I used to deliver for this place and I was very close with the head chef, who is a very passionate man when it comes to his profession as a Chef and head cook of this restaurant/kitchen side of the "Restaurant and Pizzeria." You see, there's two sets of doors for this fine establishment.Okay, technically, there are 3 sets of doors that are open to the public to enter and exit! The restaurant side doesn't open until later in the day, obviously. However, when you walk into the restaurant, it's like you've entered an entirely different place! The atmosphere is immeasurably different from that of the Pizzeria on the other side with its booths and pizza window!However, I must add that as a full-time resident of this fine town? It's not quite what it used to be. Maybe that might change since spring has picked up, and summer will be in full swing before we know it!The pizzeria is busy during all seasons! The restaurant does have an amazing N.Y. Strip Steak and a brilliant rib-eye if I'm not mistaken! Then their seafood is apparently delicious! I'm biased since I'm not big on seafood. But it does look good! All-in-all, I'd recommend trying the pizza at least once!Their specialty pizzas are good. They have a very good white cheesesteak pizza, too. Oh! Their white pizza, in general, is amazing. I used to take some home after my shift. I'm weird, though, so I'd throw some pepperoni and pineapple on it before heating the slices.This is a place you need to try for yourself to have a decent opinion. The pizza is great. They even do parties and cater to parties. I'm quite certain to an extent. Okay, I'll end here since I left a mino-novella! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
David Kerr
Ordered tuna hoagie, fries, chicken Caesar salad. Tuna is white albacore. Really good hoagie. Chicken ceaser salad was also good. Lettuce crisp and chicken well seasoned. Fries were crisp and good.You get disappointed a lot around Cape May. Horrible food, outrageous prices.NOT HERE!!!! This is a good spot. Thank you for caring about your customers!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DED Company
Great place and delicious food. My kids insist on ordering food from here every time we're in cape may.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeanette Eckert-Givens
Great cheesesteaks !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak
Joseph Zawislak Jr.
Small pepperoni pizza 5 days in a row best pizza in58 yearsVegetarian options: Pizza white pie vegetarian wife loves it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
Ed Leo
Always Great!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Pizzas, Sandwiches
Gary Landis
Typical piazza restaurant with all the right things on there menu. Take-out or
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Edward. J Antonelly
Great for lunch when visited.. the crab bisque soap and their spin on a grilled cheese sandwich was really good. When ordering the Seafood crab soup.its an upcharge in your entrée. I found the Staff was friendly. not much seating available for larger crowds . the place needs to open the whole area because of being to small as it would accommodate more and give a better atmosphere other than a pick up and take out atmosphere it shows now than the few tables available in the front .. Booths would be the answer here.Kid-friendliness: Would be great if the seating would accommodate more people and high chairs are needed.Wheelchair accessibility: None available.
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Caesar Salad, Italian, Cheese Fries
Tanja Hansen
I ordered a chicken Caesar salad and asked for the chicken to not have any seasoning on it due to food Intolerances. They said they could not accommodate me due to the fact that all the chicken is pre cooked for the Salads. Really they could not cook me a plain Piece of chicken. That is Ridiculous and they just lost business and my family’s future orders.
I don’t know who needs to hear this, but I ordered 2 pizzas at 5pm for a delivery at 7pm for a football game. The whole point of ordering 2 hours ahead, was so the pizza would arrive before my guests. But, the pizza didn’t arrive. I called twice, the second time was 7:30pm, when I telephoned “Italian Affair Pizza and Pasta” in North Cape May, NJ. and asked where my delivery was, I was told the pizza was on the way, and without an apology, they rudely hung up me. The pizza arrived at 7:35pm. An apology would’ve gone a long way, instead I received cold pizza. Again, I don’t know who needs to hear this, but the whole point of ordering the pizza in advance is so that it arrives in a timely fashion, but at least, apologize. But what you don’t do is hang up on the paying customer.
