New American Restaurants near Peapack, NJ

“Ninety Acres at Natirar is a renowned restaurant that offers an exceptional dining experience. The beautiful setting, delectable cuisine, and outstanding service create a memorable occasion for guests. The restaurant's commitment to using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients is evident in the unique and flavorful dishes featured on the menu, including a popular 4-course tasting prix fixe option. Visitors consistently praise the warm welcome, attentive staff, and relaxed atmosphere, making Ninety Acres an ideal choice for special celebrations and gatherings.“

“Seasons 52 is a renowned restaurant that consistently delivers an exceptional dining experience. From the moment guests arrive, the impeccable service and attentive staff ensure a memorable occasion. The menu offers a diverse selection of expertly prepared dishes, including the well-received filet mignon, which is cooked to perfection. The serene ambiance of the establishment creates a relaxing atmosphere, perfect for celebrations and gatherings. Whether it's a special event or a casual outing, Seasons 52 consistently exceeds expectations and provides a truly remarkable culinary journey.“

“Stoney Brook Grille is a local spot that offers a friendly and inviting atmosphere. The food is described as very good, though the portions may be a bit light. The service is noted as very friendly, but the noise level can make it challenging to have a conversation. The restaurant features a nice ambiance, with occasional live music that adds to the overall vibe. While the food is not considered amazing, it is still very good and makes for an enjoyable dining experience. The menu includes options like a delightful bruschetta and a tasty jambalaya dish. In addition to the food and atmosphere, Stoney Brook Grille is praised for its excellent happy hour and even free bingo on Tuesdays with prizes. The bartenders are also commended for their attentiveness and skill in crafting excellent cocktails, such as the delightful brown sugar old fashioned. Overall, Stoney Brook Grille is a great local spot that provides a memorable and affordable dining experience, with friendly service, a nice ambiance, and a menu that offers very good food options.“

“3 West offers a cozy atmosphere and friendly, personable staff. The food is amazing, with highlights like the Tuna Tartare and customizable Thai Noodle Salad. While some dishes may have room for improvement, the overall experience is wonderful, making it a great spot for special occasions and return visits.“

“The Red Oak Grille provides exceptional service and delicious food, making it an ideal spot for special occasions. The restaurant offers ample parking and a beautiful outdoor seating area overlooking the golf course. The menu features a variety of dishes, including strip steak, salmon, steak sandwich, and fish tacos, all perfectly prepared and attractively presented. The cocktails are special, and the service is truly impeccable. The staff is gracious, accommodating, and attentive, ensuring a memorable dining experience. With its great service, food, and views, the Red Oak Grille is a highly recommended destination.“

“The Ryland Inn Wedding & Event Venue is a perfect and special venue for any wedding celebration. Its stunning architecture and picturesque surroundings provide an ideal backdrop for a magical and unforgettable day. The venue's wedding coordinators are exceptional, attentive, and professional, ensuring every detail is taken care of. With top-notch amenities and facilities, the Ryland Inn offers a range of options to suit individual needs. Couples have praised the venue's historic elegance, charming interior spaces, and lush outdoor areas, making it a highly recommended spot for a perfect wedding celebration.“

“Jerry's Brooklyn Grill is a top-rated breakfast and lunch spot, known for the best pancakes with fresh blueberries. The homemade focaccia used for the panini is amazing. It has a classic country cafe feel with friendly staff and fast service. A hidden gem in Whitehouse Station, offering must-try brunch options like egg Benedict. Owned by Jerry and his sister, it's a comfortable and welcoming space.“

“DIG is a restaurant that offers fresh and natural food, providing healthy choices for those with dietary restrictions. The depth of flavor in their dishes encourages loyalty, and their presentation is described as beautiful. The house salad with crispy chicken and pesto dressing, as well as their vegan options, are particularly praised. The staff, including Arnie and Nikita, are noted for their friendliness and excellent recommendations. The restaurant's carrots, sweet potatoes, and cashew Caesar dressing have also received high praise. Overall, DIG is a clean, healthy, and delicious dining option with a welcoming atmosphere and enthusiastic staff.“

“Bistro Seven Three is a highly recommended restaurant with a lovely outdoor room and a varied menu including fish and pasta. The staff is professional, friendly, and accommodating to food sensitivities. Guests enjoy the BYOB option and the excellent service. The restaurant is a popular choice for events like rehearsal dinners and baby showers, with guests raving about the delicious food and the attentive staff. The event coordinator is easy to work with, ensuring a perfect experience for special occasions. Overall, Bistro Seven Three earns high praise for its food, service, and atmosphere.“

“Gladstone Tavern offers a great dining experience with attentive and friendly staff. Enjoy their excellent cheese board, burgers, and outdoor patio with plenty of space. While prices may be steep, the atmosphere and service make up for it, with a skilled bartender crafting killer drinks.“

