Old Tappan Manor
137 Orangeburgh Rd, Old Tappan
(201) 768-3292
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Nice venue
I was married here on 8/3/2025. I could not have asked for a better ceremony/event. The owners of this establishment believe in love and the understand how special the night/afternoon/day has to be for the couples they host. I was stressed out going in to the day, but from the moment I walked through those doors, to the end of the last song, they carried the weight of the world for us. This venue is incredible. It’s beautiful. And they genuinely do care. Thank you for making our wedding such a special day.
Very nice
Great venue. Lovely lighting and atmosphere
It was a lovely venue and the little fountain adds beautiful vibe to the place
Absolutely horrible they’re in the middle of a legal battle with the surrounding neighborhoods so would let our DJ preform play music too loud it felt like I could’ve just played music on my phone with a regular speaker. Will never recommend to anyone. Lied about many services and other things wish I could’ve done my event else where honestly.
Old Tappan Manor is an incredible venue and we are so grateful we found this place for our April wedding. From the moment we booked and leading up to the wedding, Rich was available, accommodating and professional. There were many details to coordinate on the day of and the team at Old Tappan Manor did not miss a single thing. Lauren, our Maitre D’, was a miracle worker in making things run smoothly all day. Our bridal attendant, Isabella, was so helpful and kind and always right there when I needed something. Our guests could not stop talking about how good the food was and how beautiful the venue was. We toured many venues before making our decision, but Old Tappan Manor stood out for its value across the board: the food, the privacy, the stunning setting, and most of all, the incredible staff.
Beautiful place! And the food was great as well. Had a lovely time here.💗💗💗💗💗
5/5! 10/10! 20/20! Amazing place and food for a king.
A friend of mine recommended The Old Tappan Manor after she toured it a while ago for her wedding. And with only 3 months to plan my wedding, I needed a place asap! Although she didn't end up going with this venue, she remembered how willing and generous they were to work with her budget and knew I'd appreciate that.
True to her words, we were met with such generosity. The venue itself did not look extra-ordinary on the outside but the inside was beautiful! Victor (venue manager), was very professional, polite and quick to listen to our needs. He reviewed and provided a package that complimented our preferences and budget. He even threw in a few add-ons, that weren't part of our package, for free, so that we'd be happy on our day!
When our guests arrived at our reception, they were welcomed with sparkling champagne. Our cocktail hour was a hit, with guests raving about how delicious the food was. We catered, and the venue provided some complimentary options as well. The main course, however, was okay. As with most events, not everything will go according to plan or there may be some hiccups in communication, etc. Even though there were a couple of things that could've been better, our overall experience with the Old Tappan Manor was positive! This place is definitely flexible, accommodating, and beautiful. I think this venue is perfect for the classy, yet simple bride who wants her beautiful wedding without breaking the bank. In the end, our guests were pleased and so were we!
(Google doesn't allow, but we'd say 4.5/5 stars!)
Restaurantji Recommends
Very inconsiderate!! They lost my item in coat check and don’t care to fix the issue. Didn’t even want to cover a lost $50 coat. Cheapskates! Avoid at all costs! Take your business elsewhere.
This venue is the ideal place if you are looking for somewhere that is not considerate of guests property.
After attending a wedding at this quantity over quality venue we received our vehicle back from the valet with a large fresh gouge in it. The manager did not have access to the video footage of the cameras on the property and the general attitude upon that day was that is was not their problem. The owners did not provide footage to the police. Their response was if insurance was involved and required footage they would comply...
Consider your guests property before booking this venue as they contract their valet service to a group that hires unsupervised teenage boys
We had our wedding here back in October and overall had a good experience. The venue was beautiful and the food was awesome. The reception was amazing and we had a wonderful time. Our maitre d and bridal attendant (I forget their names) were excellent and so so helpful throughout our wedding day.
The reason I took 2 stars off was because our catering manager changed a couple months before our wedding. We originally worked with Vincent who was super accommodating. The manager switched to Caesar, who was overall great to work with leading up to the wedding. There were a couple miscommunications (ie things Vincent told us we could have/do that we were now being told could not happen), but that was absolutely not Caesar’s fault. However, we were not thrilled with some of Caesar’s decision making during the reception. For one, he had my DJ make several (5-6 in total) announcements telling people to take their drinks off the dance floor. I’ve never been to a wedding where guests were told they couldn’t hold their drinks while dancing. It was super off putting and killed the vibe. In our wedding video, you see Caesar approach my matron of honor, who is in the middle of dancing, and tap her on the shoulder to tell her to get her drink off the dance floor; this was super disappointing to see. Mind you, it was never mentioned to us prior to the wedding that drinks weren’t allowed on the dance floor. For the amount we paid to host our wedding there, my guests had every right to bring their drinks wherever they wanted to. Later in the night, I was approaching my table with my husband to eat dinner, when Ceasar stopped me and asked me to please tell the people at the bar to come eat dinner because he was worried they’d miss it. I assured him that it was their problem if they missed dinner, but he insisted that I go tell them to go to their seats as he was worried they’d complain if they missed their meal. For one, there’s no reason to tell grown adults they have to go sit and eat their dinner. And two, the last person you should be asking to do that is the bride.
I would absolutely recommend the venue as it was beautiful and our wedding day was amazing, but everyone should be aware of the “rules” and expectations of hosting your wedding here so they can be addressed ahead of time.
Pleasant experience. Friendly staff.
I don’t recommend this place for anything or anyone. Place, food, management and everything you can think of is really terrible.
Loading...