Their pizza is great. But my friend bought 2 pies of pizza and I was restricted restroom entry until I bought a pie of pizza myself. My friend who bought the pizza came with me with a receipt but we got denied. I had to buy a water bottle just to be able to access the restroom. Good pizza but bad principles
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Brian Kauffman
Imagine the cast of jersey shore runs a pizza shop. Horrible, disrespectful "service". Pizza definitely not worth the attitude. In 52 years I've never met a more arrogant pizza worker. Save your money and hassle and get pizza across the street.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Daniel G
Not sure if this is how the Sicilian grandma pie is usually prepared but it was definitely overcooked or something. My pictures speak for themselves.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Paul Holmes
The pizza is good but there is no way to get in contact with them. They have a number you can text but they don’t reply. I stopped ordering from them because there is no way of requesting a modification.
Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Anthony c
1st time there-read about how it’s one of the best pizzas in the state. Had to ask if they served the 2 pizzas I wanted to try bc they weren’t on the menu. Counter staff was very unhelpful. When we told them we just wanted water instead of sodas they didn’t even offer the carafe of table water or glasses to us. Unbeknownst to us (not being a local) we could go to the drinks display & grab a carafe for ourselves. Waited about 10-12 minutes for the pizzas & to say we were disappointed was an understatement. I didn’t even care that the pizzas were $44 for 2; we travel & pay more & less for pizzas all over the county.
The pizzas were unevenly cooked; full of grease & the sauce on the plain cheese & the tomato pie was spicy. Never have I had a sauce like this before. Didn’t help that the sauce was so soupy, before I had even taken a bite it slid off my minuscule ceramic cake plate they provide on the table. Pizza doesn’t come close to fitting on it. Never used so many napkins eating pizza.
Bought an olive bread from the bakery section & at least my wife said was terrific.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
T Porscha
The best pizza in NJ by far. It’s pricey but totally worth it. Needs more inside seating to be less crowded and spacious. The bombas are fantastic. The bread is baked daily.
Parking: It’s in the center of Morristown on The Green. There is never parking.
Wheelchair accessibility: It’s very tight.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upside Down Sicilian
Qol Gezus
Order a pie and #203 sandwich. The pie was absolute garbage hands down never again. Plastic cheese sweet and tangy sauce do better. BUUUUT ….that sandwich was impeccable!!!! I will recommend the sandwich to EVERYONE the pizza to no one. Pricey but I’d pay that for the sandwich
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
larry mahler
So, I ordered a plain cheese pie. Added two toppings. (Sausage and mushrooms).. I can’t believe I paid $33.05 for a pie!!! This was not even one of their Special pies, like a Margarita etc. When did sausage topping ever cost $4.50 and mushrooms 3.50?? And forget the attitude I got for asking why so much…this is definitely abusive pricing. Inflation hasn’t gotten that bad!
As an fyi, When you go to “Menu” on the website, there is no price for the Large plain pie. You have to go to the “Online” tab to see the price there.. Pizza was good, but no way I am paying these Prices again. I’ll drive over to route 10 for a similar pie.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
S M
The pizza is good but dense. The price is also about 20% too high. Wouldn't think to get a bagel here but the bagels are surprisingly very good though. The iced coffee on the other hand tasted like cold Folgers.
Great atmosphere though especially for breakfast when things are a bit slower.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Lynn Khosrowshahi
Very disappointing. Got takeout. It was obviously old pizza, probably from the night before. They added powdered parm cheese on top which is expect from a low end slice joint, not the "King of Pies". What a joke.
The food is worth it. My only disappointment is that they want to turn the tables over too fast for my taste. I never encountered that in any of my extended stays in Italy, rather the opposite. But we were invited per fare un passeggari, to take a stroll.
