Krispy Pizza - Old Bridge, NJ

9/12/25 - While running errands, the dinner bell in my stomach rang. I have driven by Krispy Pizza in Old Bridge, NJ hundreds of times and tonight I was determined to stop. Krispy markets their Brooklyn heritage the minute you walk in. There's pictures of Brooklyn pasted all over the walls. But before you even get to that, the parking situation will remind you of Brooklyn. The lot is ridiculously small with cars and trucks lined up wherever they can fit in hopes of grabbing the next available spot. I personally think the name Krispy Pizza is a bit silly for a shop that wants you to associate them with Brooklyn but I wont hold that against them. After God smiles upon you with a spot, you head into a mob scene. No one directs you where to order. The people waiting by the counter run two to three deep. Almost everyone is shaking their heads in frustration. Its impossible to know who already ordered, who phoned in, who is waiting to place an order and where you should be standing. And there are no tables to be had. I literally asked a waitress for help. After finally placing our order, we noticed they weren't putting our slices in the oven. Why? The ovens were full. After another 15 minutes, the waitress directed me to a table while my son stayed behind to secure the order. This is where the bad ends however. The pizza is delightful and with the first bite, you understand why all these people are here and putting up with a terrible dining experience. The pizza is that good. I had a plain neopolitan, a Palermo Sicilian and a Tri-Color Sicilian. The plain is crunchy and flavorful. Nothing but premium ingredients here. It was cooked well and not dry at all. The tri-color Sicilian had great Sicilian flavor as well. The unexpected flavor here is pesto. Although I didn't expect pesto, it absolutely works and adds another level of flavor to an already wonderful slice. But my favorite by far was the Palermo Sicilian. The sauce is a flavor bomb of tomatoes, onions and garlic. It's the top right one in the slice picture. And both Sicilian slices have that fantastic Sicilian flavored crust. I gave the place heavy deductions for the parking, ordering and seating experience which is nothing less than stressful. The only way to fix this is by getting a new spacious location with big parking lot. Overall Rating: B+

Stopped for a slice as I seen it repeatedly on Tic Toc. The pizza crust was outstanding… thin lite and crispy . Perfect combo of tasty sauce and cheese . Busy place with very friendly outstanding service .. very clean . Will definitely pass about 10 other places to come here again .. worth the 20 minute drive ! Thank you !

Food is always so yummy here!

I was craving the pinwheels, unfortunately mine were serviced cold and burnt they tasted a few days old no sauce on the top so it tasted very dry, I ordered a fresh pie and it was very good and the service was very attentive I enjoyed it just wished the pinwheels weren’t a let down

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

So worth the 1.5 hour drive! My husband follows Krispy Pizza on YouTube and he just had to try their pizza. He started work at 2am and decided after work he wanted to take me there, and he goes back to work at 2am Sunday, this tells you how much he wanted to come here! Honestly, the best pizza I've ever had, 13th Ave pizza wow, the best (that's the name of the pie), so many choices for vegetarians like me! The staff was so kind, Jonathan had a really good time talking with them. We have a long drive back with a trunk full of pizza, of course we had to bring some home! We have a long drive back but again so worth the drive! Thank you for great food and service!

So worth the 1.5 hour drive! My husband follows Krispy Pizza on YouTube and he just had to try their pizza. He started work at 2am and decided after work he wanted to take me there, and he goes back to work at 2am Sunday, this tells you how much he wanted to come here! Honestly, the best pizza I've ever had, 13th Ave pizza wow, the best (that's the name of the pie), so many choices for vegetarians like me! The staff was so kind, Jonathan had a really good time talking with them. We have a long drive back with a trunk full of pizza, of course we had to bring some home! We have a long drive back but again so worth the drive! Thank you for great food and service!

We often go here to eat lunch/dinner. All OBHS kids go here, and it seems to be OB favorite restaurant. They have generous entree portions. The appetizer (fried calamari) is very good. We never skip that every time we come here. I ordered a 10" hot sandwich hero (chicken parm w/vodka sauce) that didn't come with any sides 😒. When the sandwich came out on a plate, I looked at it and said to myself, "Where's the chicken filet?" It had a few small pieces of thin breaded chicken and parmigian cheese and vodka sauce in the middle of the split open hero bread. The chicken filet was thin and dried. I took the other 1/2 home and had it for lunch the next day, added 2 pieces of blackened pepper chicken strips.

I think with the recent price hike of chicken, my sandwich didn't get much meat. 🫤 Could have been better if it came with fries.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari

Grandma square was very tasty !

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

I love the regular cheese slides. Crispy and delicious. There are also many other pizza topping choices, just as good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It's my favorite go-to pizza place in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Decide to stop by this location on my New Jersey pizza tour. Very nice pizzeria. Very clean. Lots of selections for slices. Friendly staff Pizza was good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

I’ve given this place a chance several times and it’s been disappointing every time. The food/ingredients aren’t fresh at all, it is easy to tell. Only thing I thought was ok was the garlic knots. Won’t return

No Works... Sucks!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Great food. One regrettable thing is they are always busy. Everyone wants some krispy pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best vodka sauce and service you'll find in the area. Always high quality.