Personal opinion: My go to order has been their personal buffalo chicken pizza and pepperoni rolls. Every once in a while I venture into their fettuccine Alfredo with chicken; but so far its been about 6+ years and the flavors had been pretty solid.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Renee
Love their food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dave Parisi
Always good. Very consistent high quality food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jefe 34
Omg all i got to say my first time trying this place let me tell you there chicken bacon ranch deep dish no flop loaded with toppings best pizza i have had in a while very happy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch
Pat Hayes
Awesome old school pizzeria. It's our dinner stop before the Stanhope house.
John Cerrato
Excellent food with such reasonable prices 👌
Jay Rodriguez
Been grabbing slices here almost everyday for lunch. The pizza is amazing ! The crust has a crunchy texture on the bottom that I love and a perfect amount of shade and cheese. Try them you’ll get hooked
Big Dudes Big Foods
Joe and I decided today while we were while munching on a some delicious garlic 🧄 knots 🪢 at #JohnnyJrsPizza 🍕in #NetcongNJ that, at our age, coming home smelling like garlic 🧄 is same as coming home as a newlywed and having glitter ✨ on you. Just let your spouse know where you were. She knows you weren’t at work. 🤣🤣🤣 Anyway…we went to Johnny Jr.’s Pizza 🍕 to get a Chicken 🐓 Bacon 🥓 Ranch 🤠Deep Dish 🍕 Pizza. It was delicious, very filling and highly recommended. If you are ever in Netcong and want to support a local small business, give it a try. #BigDudesBigFoods #SupportSmallBusiness #BDBFCertified #BDBF
Audrey Fagnano
Best pizza i think I had . So good
Tim Medini
The food is really good. The prices are average . I do take out a lot and they are always on point!
I've only done delivery so can't say much about the inside dining area but the pizza is great. Definitely one of the best in the area.
Paul Copeland
My wife and i have been getting food here for years. We are both expirienced cooks and we love this food and in my opinion it's the best italian food in this area.. It's not just that they have good pizza. They have good pasta, sandwiches and more. I have never ordered something from here and been disappointed ever. When I eat pizza here, it reminds me of the first time i've eaten pizza. Order.
Raul Sarrr
Very bad kitchen. I ordered some chicken wings and they gave me burnt ones, the same as the pizza I ordered. Bad restaurant.
Nick Scutti
My family moved to Stanhope 2 years ago and have tried all the pizza joints in the area. Johnny Jr's is easily the best pizza in the area by far. The staff are all extremely friendly. Aside from the pizza, the other food is very good. Any of the chicken is delicious and apps like fried ravioli and the empanadas are also fantastic. The shop itself is small for eat-in dining but who cares when the food is great. Love these guys!
Josh
The crust on this pizza was unlike anything I've ever had! It was so crispy and flaky without being the slightest bit burnt. The nearby park was a lovely spot to sit and enjoy a slice.
Personal opinion: My go to order has been their personal buffalo chicken pizza and pepperoni rolls. Every once in a while I venture into their fettuccine Alfredo with chicken; but so far its been about 6+ years and the flavors had been pretty solid.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love their food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always good. Very consistent high quality food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Omg all i got to say my first time trying this place let me tell you there chicken bacon ranch deep dish no flop loaded with toppings best pizza i have had in a while very happy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch
Awesome old school pizzeria. It's our dinner stop before the Stanhope house.
Excellent food with such reasonable prices 👌
Been grabbing slices here almost everyday for lunch.
The pizza is amazing !
The crust has a crunchy texture on the bottom that I love and a perfect amount of shade and cheese.
Try them you’ll get hooked
Joe and I decided today while we were while munching on a some delicious garlic 🧄 knots 🪢 at #JohnnyJrsPizza 🍕in #NetcongNJ that, at our age, coming home smelling like garlic 🧄 is same as coming home as a newlywed and having glitter ✨ on you. Just let your spouse know where you were. She knows you weren’t at work. 🤣🤣🤣 Anyway…we went to Johnny Jr.’s Pizza 🍕 to get a Chicken 🐓 Bacon 🥓 Ranch 🤠Deep Dish 🍕 Pizza. It was delicious, very filling and highly recommended. If you are ever in Netcong and want to support a local small business, give it a try. #BigDudesBigFoods
#SupportSmallBusiness #BDBFCertified
#BDBF
Best pizza i think I had . So good
The food is really good. The prices are average . I do take out a lot and they are always on point!
Restaurantji Recommends
I've only done delivery so can't say much about the inside dining area but the pizza is great. Definitely one of the best in the area.
My wife and i have been getting food here for years. We are both expirienced cooks and we love this food and in my opinion it's the best italian food in this area.. It's not just that they have good pizza. They have good pasta, sandwiches and more. I have never ordered something from here and been disappointed ever. When I eat pizza here, it reminds me of the first time i've eaten pizza. Order.
Very bad kitchen. I ordered some chicken wings and they gave me burnt ones, the same as the pizza I ordered. Bad restaurant.
My family moved to Stanhope 2 years ago and have tried all the pizza joints in the area. Johnny Jr's is easily the best pizza in the area by far. The staff are all extremely friendly. Aside from the pizza, the other food is very good. Any of the chicken is delicious and apps like fried ravioli and the empanadas are also fantastic. The shop itself is small for eat-in dining but who cares when the food is great. Love these guys!
The crust on this pizza was unlike anything I've ever had! It was so crispy and flaky without being the slightest bit burnt. The nearby park was a lovely spot to sit and enjoy a slice.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Loading...