I love it! Nice place, and good ice cream, lots of topping options.
N Sholakh
Hands down best ice cream ice ever had, especially the cotton candy flavor. Not too sweet, it was just right. Customer service was good.
Rhainnon Pfeiffer
Sprinkles are always free :)
Alexa G.
The ice cream here is the best ice cream in the area! They have a wide variety of flavors and all of them are great. With that being said, the service from the staff is AWFUL! I am a frequent customer, and I receive the same rude, unfriendly attitude every time. The staff acts as if you are bothering them from the time you walk in. It is unfortunate because the ice cream is good.
Lindsey Almeida
Large portions and a great variety of flavors.
Jose Amielle
Very yummmy ice cream!Employee are great!
Jessica Panicucci-Miras
I am very disappointed in the level of service that I received from Hometown Creamery. I am not sure if I am to blame the staff or the owners. I reached out via phone several times to both locations inquiring about their ice cream cart for private that was pictured on their website. The staff didn't have any information on it and told me they would text the owners with my contact information so that they could call me and discuss the details. Well, it took 3 tries - phone calls to the store then a text from the staff to the owner - before I finally got a call back from the owners. Once I did, we discussed the details and I was told I would receive an email with what we discussed and some additional information including flavor options by the end of the day. When that email didn't come, I opted to book someone else because I feared that they were so unreliable up until this point, what happens if they don't show the day of the event?! On top of that, their ice cream in store is very expensive, which I didn't mind paying for because they were local, but after the experience I had, I will be going elsewhere for better ice cream at a more reasonable price.
Patricia Katz
A great find, glad we tried it. The variety of flavors was impressive and all were very happy with their ice creams. I tried Oatmeal Cookie and Cookie Monster. There was a good amount of 'stuff' in my flavors and the ice cream itself was very creamy and flavorful. The prices were very fair and noticeably cheaper than nearby competitors. This will be our new spot. Staff was friendly too!
Gi L
All I can say is WOW, WOW, WOW!!! Super creamy and delicious!! Creative flavor combinations (they are all good), generous portions, clean shop, cute cow motif, attentive service and reasonable pricing - BEST OF ALL TRULY HOMEMADE and family owned. I drive up from Florida 2x a year & this will definitely be a 'MUST STOP' place for me!!! Love ❤️ it!!!
Gina Lucio
Came in summer from Florida and stumbled into this little hole the wall gourmet ice shop. The variety was great but the creaminess blew me away. Came to find out it REALLY is HOMEMADE churned DAILY!!! Took an ice cream cake back to Miami and got rave reviews. This location is closed for winter but just visited their Wayne location & AGAIN BLOWN AWAY. Never had such delicious hot chocolate from an ice cream shop. Definitely first stop I'll make whenever I'm in Jersey. Need to deliver to Miami!!!
Closed for the season but google / website says they are open
Chris Funk
The ice cream here is amazing.
Tara Lober
love coming here with my family. My girls are young and always make a mess and the staff always helps us clean up and makes the experience extra special for them. Greatest addition to our little town!
Rachel Malpica
Love this spot. Awesome flavors and the staff is so friendly!
Denise Sinatra
Delicious, unusual and favorite flavors. Very clean, and the staff is very friendly ?
I love it! Nice place, and good ice cream, lots of topping options.
Hands down best ice cream ice ever had, especially the cotton candy flavor. Not too sweet, it was just right. Customer service was good.
Sprinkles are always free :)
The ice cream here is the best ice cream in the area! They have a wide variety of flavors and all of them are great. With that being said, the service from the staff is AWFUL! I am a frequent customer, and I receive the same rude, unfriendly attitude every time. The staff acts as if you are bothering them from the time you walk in. It is unfortunate because the ice cream is good.
Large portions and a great variety of flavors.
Very yummmy ice cream!Employee are great!
I am very disappointed in the level of service that I received from Hometown Creamery. I am not sure if I am to blame the staff or the owners. I reached out via phone several times to both locations inquiring about their ice cream cart for private that was pictured on their website. The staff didn't have any information on it and told me they would text the owners with my contact information so that they could call me and discuss the details. Well, it took 3 tries - phone calls to the store then a text from the staff to the owner - before I finally got a call back from the owners. Once I did, we discussed the details and I was told I would receive an email with what we discussed and some additional information including flavor options by the end of the day. When that email didn't come, I opted to book someone else because I feared that they were so unreliable up until this point, what happens if they don't show the day of the event?! On top of that, their ice cream in store is very expensive, which I didn't mind paying for because they were local, but after the experience I had, I will be going elsewhere for better ice cream at a more reasonable price.
A great find, glad we tried it. The variety of flavors was impressive and all were very happy with their ice creams. I tried Oatmeal Cookie and Cookie Monster. There was a good amount of 'stuff' in my flavors and the ice cream itself was very creamy and flavorful. The prices were very fair and noticeably cheaper than nearby competitors. This will be our new spot. Staff was friendly too!
All I can say is WOW, WOW, WOW!!! Super creamy and delicious!! Creative flavor combinations (they are all good), generous portions, clean shop, cute cow motif, attentive service and reasonable pricing - BEST OF ALL TRULY HOMEMADE and family owned. I drive up from Florida 2x a year & this will definitely be a 'MUST STOP' place for me!!! Love ❤️ it!!!
Came in summer from Florida and stumbled into this little hole the wall gourmet ice shop. The variety was great but the creaminess blew me away. Came to find out it REALLY is HOMEMADE churned DAILY!!! Took an ice cream cake back to Miami and got rave reviews. This location is closed for winter but just visited their Wayne location & AGAIN BLOWN AWAY. Never had such delicious hot chocolate from an ice cream shop. Definitely first stop I'll make whenever I'm in Jersey. Need to deliver to Miami!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Closed for the season but google / website says they are open
The ice cream here is amazing.
love coming here with my family. My girls are young and always make a mess and the staff always helps us clean up and makes the experience extra special for them. Greatest addition to our little town!
Love this spot. Awesome flavors and the staff is so friendly!
Delicious, unusual and favorite flavors. Very clean, and the staff is very friendly ?