My Bagel Heaven

Name: My Bagel Heaven
Address: 220 Newark Pompton Turnpike, Pequannock, New Jersey, 07440, US
Telephone: (973) 305-1111
Price range: $
Rating: 3.4

$ •

Hours:
220 Newark Pompton Turnpike, Pequannock
(973) 305-1111

About My Bagel Heaven

My Bagel Heaven is a friendly, welcoming restaurant that offers a variety of bagels. A cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese and tomato, as well as plain sun-dried tomato and scallion cheese onion bagels, are popular choices. The restaurant is known for having the best bagels in New Jersey, and many customers believe it truly lives up to its name. The price is reasonable, with a bagel and coffee costing around $5, but some recent reviews mention that prices for egg sandwiches have increased, with charges reaching $8.50, which some customers find too high compared to other places.

While the music volume and lox portion size have been noted as areas for improvement, the overall experience remains positive. Customers appreciate the delicious bagels and the nostalgic feeling of returning, even after years away. The restaurant is busy, especially on weekends, and the customer service has been praised for being attentive during busy times. Overall, My Bagel Heaven continues to be a place worth visiting again and again.