Beenie's Ice Cream

38 Morris St, Morristown
(862) 260-9221

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Anastasios “Jay” Tentsoglides

I’ve only been here once but the coffee ice cream with Oreos is awesome!

Jeff Pearlman

If you know, you know!

Rayne

i’ve only been here twice. the last time my icecream leaked through the container it’s in. this time got home with my.. melted icecream (i live 15 mins away) it fell in a closed container + went all over the floor. waste of my time + money. now i get no icecream because they are so cheap they can’t spend money on something that won’t open when accidentally falling.

Sara BRS

Best one in town!

Melanie Ruiz

Eileen was so helpful and so sweet! She helped me pick the best option for me and my family. The place itself is so clean and so full of color :)

Ryan Suh

4.9/5

Glad we discovered this place. Visited 3 times in 3 days.

stracciatella 5/5. This is a sure winner that we got every visit. Creaminess 4.95. Flavor 5/5 is great but what makes this flavor unique is the aftertaste. 30 mins later, the taste still lingers and makes me crave it hence the repeat visits.

Chocolate lover 4.95/5. I find the chocolate brownie with chocolate chips a bit overpowering. Wish it was 10% less. I’m a chocolate lover but I found it a bit much. Creaminess 4.90/5.

Smurf 4.96/5. Blueberry flavor with cookies. Creaminess 4.93/5. 3rd favorite flavor.

Cookies and Cream. 4.98/5. Creaminess 4.95. The flavor is great, just as good as Curly’s Riverdale, NJ but Curly’s is 4.97 creamier. Beenie’s is closer to us so this place is our new fix.

This is the 2nd best ice cream place we found so far. Only place better is a 2.5hr drive away, Cubby’s in PA. We’re from NYC, good thing you guys are far, we’ll get fat from eating your ice cream. Too addictive.

Andi Bloom

Delicious icecream with a super cute atmosphere! Plenty of vegan and gluten free options with allergens clearly listed. But most of all just really tasty!

tiffany rose

Nice and patient staff. A lot of different and unique flavors. Everything was really good.

Leandra DeVito

Adorable ice cream shoppe thats dog friendly! Hard ice cream only with tons of flavors.

Amy Petraccoro

This icecream is next level. Had it for the first time lastnight and now I cant wait to go back. Everyone that worked there was so friendly and the atmosphere is adorable.

Jessica Beck

Some of the best ice cream around! We miss the Shirley Temple Sorbet, which was fantastic! Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Black Cherry Amaretto, Cookie Dough, Golden Oreo, Cookie Monster, Root Beer Float, Dr. Darkness, Chocolate Lovers - alllll fab though! The ice cream tacos are huge and delicious too! Such a cute shop too!

Michael Wishart

Really loved this family friendly spot. Discovered unique flavors and all were high quality. The interior design was very thoughtful too. Highly recommend

Cara Hartwig

Honey lavender and Reese’s Witherspoon was so delicious! Such a fun store interior too!

Teena Jakova

The most amazing chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich in the state. Definitely worth the $10.00's
Just really good.

Shawnee Sinclair

They offer so many yummy and unique flavors! I got the banana with nilla wafers and golden Oreo and both were delicious! They also have a spacious area to sit with fun campfire chairs around a fake fire. Super cute and highly recommend!

Loading...