Cherry On Top Ice Cream Shoppe

26 S Main St, Mullica Hill
(856) 417-3614

Recent Reviews

Cyndi Bonner

Very helpful and accommodating for my take-out

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sundae, Vanilla Peanut Butter

Chuck Harker

We were very disappointed. This was our first time to stop in as we were out driving around. The staff seemed as if we were an intrusion and obviously did not want to work. The hard ice cream scoops were one of the smallest I have encountered, the cone for the soft serve was not filled, rather just served around the edge of the cone, it was melting and falling off as she handed it to me and offered a cup to place it in so it wouldn’t fall in the floor, if my son had wanted a cup he would have asked for that and not a cone. Overall the location is a cute place, small candy store right inside the front door, tables outside and I felt like it had that old school charm we are missing these days. Overall bad experience, overpriced for the portions and service we received

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Suzanne A.

So glad I stopped here! It is such a a cute, little candy and ice cream shop. It's in the heart of Mullica Hill ( a fun place to walk around and explore)A small seat area is available inside with porch seating and an outside sitting area also. The staff were super friendly! I take my ice cream seriously lol and so do they. The ice cream is homemade and super delicious! I usually get soft serve but opted for hard ice creamBecause it was homemade. It did not disappoint! The cherry vanilla had good vanilla flavor with big pieces of real cherries. The Andes Mint was amazing-chocolate mint ice cream with pieces of chocolate! I was in chocolate heaven And they did a pup cup with ice cream and whipped cream!

Ken Mathis

Nice selection of hand dipped ice cream. A few tables inside in air conditioning, a couple tables in the front outside and picnic tables with umbrellas on the side. Parking in the rear, but be careful of your front end pulling in and exit if you have a low vehicle. I did make it ok going slowly with a C8.

edw zad

They had a peanutbutter hard dip, which was great. Enjoyed the place

Brian Carlton

Super nice staff! There is a candy shop connected to the ice cream shop which is nice. Several flavors of ice cream on hand, the two flavors I tried were quite tasty. My only complaint was that the scoops for my double were pretty small but the price was very reasonable so I suppose it evened out. I would definitely go there again!

Sarah Favinger

We live in town have come here for several years. Paid $8 today for a milkshake that was mostly milk terrible. If you want to charge those prices the quality should be better.

Greg Pyles

Not too many ice cream shops these days make everything from scratch with really great ingredients. This is one example of high-quality, making a superior product. Love the variety of flavors. You’ve got to try this place!

Sabrina Oppenheimer

Favorite ice cream place around. We get the ice cream cakes for every occasion. The cherry vanilla is my favorite!

Titus

This is one of the best places I've ever gone for ice cream. We go here a lot since we live within walking distance. I've even ordered a 5 gallon tub of root beer flavored ice cream, and it was amazing!!! Will go again!

Gilbert Santiago

Not inexpensive, but open all year except Jan-Feb. Excellent variety of ice cream and toppings plus scrumptious chocolate candies.

PatriciaRose McClain

My family and I have made some great memories here. They have some great ice cream flavors!! The staff is very nice and helpful!! Take your kids and make some great memories!! I highly recommend this place!!!

Theresa Vigliotta

Wish I had more to say about this place, but they're almost never open, so I'm not sure my limited experience is valuable. What ice cream shop isn't open on a summer weekend night?? First owners were awesome and their ice cream was beyond delicious. Now . . Not so much.

Bill Duffy

I had water ice , my wife ice cream both were enjoyable. Prices are reasonable and the counter person was very polite and efficient.

Jesi Chesney

I would love to give this place 5 stars because it’s in walking distance of my house but I can’t justify the price with the portion size. Every time my husband and I come he orders a large soft serve and gets charged for it and I order either a small or medium. They usually end up being the same amount of ice cream portion wise (relatively small). The large is just truly not a large compared to other nearby ice cream places and if you are paying that price it should be to the correct portion. It is very skimpy. We have been disappointed nearly every time. The staff is always nice and it’s tastes good you just do not get what you pay for sizing wise.

Load More

Cherry On Top Ice Cream Shoppe

26 S Main St, Mullica Hill, NJ 08062
(856) 417-3614