Good food, beat all my expectations. The margarita flight was 4 nearly fully sized drinks. Glad I could share it among my table, or I would t be able to remember anything at all for this review!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jonathan Ferrante
We used to come here regularly when we lived in the area and it was always a great experience. Food was great, service was good and prices were reasonable. Unfortunately not the same anymore. Grabbed takeaway because I was in the area. Two salads, one with a side of weirdly textured grilled chicken and an appetizer of 3 meatballs was $60!! 3 meatballs for $18?! I get that everything is more expensive now but never again, these prices for the portions and quality are egregiously gouging. Between this latest experience here and our absolutely disastrous experience at their sister restaurant Union Boil down the road I can no longer recommend any restaurants operated by the Gretalia Hospitality Group. Take your hard earned money elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Nery Ragno
I've been going to this restaurant for over 5 or 6 years. The atmosphere has definitely gotten better, but thier service in the restaurant isn't great. I visited last week 1/29/24. There were four of us with no one but another couple in the restaurant. We saw the waitress 2 times. Too busy talking and hanging with management . She looked like his daughter and she was not minding the table. Bar service is nuch better with John.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Gabriella
Went here with a friend for dinner. We each ordered a pasta dish, Gnocchi Vodka and Porcini Ravioli. Each was well prepared and bursting with flavor. Service is fast, although sometimes inattentive. Ambiance isn’t too crowded and is relatively comfortable. Prices are a little steep for what it is, although forgivable. Overall, would recommend.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Elizabeth C.
I'm rating Osteria Procaccini a 4 for the convenience of being able to eat and drink without having to stop at the liquor store first! Full bar and wine, the food was average. Appropriate for family dining with small ones. It's very hard to find quality Italian food in the Pennington area.
Erick Veliz
Great and clean place. The food is delicious and has great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Geiger
Very good food , Oscar the host /server is a gentleman, my go to place in
Finally visited on recommendation from a friend. Nice little hidden gem. Reasonable prices in a laid-back setting. Comfortable bar and dining area. The food was good and servers friendly. Will go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
G C
First time there and the place was hopping. Fun, full eclectic, wood burning pizza with a good menu of other options. Food came out a little slow but we came during rush hour and were seated right away. Will definitely go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
C. Carter (JustusWillBeServed)
Came in on a Linner date con mi dulce. This place was wonderful! The food was so delish and even the bar drinks were smooth and sumptuous. The clams were spot on and the burger was the bees knees. That being the case I will definitely try the meatballs next time because they will be outrageously good. Definitely a highlight spot whenever I'm near.
A family member lives near the restaurant. A few months ago, based on her recommendation, we went there for lunch. When we recently visited I insisted we go there again. The food is extraordinarily good, matched by the service, and a good vibe. The employees are welcoming and provide outstanding service. If I lived nearby Osteria Procaccini would be my go-to restaurant. I'll have to settle for it to be my go-to restaurant when I visit my family member.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
downhill
We went to Osteria Procaccini tonight. We've been here a handful of times before and we've liked it. They have good pizza and good drinks.Tonight, we wanted to have a nice meal with each other. The server's greeting out of the gate was aggressive. They had this pizza wine pairing menu. I asked about the wine that was in one of the featured selections. The server retorted, "you have to get the specific pizza that is paired up with the wine" which is what I wanted to begin with so - it wasn't so much that he pointed this detail out to us- it was his tone. It was pretty aggressive and not friendly. Whatever, we moved on and we orderd two pizzas. I ordered 2 glasses of wine and my wife ordered her usual 1 glass of wine. After our pizza arrived to the table, I asked the waiter for 2 glasses of water- a normal request in which the response should have been " sure, no problem." The waiter stumbled with his words for a few seconds - because he knew how ridiculous what was about to come out of his mouth. He said " argh argh argh argh......we should have explained this at the beginning when you sat down, but our tap water isn't working." He offered us a choice of sparkling or still water for purchase. This is where my head filled up with a magnitude of questions such as, "how is the restaurant functioning without tap water?", " how are they filling pots without tap water?" Are the bathrooms out of order?" " and if the bathrooms are out of order, how is the restaurant open?"I don't like dishonesty. My wife already had a stressful day and our night out was supposed to be enjoyable. While the food was decent, we won't be returning. If the restaurant wants to upcharge patrons for water, at least be honest and don't make up a cochamamy story that the tap water isn't working. It's an insult to our intelligence. Additionally, I could see the expressions on other patrons' faces when they too were told about the water saga. They didn't believe the story either. No thank you. Won't be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Midge H.
All I can say is WOW. We had dinner there last night. We'd seen the sign for a long time and didn't go in because it read pizza bar. That is so deceiving. This is a full blown restaurant with a recently redecorated lovely interior and enlarged bar with a full menu that includes pizza. Specialty is Italian food and it's excellent. Prices are good. Happy hour is great and the service is friendly and fast. We met John and Ryan who were behind the bar last night. Their friendliness and service was remarkable. Can't wait to return next Friday. Don't pass this place by, you're missing out on something special if you do. Midge
Vanessa Seiffert
Food was absolutely phenomenal. I recommend the shrimp scampi. It was the best I have ever had! The sauce was balanced with the butter, capers, and lemon. The wings were amazing as well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vanessa Van Schaik
Food was absolutely phenomenal. I recommend the shrimp scampi. It was the best I have ever had! The sauce was balanced with the butter, capers, and lemon. The wings were amazing as well!
