Coniglio's Old Fashioned

Name: Coniglio's Old Fashioned
Address: 11 South St, Morristown, New Jersey, 07960, US
Telephone: (973) 723-9430
Price range: $
Rating: 4.2

$ • Pizza, Bars, Salad

Hours:
11 South St, Morristown
(973) 723-9430

Menu Order Online

About Coniglio's Old Fashioned

Coniglio's Old Fashioned is a remarkable restaurant, known for its exceptional service and mouthwatering food. The pizzas are particularly impressive, with many considering them the best they've ever had. Rated 8.3 by Dave Portnoy, the 18" meatball and ricotta pie is a standout, featuring top-tier ingredients and a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, oil, crust, and basil. The crust has a crispy exterior with a soft, fluffy interior, and is loaded with basil. Customers praise the crust for its balance of crispness and chewiness, and some dip the crust in the sauce, which is flavorful and tangy. The atmosphere is cozy and family-friendly, making it a must-visit spot for anyone in the area. The bombas are fantastic, and the pastries are breathtaking. The salads are also amazing. The restaurant offers great value, with four dishes costing around $80, which is very reasonable given the high quality. The staff, including the friendly Nonna “Josephine” and attentive counter manager Pablo, make guests feel at home. The chicken Parm platter is highly recommended, described as as good as any fine dining NYC restaurant, or even better. Many visitors are impressed by how affordable and consistently excellent the food is, especially since the quality exceeds expectations. While some feel the restaurant turns tables quickly, which is different from the leisurely pace typical in Italy, Coniglio's remains a top choice for great pizza and Italian food, with more inside seating to accommodate guests comfortably.