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Mike
Best pizza and people in New Jersey! Recommend trying their signature Grandma's s pizza. Also, dough is made fresh daily for pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cory Balliet
Only got take out, but the pizza was very good. Great sauce, not overloaded with cheese, but for me, the dough/crust is what takes pizza to the next level, and these guys have a very well executed New York style. Relatively thin, but still thick enough to have that nice soft chewy texture, but cooked at the right temp to have the crisp, crunch on the outside. I would certainly make this a regular spot if I lived in the area.Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza, salads, fries.Parking: Part of a strip mall. Tons of parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lucia Francavilla
I use to go here years ago and I remember it was really good. I just revisited this place as of Aug 3rd 2023 since 2019. I couldn’t wait to sit down have a nice dinner. If I could give this place a zero I would??? I ordered Chicken marsala!!!The chicken was thick, hard and extremely chewy. ? They gave me a tin container and it’s look like masala soup with mushrooms. I looked at the chicken. It was literally two whole breast, not cut and grilled.. Who grills chicken for masala. Any smart chef would know if you grill it it’s going to be tough and chewy. Then tossed it a what I calls soup masala. did not even cook the chicken with the masala sauce. In all my year, this was by far the worst chicken marsala I’ve had in my life.. I literally filled myself up with bread and the masala sauce soup. I told the front counter girl, and the man that was working behind the counter that I was unhappy with this order.. His only answer to resolve this matter was that he will let The Cook know. Who does that in the restaurant industry. No one ever offered me anything else or any compensation for what I ordered.. they did nothing and just let me walk out the door. Didn’t even apologize. If he handled the situation in a different manner, I would’ve reconsidered coming back and trying something else but just the way it was handled was completely stupid and foolish on his part. Now when people tell me about this place I will tell they don’t eat there and they will tell 10 others and that’s how you loose business. Some people just don’t belong in the restaurant industry and have zero common sense.I literally tossed the food in the trash. A $23.00 lesson learned and I will never go back. I give it zero stars if I could!!!Don’t wast your money and go to Little Itaily in wildwood crest get early bird special from 4pm to 5pm. Food is amazing and really good service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Neil
Food never showed up , was told it gets there when it gets there . They have a bad attitude won’t order from there
I used to deliver for this place and I was very close with the head chef, who is a very passionate man when it comes to his profession as a Chef and head cook of this restaurant/kitchen side of the "Restaurant and Pizzeria." You see, there's two sets of doors for this fine establishment.Okay, technically, there are 3 sets of doors that are open to the public to enter and exit! The restaurant side doesn't open until later in the day, obviously. However, when you walk into the restaurant, it's like you've entered an entirely different place! The atmosphere is immeasurably different from that of the Pizzeria on the other side with its booths and pizza window!However, I must add that as a full-time resident of this fine town? It's not quite what it used to be. Maybe that might change since spring has picked up, and summer will be in full swing before we know it!The pizzeria is busy during all seasons! The restaurant does have an amazing N.Y. Strip Steak and a brilliant rib-eye if I'm not mistaken! Then their seafood is apparently delicious! I'm biased since I'm not big on seafood. But it does look good! All-in-all, I'd recommend trying the pizza at least once!Their specialty pizzas are good. They have a very good white cheesesteak pizza, too. Oh! Their white pizza, in general, is amazing. I used to take some home after my shift. I'm weird, though, so I'd throw some pepperoni and pineapple on it before heating the slices.This is a place you need to try for yourself to have a decent opinion. The pizza is great. They even do parties and cater to parties. I'm quite certain to an extent. Okay, I'll end here since I left a mino-novella! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Ordered tuna hoagie, fries, chicken Caesar salad. Tuna is white albacore. Really good hoagie. Chicken ceaser salad was also good. Lettuce crisp and chicken well seasoned. Fries were crisp and good.You get disappointed a lot around Cape May. Horrible food, outrageous prices.NOT HERE!!!! This is a good spot. Thank you for caring about your customers!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place and delicious food. My kids insist on ordering food from here every time we're in cape may.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great cheesesteaks !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak
Small pepperoni pizza 5 days in a row best pizza in58 yearsVegetarian options: Pizza white pie vegetarian wife loves it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
Always Great!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Pizzas, Sandwiches
Typical piazza restaurant with all the right things on there menu. Take-out or
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Great for lunch when visited.. the crab bisque soap and their spin on a grilled cheese sandwich was really good. When ordering the Seafood crab soup.its an upcharge in your entrée. I found the Staff was friendly. not much seating available for larger crowds . the place needs to open the whole area because of being to small as it would accommodate more and give a better atmosphere other than a pick up and take out atmosphere it shows now than the few tables available in the front .. Booths would be the answer here.Kid-friendliness: Would be great if the seating would accommodate more people and high chairs are needed.Wheelchair accessibility: None available.
