Paolo's Kitchen

162 South St, New Providence
(908) 219-4166

Recent Reviews

Vilson Borges

*GREAT RECEPTION THERE!!HE'S DEFINITELY THE KING OF THE WINGS!!I CAN ORDER ANY OPTIONS OF THE MENU ,TAST WILL BE DELICIOUS.*BUT I STILL WANT THOSE BUFFALO WINGS.HAVE YOUR OWN EXPERIENCE, I HIGHLY RECOMMEND !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Paolo's Salad, Chicken Wings, Signature Sauce Wings

Michele Vernier

Excellent Gluten Free dishes....from pie...to chicken wings....The Best!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ricardo Martin

This place sucks....or at least the wings do; and if the wings are any indication of the rest of the food....stay away. This place touts the 'best wings' anywhere...they are bready, mushy, tasteless and gross. Frozen wings from Acme are better. Really, really bad, really bad.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Robin S.

The King wings were horrible nothing but fat. When I said something to the gentleman, he said that's the way they came, but if they came into my store, that way, I would've refused them. What a waste of $20

Aditya Kaveria

Empanadas and fries were amazing. Limited seating.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Joanna Sasso

Best Sesame chicken salad - and the "crack" dressing hits every time!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bethany Kelly

We have ordered from Paolo's Kitchen numerous times for lunch at work and the food has been really good. But today, was a different story. Sandwiches not as requested with dressing on side, salad wilted and not fresh at all, and the split pea soup was literally pea flavored water for $9! Unless you like not getting your $$$ worth, I would not recommend Paolo's Kitchen anymore. Sad, just sad. :-(

Js M.

It was far from a favorable experience to say the least. Not the King of Wings. Closer to court jester The sauces lacked flavor the wings themselves were not crisp, over breaded actually. Very disappointing.

Stephen Sottile

Eggplant Rollatini! Korean chicken wings ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Ravioli, Chicken Francese, Eggplant Rollantini, Signature Sauce Wings

J J.

Buyer Beware- Had the very unpleasant experience of trying the following wings: BBQ, Buffalo and the Famous Balsamic "crack" Dressing wings.There are so many things wrong, I don't know where to begin... The breading on the pre cooked frozen wings was rubbery and mushy... most likely they purchased a very cheap quality wing from Restaurant Depot. The Balsamic "crack" dressing was truly awful, there was no discernible flavor, we couldn't eat them. The Buffalo wings had a hint of flavor which was disappointing as was the BBQ wings. The blue cheese dressing served on the side was watered down, again probably a cheap, poor quality dressing, it was so loose it barely clung to the wings. We also ordered the eggplant rolatini which was bland, flavorless and lackluster.In closing the so called "wing king" got our money once but I can assure you never again!

Jermaine Wilkinson

Didn't wow like I thought! Typically when you see little shops, the food is bafflingly mind-blowing! Kinda underwhelmed. Naked wing option would be nice. The wings were heavily breaded.Kid-friendliness: It's a small venue so there is a little bench outside near a grassy area where you can hangout with the kids and or dog

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Cheese Fries, Signature Sauce Wings

Addolorata “Dee” Hook

Ordered cheesesteaks for pickup. No cheese on any of the steaks and barely any steak. Not the same as the prior owners. Very disappointed

Dolores Hook

Ordered cheesesteaks for pickup. No cheese on any of the steaks and barely any steak. Not the same as the prior owners. Very disappointed

Todd Cooper

Found this Hidden Gem unexpectedly...I came for good food and left with some powerful life lessons, Great Food and even a crash course on how to make garlic, butter lemon sauce. May GOD bless you, your family, everyone and everything you touch Chef Paolo!! Great job ????Looking forward to ordering from your restaurant on GOLD BELLYGODSPEED

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Meatball Parm

Damian D.

Pretty much anything for everyone. Excellent American Buffalo wings, reliable Tex Mex, toothsome Italian-but Sabrett canned onions in clam chowder? That I don't get.

Load More