I found “no table service” disappointing. You have to order and pay at the register, find a table and hope the server finds you. Also every time someone enters the restaurant a winter cold blast enters the restaurant. The food was okay but a bit pricey.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Eggplant Parm Sandwich
Daniel Maldonado
Nice pastries nice vibes, authentic Italian treats, but you need to sell your pizza by the slice too, it’s Jersey.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diogo Campos
Terrible service. We have ordered and sat in the table as they told us to. They simply forgot about my order. Then I needed to ask again in the counter and they tried to charge again!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Jordan Wiles
Came in to get a pie before a tournament and the place looked nice and the atmosphere was great! I was expecting an amazing pizza but was sadly disappointed. The crust was perfect no complaints there but there was too little cheese and i could not tell where the sauce began or ended. honestly not worth the $24.50 i paid for it and i get it Morristown is expensive but it should’ve been better,
Their pizza is great. But my friend bought 2 pies of pizza and I was restricted restroom entry until I bought a pie of pizza myself. My friend who bought the pizza came with me with a receipt but we got denied. I had to buy a water bottle just to be able to access the restroom. Good pizza but bad principles
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Imagine the cast of jersey shore runs a pizza shop. Horrible, disrespectful "service". Pizza definitely not worth the attitude. In 52 years I've never met a more arrogant pizza worker. Save your money and hassle and get pizza across the street.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Not sure if this is how the Sicilian grandma pie is usually prepared but it was definitely overcooked or something. My pictures speak for themselves.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
The pizza is good but there is no way to get in contact with them. They have a number you can text but they don’t reply. I stopped ordering from them because there is no way of requesting a modification.
Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
1st time there-read about how it’s one of the best pizzas in the state. Had to ask if they served the 2 pizzas I wanted to try bc they weren’t on the menu. Counter staff was very unhelpful. When we told them we just wanted water instead of sodas they didn’t even offer the carafe of table water or glasses to us. Unbeknownst to us (not being a local) we could go to the drinks display & grab a carafe for ourselves.
Waited about 10-12 minutes for the pizzas & to say we were disappointed was an understatement. I didn’t even care that the pizzas were $44 for 2; we travel & pay more & less for pizzas all over the county.
The pizzas were unevenly cooked; full of grease & the sauce on the plain cheese & the tomato pie was spicy. Never have I had a sauce like this before. Didn’t help that the sauce was so soupy, before I had even taken a bite it slid off my minuscule ceramic cake plate they provide on the table. Pizza doesn’t come close to fitting on it. Never used so many napkins eating pizza.
Bought an olive bread from the bakery section & at least my wife said was terrific.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
The best pizza in NJ by far. It’s pricey but totally worth it. Needs more inside seating to be less crowded and spacious. The bombas are fantastic. The bread is baked daily.
Parking: It’s in the center of Morristown on The Green. There is never parking.
Wheelchair accessibility: It’s very tight.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upside Down Sicilian
Order a pie and #203 sandwich. The pie was absolute garbage hands down never again. Plastic cheese sweet and tangy sauce do better. BUUUUT ….that sandwich was impeccable!!!! I will recommend the sandwich to EVERYONE the pizza to no one.
Pricey but I’d pay that for the sandwich
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
So, I ordered a plain cheese pie. Added two toppings. (Sausage and mushrooms)..
I can’t believe I paid $33.05 for a pie!!!
This was not even one of their Special pies, like a Margarita etc.
When did sausage topping ever cost $4.50 and mushrooms 3.50??
And forget the attitude I got for asking why so much…this is definitely abusive pricing. Inflation hasn’t gotten that bad!
As an fyi, When you go to “Menu” on the website, there is no price for the Large plain pie. You have to go to the “Online” tab to see the price there..
Pizza was good, but no way I am paying these
Prices again. I’ll drive over to route 10 for a similar pie.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
The pizza is good but dense. The price is also about 20% too high. Wouldn't think to get a bagel here but the bagels are surprisingly very good though. The iced coffee on the other hand tasted like cold Folgers.
Great atmosphere though especially for breakfast when things are a bit slower.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Very disappointing. Got takeout. It was obviously old pizza, probably from the night before. They added powdered parm cheese on top which is expect from a low end slice joint, not the "King of Pies". What a joke.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
The food is worth it. My only disappointment is that they want to turn the tables over too fast for my taste. I never encountered that in any of my extended stays in Italy, rather the opposite. But we were invited per fare un passeggari, to take a stroll.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Eggplant Parm Sandwich, Chicken Parm Sandwich
I found “no table service” disappointing. You have to order and pay at the register, find a table and hope the server finds you. Also every time someone enters the restaurant a winter cold blast enters the restaurant. The food was okay but a bit pricey.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Eggplant Parm Sandwich
Nice pastries nice vibes, authentic Italian treats, but you need to sell your pizza by the slice too, it’s Jersey.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrible service. We have ordered and sat in the table as they told us to. They simply forgot about my order. Then I needed to ask again in the counter and they tried to charge again!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Came in to get a pie before a tournament and the place looked nice and the atmosphere was great! I was expecting an amazing pizza but was sadly disappointed. The crust was perfect no complaints there but there was too little cheese and i could not tell where the sauce began or ended. honestly not worth the $24.50 i paid for it and i get it Morristown is expensive but it should’ve been better,
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Loading...