Good food, beat all my expectations. The margarita flight was 4 nearly fully sized drinks. Glad I could share it among my table, or I would t be able to remember anything at all for this review!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
We used to come here regularly when we lived in the area and it was always a great experience. Food was great, service was good and prices were reasonable. Unfortunately not the same anymore. Grabbed takeaway because I was in the area. Two salads, one with a side of weirdly textured grilled chicken and an appetizer of 3 meatballs was $60!! 3 meatballs for $18?! I get that everything is more expensive now but never again, these prices for the portions and quality are egregiously gouging. Between this latest experience here and our absolutely disastrous experience at their sister restaurant Union Boil down the road I can no longer recommend any restaurants operated by the Gretalia Hospitality Group. Take your hard earned money elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
I've been going to this restaurant for over 5 or 6 years. The atmosphere has definitely gotten better, but thier service in the restaurant isn't great. I visited last week 1/29/24. There were four of us with no one but another couple in the restaurant. We saw the waitress 2 times. Too busy talking and hanging with management . She looked like his daughter and she was not minding the table. Bar service is nuch better with John.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Went here with a friend for dinner. We each ordered a pasta dish, Gnocchi Vodka and Porcini Ravioli. Each was well prepared and bursting with flavor. Service is fast, although sometimes inattentive. Ambiance isn’t too crowded and is relatively comfortable. Prices are a little steep for what it is, although forgivable. Overall, would recommend.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
I'm rating Osteria Procaccini a 4 for the convenience of being able to eat and drink without having to stop at the liquor store first! Full bar and wine, the food was average. Appropriate for family dining with small ones. It's very hard to find quality Italian food in the Pennington area.
Great and clean place. The food is delicious and has great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good food , Oscar the host /server is a gentleman, my go to place in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatballs, Eggplant Rollatini, Burrata and Figs, Parmesan Sandwich Meatball
Finally visited on recommendation from a friend. Nice little hidden gem. Reasonable prices in a laid-back setting. Comfortable bar and dining area. The food was good and servers friendly. Will go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
First time there and the place was hopping. Fun, full eclectic, wood burning pizza with a good menu of other options. Food came out a little slow but we came during rush hour and were seated right away. Will definitely go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Came in on a Linner date con mi dulce. This place was wonderful! The food was so delish and even the bar drinks were smooth and sumptuous. The clams were spot on and the burger was the bees knees. That being the case I will definitely try the meatballs next time because they will be outrageously good. Definitely a highlight spot whenever I'm near.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
A family member lives near the restaurant. A few months ago, based on her recommendation, we went there for lunch. When we recently visited I insisted we go there again. The food is extraordinarily good, matched by the service, and a good vibe. The employees are welcoming and provide outstanding service. If I lived nearby Osteria Procaccini would be my go-to restaurant. I'll have to settle for it to be my go-to restaurant when I visit my family member.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went to Osteria Procaccini tonight. We've been here a handful of times before and we've liked it. They have good pizza and good drinks.Tonight, we wanted to have a nice meal with each other. The server's greeting out of the gate was aggressive. They had this pizza wine pairing menu. I asked about the wine that was in one of the featured selections. The server retorted, "you have to get the specific pizza that is paired up with the wine" which is what I wanted to begin with so - it wasn't so much that he pointed this detail out to us- it was his tone. It was pretty aggressive and not friendly. Whatever, we moved on and we orderd two pizzas. I ordered 2 glasses of wine and my wife ordered her usual 1 glass of wine. After our pizza arrived to the table, I asked the waiter for 2 glasses of water- a normal request in which the response should have been " sure, no problem." The waiter stumbled with his words for a few seconds - because he knew how ridiculous what was about to come out of his mouth. He said " argh argh argh argh......we should have explained this at the beginning when you sat down, but our tap water isn't working." He offered us a choice of sparkling or still water for purchase. This is where my head filled up with a magnitude of questions such as, "how is the restaurant functioning without tap water?", " how are they filling pots without tap water?" Are the bathrooms out of order?" " and if the bathrooms are out of order, how is the restaurant open?"I don't like dishonesty. My wife already had a stressful day and our night out was supposed to be enjoyable. While the food was decent, we won't be returning. If the restaurant wants to upcharge patrons for water, at least be honest and don't make up a cochamamy story that the tap water isn't working. It's an insult to our intelligence. Additionally, I could see the expressions on other patrons' faces when they too were told about the water saga. They didn't believe the story either. No thank you. Won't be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
All I can say is WOW. We had dinner there last night. We'd seen the sign for a long time and didn't go in because it read pizza bar. That is so deceiving. This is a full blown restaurant with a recently redecorated lovely interior and enlarged bar with a full menu that includes pizza. Specialty is Italian food and it's excellent. Prices are good. Happy hour is great and the service is friendly and fast. We met John and Ryan who were behind the bar last night. Their friendliness and service was remarkable. Can't wait to return next Friday. Don't pass this place by, you're missing out on something special if you do. Midge
Food was absolutely phenomenal. I recommend the shrimp scampi. It was the best I have ever had! The sauce was balanced with the butter, capers, and lemon. The wings were amazing as well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was absolutely phenomenal. I recommend the shrimp scampi. It was the best I have ever had! The sauce was balanced with the butter, capers, and lemon. The wings were amazing as well!