We had a Saturday night reservation but when we arrived at the restaurant the parking lot was empty and the lights were off. The restaurant was closed and neither the restaurant nor open table alerted us to this.
Sean
Never experienced the food. Esty closed for the evening without a call. This happened after calling to modify a reservation and left phone #, as instructed, with no call back. Drove to location to modify reservation during published hours but doors were locked. Ended up canceling and rebooking reservation in order to accommodate desired change. Confirmed reservation, but when my party of 7 showed up to Esty a hand written note on the door informed us we would not be dining there. I have heard good things about the food, but I will never know.
Gina
When called a restaurant and hour before reservation to confirm if can add more people, they told that are closed. I understand emergency situations, but do not connect with customers????? We had double birthdays to celebrate that day....
Opentable Diner
Food was absolutely amazing. Loved the drinks too. We liked the date night vibes and our waitress was awesome. We'll be back!!
Emma Dawson
Absolutely amazing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deo of Hudson Valley Foie Gras & Scallop
StevenB
Outstanding service, food, cocktails, I mean this place is amazing. The Manager has the same name as me (Steven) one of the nicest guys, he always makes us feel like we are the most valued, important people every time we dine and makes us feel special . Thank you and thank you for always being so generous, helpful and kind to us every single time we dine with friends and family and or colleagues. The absolute best restaurant Love this place and love the staff, what a pleasure .
Emmyy
Another phenomenal experience at Esty Street. Food was delicious, cocktails are incredible!! Will be back soon.
Salman Hamirani
Great service and drinks!
Service: 5
Jimmy
The food and service have always been outstanding at Esty Street, however Saturday February 24 was an exception. The food was outstanding, however the service was extremely disappointing. Our waiter was extremely inattentive, impatient, and aloof. He was annoyed when asked to repeat a special, he did not check on our table after the food was delivered, and he did not notice that we had two empty wine glasses on our table midway though our meal. I actually went to the bar and ordered more wine, as he apparently had no interest in providing us refills... Since this experience was an exception to the norm, I will give Esty Street another try.
Sassy87
The food was okay to good. The servers are all below average. For a place like this where you're paying good money, I can't believe how bad the servers are. Our head waiter acted like he didn't care and does not communicate well. The other servers were more personable but keep forgetting follow up requests for iced tea, butter, bread, etc. Will not go back to this place anymore. It was 10x better pre-pandemic!
One of the best nights out I've had in a long time. My partner and I were out for our wedding anniversary. We were both made to feel so special. The library atmosphere was so welcoming and cozy. The staff was super friendly and knowledgeable when we had questions about the specials. The drinks were nice and strong. Our dinner came out quickly and was cooked to perfection. We skipped the dessert but they did sound great. Next time for sure. I would highly recommend Esty Street to anyone looking to have a spectacular night out.
DianaY
Another great date night. The Tuna Tartar was excellent, the beet salad was fresh with just the right balance of ingredients. The Icelandic Cod was delicious. Service was right on key. Friendly and helpful. Our cocktails were imaginative and well balanced. We will be back for another date night soon
Patricia F Schwartz
We had not been there in a while and decided to try again. I remember the cozy library and fish. We started with the spicy Tuna tartar, not really spicy. It was quite good but needed a kick to it. We also tried a special salmon appetizer. For dinner they had a veal shop and I asked for medium rear, she said to try medium plus due to the size of it. Should have gone the way I had chosen. We also ordered the fillet mignon, medium rare with a crab cake. We had to return the fillet mignon, it was overcooked, the crab cake was quite bland. I asked them to keep my chop warm while waiting for the fillet. We waited about 15 minutes for it. My chop was even drier and opted to take more than half home for a family member who likes well done meat. We order the Triple chocolate dessert it was good but not great. I had an expresso martini, it was ok. Service was good but maybe suggesting to cook meats more not a great idea. It is best to undercook and send back if it’s not to one’s liking. Staff tries to be helpful and caring. If we go back, I will stick to their seafood. Beautiful presentation of the food. Don’t mind prices as long as food is good. If you pay by credit card, you will be charged 4% extra.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Surf and Turf Special
Shannon Rosen
Cozy ambiance, great food, delicious drinks, attentive service. Anthony gets 2 thumbs up! He was our server and had a bunch more tables and was absolutely killing it. I’ll definitely be back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Todd Hammond
