Butterworths Bagel Bakery
50 Bi State Plaza, Old Tappan
(201) 666-8111
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Marble Crumb Cake
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Sausage Egg & Cheese
Bagel with Butter
Cinnamon Roll
Breakfast Sandwiches
Sausage and Cheese
Double sausage & double cheese
Taylor Ham and Cheese Sandwich
Loaded with extra Taylor ham and double cheese
BOBO
Double egg, bacon, cheese, hash browns, on a bagel, roll, or wrap.
2 Eggs Sandwich
Double fried eggs
Bacon and Cheese Sandwich
6 strips of Boar's Head bacon with melted double American cheese
Sausage Egg and Cheese
Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich
3 strips of hotel grade bacon.
Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Double egg and cheese
Taylor Ham, Egg and Cheese Sandwich
3 slices of trenton pork rolls
Steak Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Signature Sandwiches
B.L.T
6 strips of hotel grade bacons with iceberg lettuce and tomatoes.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken Caesar Salad Wrap
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
On a Toasted Rye bread Brooklyn Style boar's head pastrami with Swiss cheese melted with mustard.
Hot Roast Beef Special Sandwich
With fresh mozzarella and roasted red pepper on toasted garlic roll.
Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Thinly sliced sirloin steaks with melted american cheese with sauted onions and bell peppers
on a long roll.
Turkey Club Sandwich
Thinly Sliced oven gold turkey With bacon, lettuce, tomato on 3 layered white toast.
Italian Bomber Sandwich
Boar's head Deluxe ham, pepperoni, salami and provolone with roasted peppers, red onion, lettuce, tomato with oil and vinegar on a hero bread.
Bagel with Spreads
Bagel w/ Butter and Jelly
Mini Bagel w/ Butter
Mini Bagel w/ Cream Cheese
Muffin
Muffin w/ Butter
Bagel w/ Lox Cream Cheese
Bagel w/ Butter
Bagel w/ Cream Cheese
Bagel w/ Fresh Nova and Cream Cheese
Nova scotia freshly sliced with cream cheese
Breakfast Specials
Protein Wrap
4 egg whites, spinach, Boar's head oven gold turkey, onion and green peppers.
Breakfast Burrito
3 eggs, sauteed onions & green peppers, home fries and ham.
Omelettes
Spinach Omelette
Western Omellettes
Grilled onions and pepper with sliced ham.
Hash Browns
Meat and Cheese Omelette
Big Breakfast Platter
2 eggs any style with Bacon or Sausage or Ham & Hash Brown and buttered toast.
Bagels
Bagel
Plain Poppy Sesame Cinn-Raisin Everything Whole Wheat Egg Pumper Nickel Marble Rye wholewheat everything
Cream Cheese by 1/2 Pound
8oz Container of our Freshly made Cream Cheeses Plain , Scallion, Vegetable, Olive, Strawberry, Lox Spread, Cucumber & Dills
Nova Lox by 1/4 Pound
1/4 lb Nova (smoked salmon from Brooklyn) Freshly sliced.
Philladelphia Whipped Plain Cream Cheese
8 oz. packed Philadelphia whipped cream cheese.
Breakstone Butter
8oz whipped butter.
Nova Lox & Cream Cheese sandwich
Nova (smoked salmon from Brooklyn) Freshly sliced. ** picture shown is nova & cream cheese sandwich, please select it on bagels with spreads section **
Salad by lb.
Tuna Salad (1/2 Pound)
1/2 lb. of tuna
Egg Salad (1/2 Pound)
Egg salad by 1/2 lb.
Chicken Salad (1/2 Pound)
Classic Sandwiches
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Our slowly oven cooked Chicken Breast.
Turkey Sandwich
Boar's Head Oven gold turkey with lettuce and tomatoes on our Rainbow Bagel.
Roast Beef Sandwich
Our oven baked Fresh Boar's Head Roast Beef.
Egg Salad Sandwich
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
Tuna Sandwich
Albacore white tuna and tongol tuna salad
Bologna Sandwich
Ham Sandwich
Boar's Head deluxe ham
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Albacore white tuna and tongol tuna salad
Cheese Sandwich
Salads
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Romaine, lettuce, mesculine, Bermuda onions, croutons and Parmesan cheese topped with grilled chicken cutlet.
Garden Salad
Mix greens, tomato, cumber, green pepper and onion.
Traditional Greek Salad
Mixed field greens, diced cucumber, ripe tomato, Bermuda onions, Kalamata olives and crumbled feta cheese.
Borderline Remedies
Yogurt Parfair
Low fat vanilla yogurt. Mixed Fruits
Fruit Cup
16 oz. Fresh fruits seasonal changes on choices: watermelon, cantaloupe, honey dew, pineapples
Potato Chips
Frito Lay
1.5 - 1.75 oz. bags
Sweet Desserts
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Cinnamon Roll
Plain Croissant
Plain Crumb Cake
Chocolate Marble Crumb Cake
Black & White Cookies
Plain Pound Cake
Marble Pound Cake
Breakfast for the Group
Baker's Dozen
Please choose 13 bagels from the following flavors: plain, sesame, poppy, everything, whole wheat, whole wheat everything, pretzel salt, onion, cinnamon raisin.
Baker's Dozen Value Pack
includes 2 tubs of 1/2 lb cream cheese.
Butterworth Bagel Platter
15 assorted bagels, 6 assorted pastries with 2 tubs of cream cheese and butter. serves up to 20.
Beverages
Reg/De-Caf Coffee
Ice Coffee Reg Small
Ice Coffee Reg Large
Tropicana Juice
12 oz. bottle
Soda 20 oz
Snapple
16 oz. bottle all natural
Strawberry Smoothie
Fresh made strawberry smoothie 16 oz.
Nesquik Chocolate
14 oz. bottle
Poland Spring
Gatorade
20 oz. bottle
Vitamin Water
Red bull reg size
Tropicana Family Size
1/2 gallon original 100% pure juice bottle
Naked Juice
Natural 15.2 oz. bottle
V8
Original 100% vegetable juice 12oz. bottle
Yoohoo
16 oz. bottle
Half & Half
cream o land quart size.
Passion Fruit Ade
Ice cold fresh made Strawberry ade 20oz
Strawberry ade
Ice cold Fresh made Strawberry ade 20 oz
Hot Chocolate
Strawberry & Banana Smoothie
Fresh made strawberry and banana smoothie
Milk
Pint valley farm regular milk
Photos
+53 photos
+52 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This place has a really good bagels and not only bagels any choice is delicious. It is clean. Service is fast, attendees are knowledgeable and highly professionals.
This is a place to visit and go again.
This is a place to visit and go again.
May 2025
Good breakfast spot.... they obviously make great bagels or they wouldn't still be in business.... their prices are good..... i like the smoked salmon with onions, capers and cream cheese.... but bacon egg and cheese is solid
January 2025
You May Also Like
MOOYAH Burgers, Fries & Shakes - 216 Old Tappan Rd Ste 1C
![]()
Hamburger, Burgers, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Gluten-Free, Vegan
La Bona Pizza - 216 Old Tappan Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian
Hoshitori Sushi & Ramen - 216 Old Tappan Rd #5C
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Sushi
You can tell they put pride into what they do. It’s a place that feels like a staple in the community—reliable, friendly, and always satisfying....