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Caesar Salad, Italian, Cheese Fries
I ordered a chicken Caesar salad and asked for the chicken to not have any seasoning on it due to food Intolerances. They said they could not accommodate me due to the fact that all the chicken is pre cooked for the Salads. Really they could not cook me a plain Piece of chicken. That is Ridiculous and they just lost business and my family’s future orders.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great food great people,a local staple for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Cheese Steak
Restaurantji Recommends
I don’t know who needs to hear this, but I ordered 2 pizzas at 5pm for a delivery at 7pm for a football game. The whole point of ordering 2 hours ahead, was so the pizza would arrive before my guests. But, the pizza didn’t arrive. I called twice, the second time was 7:30pm, when I telephoned “Italian Affair Pizza and Pasta” in North Cape May, NJ. and asked where my delivery was, I was told the pizza was on the way, and without an apology, they rudely hung up me. The pizza arrived at 7:35pm. An apology would’ve gone a long way, instead I received cold pizza. Again, I don’t know who needs to hear this, but the whole point of ordering the pizza in advance is so that it arrives in a timely fashion, but at least, apologize. But what you don’t do is hang up on the paying customer.
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Best pizza and people in New Jersey! Recommend trying their signature Grandma's s pizza. Also, dough is made fresh daily for pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Only got take out, but the pizza was very good. Great sauce, not overloaded with cheese, but for me, the dough/crust is what takes pizza to the next level, and these guys have a very well executed New York style. Relatively thin, but still thick enough to have that nice soft chewy texture, but cooked at the right temp to have the crisp, crunch on the outside. I would certainly make this a regular spot if I lived in the area.Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza, salads, fries.Parking: Part of a strip mall. Tons of parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I use to go here years ago and I remember it was really good. I just revisited this place as of Aug 3rd 2023 since 2019. I couldn’t wait to sit down have a nice dinner. If I could give this place a zero I would??? I ordered Chicken marsala!!!The chicken was thick, hard and extremely chewy. ? They gave me a tin container and it’s look like masala soup with mushrooms. I looked at the chicken. It was literally two whole breast, not cut and grilled.. Who grills chicken for masala. Any smart chef would know if you grill it it’s going to be tough and chewy. Then tossed it a what I calls soup masala. did not even cook the chicken with the masala sauce. In all my year, this was by far the worst chicken marsala I’ve had in my life.. I literally filled myself up with bread and the masala sauce soup. I told the front counter girl, and the man that was working behind the counter that I was unhappy with this order.. His only answer to resolve this matter was that he will let The Cook know. Who does that in the restaurant industry. No one ever offered me anything else or any compensation for what I ordered.. they did nothing and just let me walk out the door. Didn’t even apologize. If he handled the situation in a different manner, I would’ve reconsidered coming back and trying something else but just the way it was handled was completely stupid and foolish on his part. Now when people tell me about this place I will tell they don’t eat there and they will tell 10 others and that’s how you loose business. Some people just don’t belong in the restaurant industry and have zero common sense.I literally tossed the food in the trash. A $23.00 lesson learned and I will never go back. I give it zero stars if I could!!!Don’t wast your money and go to Little Itaily in wildwood crest get early bird special from 4pm to 5pm. Food is amazing and really good service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Food never showed up , was told it gets there when it gets there . They have a bad attitude won’t order from there
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread