guy who I saw butter it doesn't eat so no butter looked good to him. LolThe egg sandwiches are not any better. It's like where's the beef. The thinnest sandwiches I've ever seen in NJ.I'd like to see them succeed but please give us what we are paying for.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Bagel
gino e
Was so excited about a new bagel place. But what a disappointment I have to say. The bagels are burnt and too big to much dough. I tried three different times because it’s right up the street from me. I Ordered a bacon, egg and cheese. What a joke there wasn’t hardly any bacon and cheese very chinch for the price. Second time a bagel with cream cheese which was so skimpy I had to choke it down. The third and last time was the other day I came in asked for a bagel with butter and asked them to please put butter on the bagel because I was afraid there wouldn’t be any. Well, even after asking there was barely any butter. I see another review saying same thing so it’s not just me. You guys are not going to make it in our neighborhood if you can’t give us decent food. We don’t care about the price but give us the product. I would only suggest this place if your on a Keto diet
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Nicholas S.
got a christmas bagel this morning and got a warm welcoming hello from everyone!! the bagel was so cute and i loved it. one of the best bagels i've ever had .
Yancy Chris A
Good bagels, good sandwiches and choices. Nice staff. Will definitely come again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sebastian Trujillo
Great people who work here and the food is amazing. I got the Holmdel hot sub and one of the best sandwiches I’ve had. Everything tastes so fresh. Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Klimchuk
Place is amazing and has become. My wife and my new favorite place for
Best bagel with butter ever. Could not recommend more, the everything bagel has the best flavor I've ever had. Has like a pinch of pretzel salt and it's amazing.
Sophia K.
My mom and I are constantly in search of a good bagel place and we've finally found it. The service is amazing and the bagels are so fluffy! We even drive 20 minutes to go get it! Highly recommend
John Y.
This "bagel" shop is a disguise for an amazing take out or dine in. The bagel and bread is always fresh...sandwich combos are outta control...doesn't skimp on the meat or the fixings. At the end of the day...doesn't disappoint.
J G
First time coming to this bagel shop. The Staff and owner or pleasant to deal with. Probably one of the best bagels I have had in a long time outside was crunchy inside with Chewy. My nephew loved the bacon that they put on it with the cream cheese. I definitely will be coming back and I’m coming from East Brunswick, with bagel shops on every corner.
Kat Tolerico
Best bagel shop in Marlboro and Old Bridge. Owners are so nice, staff very friendly and polite, always have fresh hot delicious bagels ready. Sandwiches are fabulous too!
Big red sign above store that says Bagels/ everything bagel and more. Like who could miss it right? The taxi driver couldnt find it because his GPS didnt take him to the door! Ha. They had a variety of bagels, muffins and drinks, with a seated area to dine in. They take credit cards and there is a % fee for use. I found this out after the server asked the workers as she did not know. We met a few customers there from the Taekwondo place a few stores down. They were pleased to allow me to take and place a picture. They noted that the sabom was really good and suggested we stop by and meet him after our breakfast. We did walk over to find the door locked and hours open at 1pm. This noted the review is about the bagel store. The workers were pleasant enough. I could not comment on the other items as I had a blueberry muffin toasted as I had requested and my friend had a scrambled egg on white bread. While we were there they were installing a new TV on the wall. That's nice.
Had the most delicious cinnamon raisin toasted bagel with egg and cheese!! Perfect heat and taste!! Very friendly people! Clean and spacious inside. Lots of tables to sit and eat.
You're not gonna find a bagel Store anywhere in the area that is as warm and inviting as Everything bagel and Cafe. They have the best selection of kettle bagels and you will not get a better tasting bagel. anywhere in the area then what you can get at Everything Bagel Cafe. Services impeccable, food is incredible. The owners are on premises every day to ensure their customers are satisfied. You will not be disappointed.
Best bagels in the area by far. I'm from NYC and used to getting good bagels. Moved to NJ and hadnt found any place that was close to comparable until I was recommended this place and most say they are top notch bagels that are like having my normal ny bagels again
Went here several times because I actually like the taste of the bagels. The issue I have is like other reviewers there is hardly any butter, cream cheese, etc. on the bagel. I was there recently asked to butter it well and it was worse than ever. I guess the skinny tall guy who I saw butter it doesn't eat so no butter looked good to him. LolThe egg sandwiches are not any better. It's like where's the beef. The thinnest sandwiches I've ever seen in NJ.I'd like to see them succeed but please give us what we are paying for.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Bagel
Was so excited about a new bagel place. But what a disappointment I have to say. The bagels are burnt and too big to much dough. I tried three different times because it’s right up the street from me. I Ordered a bacon, egg and cheese. What a joke there wasn’t hardly any bacon and cheese very chinch for the price. Second time a bagel with cream cheese which was so skimpy I had to choke it down. The third and last time was the other day I came in asked for a bagel with butter and asked them to please put butter on the bagel because I was afraid there wouldn’t be any. Well, even after asking there was barely any butter. I see another review saying same thing so it’s not just me. You guys are not going to make it in our neighborhood if you can’t give us decent food. We don’t care about the price but give us the product. I would only suggest this place if your on a Keto diet
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
got a christmas bagel this morning and got a warm welcoming hello from everyone!! the bagel was so cute and i loved it. one of the best bagels i've ever had .
Good bagels, good sandwiches and choices. Nice staff. Will definitely come again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great people who work here and the food is amazing. I got the Holmdel hot sub and one of the best sandwiches I’ve had. Everything tastes so fresh. Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Place is amazing and has become. My wife and my new favorite place for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pork Roll, Fries, Bagel, French Toast Bagel, Mozzarella Sticks
Restaurantji Recommends
Best bagel with butter ever. Could not recommend more, the everything bagel has the best flavor I've ever had. Has like a pinch of pretzel salt and it's amazing.
My mom and I are constantly in search of a good bagel place and we've finally found it. The service is amazing and the bagels are so fluffy! We even drive 20 minutes to go get it! Highly recommend
This "bagel" shop is a disguise for an amazing take out or dine in. The bagel and bread is always fresh...sandwich combos are outta control...doesn't skimp on the meat or the fixings. At the end of the day...doesn't disappoint.
First time coming to this bagel shop. The Staff and owner or pleasant to deal with. Probably one of the best bagels I have had in a long time outside was crunchy inside with Chewy. My nephew loved the bacon that they put on it with the cream cheese. I definitely will be coming back and I’m coming from East Brunswick, with bagel shops on every corner.
Best bagel shop in Marlboro and Old Bridge. Owners are so nice, staff very friendly and polite, always have fresh hot delicious bagels ready. Sandwiches are fabulous too!