Surreal Creamery

5 Washington St, Morristown
(973) 750-8870

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Design Your Own Earl Grey and Taro Ice Cream with Waffle Cookie
Mako - Make Your Own Mason Jar
Mason Jars Sampler Platter
Design Your Own Ice Cream
Earl Grey Everyday
Chocolate Blackout
Mango Slushyswirl
Meet Your Matcha
It's My Birthday
Nom Nom Cookie

Mason Jar
Say Cheese
Nom Nom Cookie
Monster Cookie Ice Cream, Chocolate Crunch, Chocolate Syrup, Cookie Crisp, Marshmallows, and Oreos
Chocolate Blackout
Earl Grey Everyday
It's My Birthday
Matcha Made In Heaven
Know Your Roots
MAKO - Make Your Own Mason Jar

Classic Ice Cream
Ice Cream Cup
Waffle Cone
Milk Shake

Cookies
Surreal Milk & Cookie Combo
Surreal Cookie (Huge 6oz cookie) + Milk + Cereal Combination
Peanut Butter Chocolate
Double-chocolate dough mixed with smooth natural peanut butter. Huge 6oz cookie.
Oatmeal Raisin with Pecans
California raisins with crunch pecans in soft oat filled dough. Huge 6oz cookie.
Brownie Cookie
Ultimate chocolately indulgence with premium ground chocolate. Huge 6oz cookie.
Milk Chocolate Chunk
Rich smooth milk chocolate in a soft butter dough. Huge 6oz cookie.
Toffee Fudge Brownie
Sinfully sweet toffee with rich dark chocolate. Huge 6oz cookie.
Kitchen Sink
Almonds, pecans, rolled oats, coconut with rich milk and semi-sweet chocolate. Huge 6oz cookie.
Chocolate Chip with Walnuts
California walnuts with rich semi-sweet chocolate. Huge 6oz cookie.
Chocolate Chip
Classic rich semi-sweet chocolate in soft buttery dough. Huge 6oz cookie.
Milk
Milk

Floteas
Bubbles n Cream
Earl Grey Bubble Tea & Earl Grey Ice Cream
Silk Road
Thai Milk Bubble Tea & Vietnamese Iced Coffee Ice Cream
Saigon Fog
Vietnamese Coffee & Earl Grey Ice Cream
Meet your Matcha
Matcha Bubble Tea & Matca / Taro Swirl Ice Cream
Tardy Mates
Taro Bubbles Tea & Matcha Ice Cream
Earl of Sugarland
Brown Sugar Bubble Tea & Earl Grey Ice Cream
MAKO - MAKE YOUR OWN Flotea

SlushySwirl
Strawberry SlushySwirl
Strawberry Slushie + Strawberry Ice Cream
Mango SlushySwirl
Mango Slushie + Earl Grey Ice Cream
Watermelon SlushySwirl
Watermelon Slushie + Earl Grey Ice Cream
Passion Fruit SlushySwirl
Passion Fruit Slushie + Earl Grey Ice Cream
MAKO - MAKE YOUR OWN SlushySwirl
Lychee SlushySwirl
Lychee Slushie + Earl Grey Ice Cream

Swaffles
Monster Madness Swaffle
Belgian Liége Waffle + Monster Ice Cream, chocolate syrup, Oreos , cookie dough bites, marshmallows, chocolate crunch
Decadent Chocolate Swaffle
Belgian Liége Waffle + Chocolate Ice Cream, Cookie Dough Bites, Marshmallows, Oreos, Chocolate Syrup
PartyTime Swaffle
Belgian Liége Waffle + Strawberry Ice Cream, strawberry syrup, fruity pebbles, rainbow sprinkles
Berry Banana Swaffle
Belgian Liége Waffle + Earl Grey Ice Cream, fresh strawberries, fresh bananas, chocolate syrup, powdered sugar

Bubble Tea - Milk
Earl Grey Bubble Tea
Matcha Bubble Tea
Vietnamese Coffee Bubble Tea
MAKO - Make Your Own Bubble Tea
Brown Sugar Bubble Tea
Taro Bubble Tea
Thai Bubble Tea

Bubble Tea - Fruit
Mango Bubble Tea
Passion Fruit Bubble Tea
Strawberry Bubble Tea
Lychee Bubble Tea

Slushies
Watermelon Slushie
Lychee Slushie
Strawberry Slushie
Mango Slushie
Passionfruit Slushie

Lemonade Refreshers
Peach Lemonade Refresher
Strawberry Lemonade Refresher

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+13 photos
Photo credit: google
+12 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I tried the cookies here and they are amazing. Ethan was so friendly and the vibe was so welcoming. It’s obvious to see as soon as you step in the store that they care about the quality of their food and giving the customer a great experience.
October 2024
Ice cream is ok. I didn't realize this going in but it is soft serve only. The texture was pretty firm and not melty. It was also creamy. I got the Vietnamese coffee ice cream flavor and it tastes more like regular coffee. It had the bitterness of vietnamese coffee but not the same condensed milk sweetness unfortunately. The portion size wasn't bad but it was not cheap.
October 2024
Usually love this place, however understandably there may have been a new worker and our drinks weren’t up the quality we are used to. Bf told me Workers were getting yelled at by other people unfortunately. Please hire more people on busy days or have the girls who regularly make them teach the newer workers. The times the girls worked I’ve had no complaints. This is an expensive treat, it should be made right.
October 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

John's Delicatessen - 17 Washington St
Fast Food
The Frog Restaurant and Sports Bar - 18 Washington St
American, Bar, Sports Bar
Hops Craft Bar - 18 Washington St
Gastropubs, Wine Bar, American

Surreal Creamery

5 Washington St, Morristown, NJ 07960
(973) 750-8870