Tommys Tavern + Tap

1900 NJ-10, Morris Plains
(973) 998-6429

Recent Reviews

Sort by
mindy rosen

1st time there but won't b the last. We had Asian ribs & chicken nachos both excellent. Also ordered pesto chicken sandwich(sorry no pic) which we had 2 take home bc full. Nice atmosphere. Great waiter & Antonio, Manager stopped by. Highly recommend

Mickey Chopra

Tommy’s is close to our house and we do like going there. Food quality is good service is slow. But they can do better.

matt caine

They ran out of their ice tea concentrate so they boiled some tea and put it on ice for me!

Joey Natale

Overall nice spot for night time atmosphere and simple bar food and drinks. Food is inconsistent. Sometimes it’s solid, other times you’ll get a soggy pizza or soft wings. They’ll have the same exact sporting event on TVs next to each other and the main event on the TVs in the corners of the place. When you ask politely for them to change it to the Yankee game for example, it’s as if it’s some challenging task. They’ll say they’ll “try” to change it.

Davidb Umstead

Overall, the atmosphere is great. The service is spectacular but I do have to say the food is lacking a little bit and for the prices you're paying it shouldn't be lacking at all has to be one or the other. The food has to be spectacular or the prices have to be cheaper. Can't be both. Otherwise, I'd recommend nice place. Great atmosphere. They do have a rewards program. You can sign up with your phone number

Carmen Foti

Drove 50 miles for the Barrata and its off the menu. Very sad.

Jerry Primamore

Sadly it was not their best night. A simple sandwich and fish and Chips took half an hour wait to the table. Fish and chips was probably the greasiest I’ve ever had. Not the common at this place but tonight was very disappointing

em fitz

Overall its a pretty good restaurant! Ive always loved the food I have ordered and the service is good. Plus they have a great variety of food from sandwiches, to pasta, to sushi! I love their pizza.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Jumbo Pretzel

Milton Lightner

Great food and the service was very good. Every time I have been there it’s been packed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Pulled Pork, Burgers, Pepperoni Pizza

richard brown

We come here a few times a month The food snd service is always top notch.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salad, Penne Vodka, Sandwich

Jeff Guenther

First time there. Nice, comfortable, casual atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mr. J Felony

I was a big fan, but last night, 3 in my party ate the "crock of chili", with the chips.. while it did not taste rancid, it wasn't too flavorful... but we are all sick today with stomach issues... the table service was poor, which is unusual, but what really suprised was when we left, there were 4 employees at the greeters desk, a manager type and 3 others, yes 4 employees, and not even one looked up to say good night, or thank you... when I said thank you to them, not one of em acknowledged us.. too bad... none of us will be back. If the chili is a low rotatation item, and it can't be served fresh, it should be removed from the menu.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

Michael Toomey

Nice place, pretty good food!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Isaac Calvo

I’ve been to the one in Bridgewater, so I’m comparing to that experience.

We order the brussels sprouts the lobster bisque, cold wings, and a burger . Service was a little slow, but the staff was very friendly. The food itself was just OK if I had to give it a one out of five I would give it a 3.5.

The crispy brussels sprouts were not cooked all the way so they were very raw in the center

The burger was nothing to brag about. It’s burger. The lobster bisque was actually pretty good very heavy but good. I do recommend that one. Or drinks the paper plain was delicious.

That being said that fell short of the usual I expected the wings were not really crispy on the outside. They were kinda like soggy almost like a boiled chicken. They were cooked all the way, but it didn’t have a lot of flavor once again food wise I would say this whole thing was a 3.5 out of five not good not bad just above average .

Definitely a good spot for happy hour and drinks and some appetizers though

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Mark Villaluz

Had another great experience at Tommy's Tavern + Tap. Food is always consistent, good atmosphere and our server was great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Burgers, Poke Bowl, Pepperoni Pizza

Loading...