Ordered a Grandma pizza, first time there. Pizza did not resemble or taste like any grandma pizza I ever had. The crust looked like a frozen pie. Taste was not good. Kid was friendly and attentive at the register.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Jasmin Matthews
Delicious as usual. They have the best sauce.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Funk
Great food great prices. My New go to spot.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sam
Best American pizza I've had in my life. It has been my favorite ever since I was a child. I've moved around multiple times now and nothing comes close. The buffalo chicken pizza, the muscles, the everything. Their side items are not made like side items. They deserve more business. I hope they never close. Classic hole in the wall place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Josue Camey
excellent ?
Food: 5
WPU
Pizza was fresh with all the toppings...but very little sauce?
Food: 2
Service: 5
Scram___ Trashcan
Hello, My name is Mordecai Obsidian, and This food was absolutely delectable, not only that, but the other options on the menu were extremely insanity………………..in a good way LOL!!!
Mark S.
This was my first visit to Anthony & Mario's. It was a Tuesday at 11:45am. I didn't expect to see a staircase once I opened the door. I made my way to the speakeasy-looking basement and found a pizzaeria. I ordered the Peppers & Onions Marinara Linguini pasta. I enjoyed my meal while watching and listening to a former president being arrested on Fox News. I also received some warm bread. I thought my lunch was great. I added a slice of pizza. Only cheese pizza is available for slices. It's smaller than the gigantic slices you may find in nyc.
Narguis Benyamin
Best pizzeria in North Haledon. Everything is delicious and prices are great.
Julia Zele
We just moved to North Haledon and were very excited to try out the local restaurants. The prices at Anthony’s and Mario’s are reasonable and the pizza was ready quickly, but the pie itself tasted a little bland. The large cheese pie was $10 and we were charged $2 for the pepperoni on the half. There was also an additional 3.5% surcharge for using a credit card. So overall it does add up, but still not as expensive as other places that we’ve been to.
Authentic Italian Pizzeria ✅Pizza sauce and cheese taste amazing ✅Prices are great ✅Friendly and Familylike staff and treatment ✅Addictive pizza And I’m going to gain weight ✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅Simply amazing
An Unoriginal Excuse For Unhidden Agenda
Authentic Italian Pizzeria ✅Pizza sauce and cheese taste amazing ✅Prices are great ✅Friendly and Familylike staff and treatment ✅Addictive pizza And I’m going to gain weight ✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅Simply amazing
Sean F.
Nice finding this little spot first time coming to the town. Food is good definitely worth checking out and making your own opinion about the food, but it is good for me!
Stephanie S.
This is our go to place for pizza! Affordable and delicious! Consistently great food!
Omar Abbassi
One of my 2 favorite local pizza places. Good Pizza. Haven’t ordered anything else on the menu, but one of the goto places in the area when my kids ask for Pizza.
Ordered a Grandma pizza, first time there. Pizza did not resemble or taste like any grandma pizza I ever had. The crust looked like a frozen pie. Taste was not good. Kid was friendly and attentive at the register.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Delicious as usual. They have the best sauce.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food great prices. My New go to spot.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best American pizza I've had in my life. It has been my favorite ever since I was a child. I've moved around multiple times now and nothing comes close. The buffalo chicken pizza, the muscles, the everything. Their side items are not made like side items. They deserve more business. I hope they never close. Classic hole in the wall place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
excellent ?
Food: 5
Pizza was fresh with all the toppings...but very little sauce?
Food: 2
Service: 5
Hello, My name is Mordecai Obsidian, and This food was absolutely delectable, not only that, but the other options on the menu were extremely insanity………………..in a good way LOL!!!
This was my first visit to Anthony & Mario's. It was a Tuesday at 11:45am. I didn't expect to see a staircase once I opened the door. I made my way to the speakeasy-looking basement and found a pizzaeria. I ordered the Peppers & Onions Marinara Linguini pasta. I enjoyed my meal while watching and listening to a former president being arrested on Fox News. I also received some warm bread. I thought my lunch was great. I added a slice of pizza. Only cheese pizza is available for slices. It's smaller than the gigantic slices you may find in nyc.
Best pizzeria in North Haledon. Everything is delicious and prices are great.
We just moved to North Haledon and were very excited to try out the local restaurants. The prices at Anthony’s and Mario’s are reasonable and the pizza was ready quickly, but the pie itself tasted a little bland. The large cheese pie was $10 and we were charged $2 for the pepperoni on the half. There was also an additional 3.5% surcharge for using a credit card. So overall it does add up, but still not as expensive as other places that we’ve been to.
Restaurantji Recommends
Authentic Italian Pizzeria ✅Pizza sauce and cheese taste amazing ✅Prices are great ✅Friendly and Familylike staff and treatment ✅Addictive pizza And I’m going to gain weight ✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅Simply amazing
Authentic Italian Pizzeria ✅Pizza sauce and cheese taste amazing ✅Prices are great ✅Friendly and Familylike staff and treatment ✅Addictive pizza And I’m going to gain weight ✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅Simply amazing
Nice finding this little spot first time coming to the town. Food is good definitely worth checking out and making your own opinion about the food, but it is good for me!
This is our go to place for pizza! Affordable and delicious! Consistently great food!
One of my 2 favorite local pizza places. Good Pizza. Haven’t ordered anything else on the menu, but one of the goto places in the area when my kids ask for Pizza.