~ ?????????? ??? ????????? ?? $??? ??? ????? ~???? ????????????? ?? ??????????? ??????? ??? ? ?????? ??????? ???? ?? ??? ?????? - ??'? ? ??????? ???? ?? ????? ?????. ?? ??? ??? ????? ??? ????? ???? ????? ?????? 3.75 ????? ?? ???????, ?? ????? ??? ??? ?????? ?? ???? ???.?? ???????? ? ????? ??? ? ??. But oh, beware the $25 penalty for canceling, because evidently, their desperation for cash knows no bounds. Yet they do not return the diligence when they fail to keep their commitment to your reservation.My spouse and I ??????? ???????? ?? ?:?? ??, only to find a line of disgruntled patrons with reservations for 7:15 and a packed bar of those with even earlier bookings. The hostess was very apologetic and a guy with tattoos and a grease covered shirt came out and apologized - promising the first round is on the restaurant. You can make that the first failure to deliver. Never happened.After a long wait and a 1-1/2 hour conversation with a nice couple ?? ???? ?????? ?????? ?:??-???. I ordered a drink.However, our ordeal was far from over: ??? ?????????? ????????? ? ????? ?????, ??????? ???? ??? ???????? ?? ???????? ??????' ?????, ???????? ???? ????? ?????? ??? ????? ????? ?????? as if cleanliness is a foreign concept to them.?? ????? ?? ????? ?????? ??? ????? ????? ?:??-??? and when I finally received my drink, when I say received i mean ? ???? ?? ??? ??? ?? ????? ??? ????? ?????? ? ?????????? ?? ??????? ????? ????????.Not to mention the tables are very close and ???? ??? ???????? ??? ??????? ??? ???? ????? ??? ???? ??? ????? ?"- ?" ???? ????.To add insult to injury, ? ??????? ?? ?????? ? ??????? ?????? ?????? - ???? ???? ?????? ??????????? ?? ??? ???????? ?? ???? ??? ???????? they allowed to unfold not only for us but several other diners - no wonder they charge $25.00 for a missed reservation - they can't keep diners in the place due to the horrendous service.?? ??:?? ??, ??? ? ?????? ????????? ??? ?????? ??? ?????, despite the fact that the nice couple we were speaking sat at the same time as us had already polished off their entire meals and were cracking open a the bottle of wine they ordered 40 minutes earlier that just arrived.In a final act of desperation at about 11:00 PM we paid for our drinks and left a generous 20% tip for the ??????? ?????, ??? ?????? ???? ?????????? ???? ?????????.The cherry on top? ? ??-????-??? ????? ??? ?????????? ???????? ?? ?? ??? ????????? ??????????. ? ??? ????????? ??? ?? ??? ???? ????. He was the highlight of the service.A follow-up call only served to highlight the delusional state of this establishment. The bartender implored me to praise their Old ?????????? - ????? ???? ???????? ?? ????.Save yourself the agony and flee from this place with all the haste you can muster ... Should've gone to McDonalds.
We had a Saturday night reservation but when we arrived at the restaurant the parking lot was empty and the lights were off. The restaurant was closed and neither the restaurant nor open table alerted us to this.
Never experienced the food. Esty closed for the evening without a call. This happened after calling to modify a reservation and left phone #, as instructed, with no call back. Drove to location to modify reservation during published hours but doors were locked. Ended up canceling and rebooking reservation in order to accommodate desired change. Confirmed reservation, but when my party of 7 showed up to Esty a hand written note on the door informed us we would not be dining there. I have heard good things about the food, but I will never know.
When called a restaurant and hour before reservation to confirm if can add more people, they told that are closed. I understand emergency situations, but do not connect with customers????? We had double birthdays to celebrate that day....
Food was absolutely amazing. Loved the drinks too. We liked the date night vibes and our waitress was awesome. We'll be back!!
Absolutely amazing!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deo of Hudson Valley Foie Gras & Scallop
Outstanding service, food, cocktails, I mean this place is amazing. The Manager has the same name as me (Steven) one of the nicest guys, he always makes us feel like we are the most valued, important people every time we dine and makes us feel special . Thank you and thank you for always being so generous, helpful and kind to us every single time we dine with friends and family and or colleagues. The absolute best restaurant Love this place and love the staff, what a pleasure .
Another phenomenal experience at Esty Street. Food was delicious, cocktails are incredible!! Will be back soon.
Great service and drinks!
Service: 5
The food and service have always been outstanding at Esty Street, however Saturday February 24 was an exception. The food was outstanding, however the service was extremely disappointing. Our waiter was extremely inattentive, impatient, and aloof. He was annoyed when asked to repeat a special, he did not check on our table after the food was delivered, and he did not notice that we had two empty wine glasses on our table midway though our meal. I actually went to the bar and ordered more wine, as he apparently had no interest in providing us refills... Since this experience was an exception to the norm, I will give Esty Street another try.
The food was okay to good. The servers are all below average. For a place like this where you're paying good money, I can't believe how bad the servers are. Our head waiter acted like he didn't care and does not communicate well. The other servers were more personable but keep forgetting follow up requests for iced tea, butter, bread, etc. Will not go back to this place anymore. It was 10x better pre-pandemic!