“The Pluckemin Inn offers an exceptional dining experience just off 287. The menu is meat-forward, but the chefs can accommodate vegetarian requests. The cocktail selection is sublime, and the wine list is extensive. Vegetable sides are cooked to perfection, and fresh bread is served while you wait. The elegant atmosphere is perfect for special occasions, and the restaurant also welcomes casual diners. With plenty of parking and outdoor spaces, The Pluckemin Inn is suitable for both dining and events.“

“Monterey Fine Foods is a great place serving amazing food. They offer professional catering services, with a helpful and patient team. Their menu features delicious options like shrimp tostados, summer salad, and onion dip with homemade potato chips. They provide convenient services, leaving the venue spotless after events.“

“The Tewksbury Inn is a welcoming spot that feels like a neighborhood gathering place. The bartenders are friendly, and the atmosphere is reminiscent of Cheers. The menu features delicious options like French onion soup, fish and chips, and amazing burgers. While the restaurant tends to prioritize its regular locals, visitors can still enjoy a great meal and drinks, including Sunken Silo IPA on tap. Despite some inconsistencies in service, the Inn's warm atmosphere and tasty food make it a great spot to visit.“

“My stay at Delta Hotels by Marriott Basking Ridge was delightful, but the true gem was their restaurant! Forget overpriced hotel dining - this spot offered delicious, affordable dishes that surpassed any outside option. From the serene atmosphere (thanks to the smaller crowd) to the attentive service and delicious food, every aspect impressed. The hot buffet breakfast was a lifesaver - delicious, varied, and budget-friendly. Skip the tourist traps and treat yourself to this hidden gem. Your taste buds will thank you!“

“The Rail is a casual restaurant with a welcoming atmosphere. Their Jersey-Bound burger is a must-try, featuring a generous beef patty with an egg and Taylor Ham. The restaurant also offers a variety of wraps, salads, meatloaf, ravioli, and giant pretzels, all of which have been praised by customers. On certain nights, trivia nights are held with exciting prizes. The staff is friendly and attentive, making every visitor feel at home.“

“Grain House is a casual restaurant open 7 days a week with consistently good quality food and portions. The warm and inviting ambience in the "pub" room makes it a favorite spot for many. However, some customers have experienced a decline in service quality over the years, with long wait times and mix-ups with orders. The Cobb salad was tasty but lacking in components for the price. The noise level in the restaurant doesn't match the decor, but it's generally busy. Despite some service issues, the food and service provided by the bartender were excellent during one visit.“

“Redstone American Grill serves flavorful food with beautiful plating, and the staff is warm and accommodating, particularly with food allergies. The braised beef short rib is a highlight, served with a flavorful jus. Portion sizes are generous, and the patio seating is a great option. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, with vegetarian options available, although dairy-free options may be limited.“

“Social is a hidden gem that offers an exceptional dining experience. The restaurant's outdoor seating creates a resort-like atmosphere, and the food is consistently praised, with dishes like chicken francais and beet salad standing out. The attentive service and high-quality drinks, such as the Elloun chardonnay and decaf cappuccino, contribute to an overall excellent experience. While some visitors have had mixed experiences, the majority of reviews highlight Social as a highly recommended destination.“

“Red Horse by David Burke at Bernards Inn offers an outstanding dining experience with vibrant, spirited, and sophisticated atmosphere. The service is excellent, and the food is fabulous, including creative cocktails, delicious appetizers, Veal Parm special on Saturdays, cod dish in parchment, filet, and whipped potatoes. Perfect for special occasions, this restaurant ensures a memorable dining experience from start to finish, ending on a sweet note with dessert and cappuccinos.“

“California Pizza Kitchen at Bridgewater Commons offers a great dining experience, especially for kids' birthday parties. The restaurant provides a fun and interactive experience, allowing kids to create their own custom pizzas. The menu features a variety of options, including the Spicy Buffalo Chicken, Avocado Club Rolls, and Dynamite Shrimp, which are all delicious. The cocktail and mocktail offerings are also refreshing. The staff is attentive, helpful, and informative, making planning and execution seamless. However, some customers have noted that the food can be pricey and the restaurant can get loud. Additionally, wheelchair accessibility is limited due to the small space. Despite this, the restaurant's cleanliness, pleasant vibe, and convenient parking make it a popular choice.“

“The Market Tavern Restaurant & Bar offers a lively atmosphere with a wide selection of drinks, including a great beer list and a huge wine list. The menu features a variety of options, including a cheese steak, a "Too Gouda to be true" burger, fried zucchini, and delicious oysters. While the service can be slow at times, the friendly staff and good food make it a popular spot for both lunch and dinner.“