we went to The Godfather last Saturday about 5:30, well before the evening rush. In the past we loved every visit. Last week was not at all the same. The appetizer arrived soggy and was not hot. it was barely tepid in the middle. Both entree's were the same. Barely warm in the middle and the cheese wasn't fully melted. I can confidently say this was our last trip.
Josiah MACK
The worst cheese cake i ever had the menu on line says fresh strawberries on cheesecake i got plain with one black berry one blue berry and a ton of powered sugar pizza was cold when it arrived
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 2
Shuchi Gupta
This is some of the worst pizza I have ever had. It was cold, chewy, and felt like it was cooked hours ago and just sent over stale. Avoid at all costs.
Food: 1
Sheena's C.
The La Parma pizza is a must try!! It hits all the right flavors with a crispy crust. I mean it is a salad pizza and so much flavor!!
Chad Sexington
Popped in for a quick bite, meh slice nothing to write home about. $4.80 for a slice of white broccoli is insane tho. I’m assuming they’re overcharging cause of the yuppies next door in the Deloitte building.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Real Rizskas biznas
First I will begin by saying this is my first time going there based on a recommendation from a friend. It has a nice looking facility, and the food was prepared when I was arrived.The bread was fresh to their credit, which can make a break a sandwich. The chicken was also fresh, but was the equivalence of about 2 dinky chicken tenders topped with messy cheese and what I believe was cheap cannds sauce.When I arrived there was nobody at the register but there was a kid in pajamas hanging out behind the counter. I didn't know if I was walking into a slumber party or not. When the girl came to the register from the back, she was very friendly and asked if I was paying cash or card. I said is it the same price for both? she said YES, so I paid with card when I could have paid with cash. Turns out when I later checked my receipt, that was not the case. I do not like to get nickel and dimed or support businesses that like to charge fees for every little thing . I have plenty of options. So now I just bought a $14 sandwich that was ok, but certainly not great, and I get to my destination only to find out that I paid extra for a credit card and they didn't even include napkins. How do you charge 14 for a average to below average sandwich like that and not include napkins?I'll give them credit for using fresh bread, but I would not recommend this place.Update* This is laughable, notice the childish response on any criticism or feedback in all their reviews. Common denominator .My review was complimenting the food quality but the portions and professionalism needed help. Immediately he drops the victim card and tries shaming a potential return customer about something I said nothing about. Maybe spend more time addressing ways to get better instead of having to be right all the time.
Martine Dolcine
Thank you Godfather for always be on time with our orders. Best Pizza place in the Morristown area... from the staff at Morristown Post Acute 77 Madison Ave Morristown.
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Jones
Counter girl was nice. Ordered clams all bread no clams and fettucine and meatballs…sucked. Total was 41 without tip. Come on
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Lou B.
Excellent. Great food, great service. Ambiance is relaxing. Pizza is always cooked to perfection. Chicken parm is one of the best I have ever eaten.To put it into one word DELICIOUS!
Corinne Neal
Ordered on DoorDash. Everything was delicious!!!!!
Very expensive menu and pizza isn’t good at all better off ordering door dash or Uber eats for the same price and get more for your buck , food isn’t even worth the price also supervisor is very rude to customers do not
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Greg H.
We were on a road trip and picked a random town and a random restaurant to stop at for dinner. We've never been to Morristown and are from out of state and we ended up here by chance. The parking was EXTREMELY convenient for this restaurant. At 3:30ish, we were the only people in the restaurant. We ordered a sauceless pizza for our picky 8 year old, penne with marinara and meatballs, and homemade fusilli with marinara and meatballs. The portions were great, the food tasted great, and we had very quick service. We started a round of pass the pigs with our kid and they brought bread out right away. By the time we finished the bread, the food was on its way out. We never even finished our game. Thanks for great service and an enjoyable stop on a long road trip.
Alejandro Pineda
Good Pizza, not my personal favorite in Morristown but it's good. Good crust. I feel like a little more sauce would be better but that's me. Tried the Thai Wings, they were solid. The right amount of sweet and spicy. Overall very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Marie Colombo
Get the homemade pasta! Great place to go with you family. Little hot or loud depending on where you sit.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
T O.