Restaurantji Recommends
One of the best nights out I've had in a long time. My partner and I were out for our wedding anniversary. We were both made to feel so special. The library atmosphere was so welcoming and cozy. The staff was super friendly and knowledgeable when we had questions about the specials. The drinks were nice and strong. Our dinner came out quickly and was cooked to perfection. We skipped the dessert but they did sound great. Next time for sure. I would highly recommend Esty Street to anyone looking to have a spectacular night out.
Another great date night. The Tuna Tartar was excellent, the beet salad was fresh with just the right balance of ingredients. The Icelandic Cod was delicious. Service was right on key. Friendly and helpful. Our cocktails were imaginative and well balanced. We will be back for another date night soon
We had not been there in a while and decided to try again. I remember the cozy library and fish. We started with the spicy Tuna tartar, not really spicy. It was quite good but needed a kick to it. We also tried a special salmon appetizer. For dinner they had a veal shop and I asked for medium rear, she said to try medium plus due to the size of it. Should have gone the way I had chosen. We also ordered the fillet mignon, medium rare with a crab cake. We had to return the fillet mignon, it was overcooked, the crab cake was quite bland. I asked them to keep my chop warm while waiting for the fillet. We waited about 15 minutes for it. My chop was even drier and opted to take more than half home for a family member who likes well done meat. We order the Triple chocolate dessert it was good but not great. I had an expresso martini, it was ok. Service was good but maybe suggesting to cook meats more not a great idea. It is best to undercook and send back if it’s not to one’s liking. Staff tries to be helpful and caring. If we go back, I will stick to their seafood. Beautiful presentation of the food. Don’t mind prices as long as food is good. If you pay by credit card, you will be charged 4% extra.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Surf and Turf Special
Cozy ambiance, great food, delicious drinks, attentive service. Anthony gets 2 thumbs up! He was our server and had a bunch more tables and was absolutely killing it. I’ll definitely be back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
~ ?????????? ??? ????????? ?? $??? ??? ????? ~???? ????????????? ?? ??????????? ??????? ??? ? ?????? ??????? ???? ?? ??? ?????? - ??'? ? ??????? ???? ?? ????? ?????. ?? ??? ??? ????? ??? ????? ???? ????? ?????? 3.75 ????? ?? ???????, ?? ????? ??? ??? ?????? ?? ???? ???.?? ???????? ? ????? ??? ? ??. But oh, beware the $25 penalty for canceling, because evidently, their desperation for cash knows no bounds. Yet they do not return the diligence when they fail to keep their commitment to your reservation.My spouse and I ??????? ???????? ?? ?:?? ??, only to find a line of disgruntled patrons with reservations for 7:15 and a packed bar of those with even earlier bookings. The hostess was very apologetic and a guy with tattoos and a grease covered shirt came out and apologized - promising the first round is on the restaurant. You can make that the first failure to deliver. Never happened.After a long wait and a 1-1/2 hour conversation with a nice couple ?? ???? ?????? ?????? ?:??-???. I ordered a drink.However, our ordeal was far from over: ??? ?????????? ????????? ? ????? ?????, ??????? ???? ??? ???????? ?? ???????? ??????' ?????, ???????? ???? ????? ?????? ??? ????? ????? ?????? as if cleanliness is a foreign concept to them.?? ????? ?? ????? ?????? ??? ????? ????? ?:??-??? and when I finally received my drink, when I say received i mean ? ???? ?? ??? ??? ?? ????? ??? ????? ?????? ? ?????????? ?? ??????? ????? ????????.Not to mention the tables are very close and ???? ??? ???????? ??? ??????? ??? ???? ????? ??? ???? ??? ????? ?"- ?" ???? ????.To add insult to injury, ? ??????? ?? ?????? ? ??????? ?????? ?????? - ???? ???? ?????? ??????????? ?? ??? ???????? ?? ???? ??? ???????? they allowed to unfold not only for us but several other diners - no wonder they charge $25.00 for a missed reservation - they can't keep diners in the place due to the horrendous service.?? ??:?? ??, ??? ? ?????? ????????? ??? ?????? ??? ?????, despite the fact that the nice couple we were speaking sat at the same time as us had already polished off their entire meals and were cracking open a the bottle of wine they ordered 40 minutes earlier that just arrived.In a final act of desperation at about 11:00 PM we paid for our drinks and left a generous 20% tip for the ??????? ?????, ??? ?????? ???? ?????????? ???? ?????????.The cherry on top? ? ??-????-??? ????? ??? ?????????? ???????? ?? ?? ??? ????????? ??????????. ? ??? ????????? ??? ?? ??? ???? ????. He was the highlight of the service.A follow-up call only served to highlight the delusional state of this establishment. The bartender implored me to praise their Old ?????????? - ????? ???? ???????? ?? ????.Save yourself the agony and flee from this place with all the haste you can muster ... Should've gone to McDonalds.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...