Tony Boys Sandwich House Montville
263 Changebridge Rd, Pine Brook
(973) 494-7727
Customers' Favorites
Chop Chop Chopped Salad on a Sub
Liquid Lancer
The Phat Phil
Jersey Club
Mr Goodbyte
California
Strawberry
Boardwalk
American
Stallone
Menu
Photos
+23 photos
+22 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Was excited to try out this place. Ordered #10 and Mr Goodbyte as they seemed to popular choices. Positives - large, generously filled sandwiches. Pretty decent flavor on each sandwich . Negatives - though lots of slices of chicken, they were dry as if they had been cooked awhile ago. Menu said “ribeye steak”, it was definitely not ribeye. Seemed more like eye round which was very lean. Slices were on the thick side, making a bit hard to chew. Did not look like sliced...
I was so excited to try this place & I wanted to love them but the drunk chicken was mediocre at best & maybe I just went in at a bad time but the cheese wasn’t even melted well, just warm. The vodka sauce is also pure water, they should consider making a thicker vodka sauce. As far as the ribeye cheesesteak I ordered - it reminds me of an nyc chopped cheese you get from the bodegas. It was good, but nothing mind blowing.
The customer service was good.
The customer service was good.
I ordered the doozer - the sandwich was overpowered by peppers, cherry peopers and green pepper spicy, way too much balsamic and vinegar that it made the sandwich un enjoyable. Maybe you guys should add a spicy chart for each sandwich so that way we know what we’re getting into.