I always find the front of house staff is unfriendly and short on the phone. . I've only had their pizza, which is subpar for the area. The margarita was undercooked, has way to much marinara sauce, and not enough mozzarella.
we went to The Godfather last Saturday about 5:30, well before the evening rush. In the past we loved every visit. Last week was not at all the same. The appetizer arrived soggy and was not hot. it was barely tepid in the middle. Both entree's were the same. Barely warm in the middle and the cheese wasn't fully melted. I can confidently say this was our last trip.
The worst cheese cake i ever had the menu on line says fresh strawberries on cheesecake i got plain with one black berry one blue berry and a ton of powered sugar pizza was cold when it arrived
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 2
This is some of the worst pizza I have ever had. It was cold, chewy, and felt like it was cooked hours ago and just sent over stale. Avoid at all costs.
Food: 1
The La Parma pizza is a must try!! It hits all the right flavors with a crispy crust. I mean it is a salad pizza and so much flavor!!
Popped in for a quick bite, meh slice nothing to write home about. $4.80 for a slice of white broccoli is insane tho. I’m assuming they’re overcharging cause of the yuppies next door in the Deloitte building.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
First I will begin by saying this is my first time going there based on a recommendation from a friend. It has a nice looking facility, and the food was prepared when I was arrived.The bread was fresh to their credit, which can make a break a sandwich. The chicken was also fresh, but was the equivalence of about 2 dinky chicken tenders topped with messy cheese and what I believe was cheap cannds sauce.When I arrived there was nobody at the register but there was a kid in pajamas hanging out behind the counter. I didn't know if I was walking into a slumber party or not. When the girl came to the register from the back, she was very friendly and asked if I was paying cash or card. I said is it the same price for both? she said YES, so I paid with card when I could have paid with cash. Turns out when I later checked my receipt, that was not the case. I do not like to get nickel and dimed or support businesses that like to charge fees for every little thing . I have plenty of options. So now I just bought a $14 sandwich that was ok, but certainly not great, and I get to my destination only to find out that I paid extra for a credit card and they didn't even include napkins. How do you charge 14 for a average to below average sandwich like that and not include napkins?I'll give them credit for using fresh bread, but I would not recommend this place.Update* This is laughable, notice the childish response on any criticism or feedback in all their reviews. Common denominator .My review was complimenting the food quality but the portions and professionalism needed help. Immediately he drops the victim card and tries shaming a potential return customer about something I said nothing about. Maybe spend more time addressing ways to get better instead of having to be right all the time.
Thank you Godfather for always be on time with our orders. Best Pizza place in the Morristown area... from the staff at Morristown Post Acute 77 Madison Ave Morristown.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Counter girl was nice. Ordered clams all bread no clams and fettucine and meatballs…sucked. Total was 41 without tip. Come on
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Excellent. Great food, great service. Ambiance is relaxing. Pizza is always cooked to perfection. Chicken parm is one of the best I have ever eaten.To put it into one word DELICIOUS!
Ordered on DoorDash. Everything was delicious!!!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Very expensive menu and pizza isn’t good at all better off ordering door dash or Uber eats for the same price and get more for your buck , food isn’t even worth the price also supervisor is very rude to customers do not
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We were on a road trip and picked a random town and a random restaurant to stop at for dinner. We've never been to Morristown and are from out of state and we ended up here by chance. The parking was EXTREMELY convenient for this restaurant. At 3:30ish, we were the only people in the restaurant. We ordered a sauceless pizza for our picky 8 year old, penne with marinara and meatballs, and homemade fusilli with marinara and meatballs. The portions were great, the food tasted great, and we had very quick service. We started a round of pass the pigs with our kid and they brought bread out right away. By the time we finished the bread, the food was on its way out. We never even finished our game. Thanks for great service and an enjoyable stop on a long road trip.
Good Pizza, not my personal favorite in Morristown but it's good. Good crust. I feel like a little more sauce would be better but that's me. Tried the Thai Wings, they were solid. The right amount of sweet and spicy. Overall very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Get the homemade pasta! Great place to go with you family. Little hot or loud depending on where you sit.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I always find the front of house staff is unfriendly and short on the phone. . I've only had their pizza, which is subpar for the area. The margarita was undercooked, has way to much marinara sauce, and not enough mozzarella.