I love this place. The owner is always very nice, the staff is great and the food is amazing. It’s also right in the heart of downtown Pitman, which makes it a perfect atmosphere too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeffrey Venella
This place should be ashamed calling what they served a cheesesteak. Definitely way over priced for such a horrible sandwich. The fries had no seasoning at all, just a patatoe cut up and fried. Pizza was just ok but not enough for us to visit again. What a waste of money
Food: 1
Service: 2
Shukrat
Nice ppl
Food: 4
Service: 5
maddy stewart
I thought to myself, I’ve lived in pitman so long. Let me try out a place on the over hyped street! I ordered chicken fingers/fries with a side of honey mustard (which it comes with) and a CHEESE steak. I walk back home open the boxes. The honey mustard is SPLATTERED all over the box and chicken fingers/fries. It was disgusting. Then I say at least I have a cheesesteak. I open it, NO CHEESE. halfway filled with steak. No. The price of food these days, my order should at least be correct. Very disappointed and got an instant refund. Will not be a returning customer. Off to McDonald’s I go.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Erin Wadsworth
It’s wild that I am just now reviewing Attilio’s Pizza! They are truly a staple piece in Pitman. Just a classic pizzeria! I love getting slices or candy to go as well dining in with my boyfriend. We can enjoy great food and people watch. It’s cozy as hell. I would choose Attilio’s any day over the “fancier” restaurants in town. Prices are totally affordable. Food is so good. I could go on & on about how amazing the sicillian pizza is, oh my god I’m actually obsessed. I also appreciate seeing kids have a place to go & grab a bite. What a dream, I would’ve killed to have a pizza place within walking distance that I could hit up with my friends as a kid/teen. Awesome place, awesome ownership, awesome workers, awesome food. Well done!
Aaron Parker
Went here while on vacation. Food was amazing just lime I remembered it to be.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Magdelina Davis
I love this place! Grew up eating here a big comfort place with lots of good food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Taylor Clark
Best cheesesteak I’ve ever had! Grew up here, but currently visiting my from FL and this is exactly what I’ve been missing! Super fast delivery & great customer service!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Justin D
Great Pizza! The crust is thin and crispy and is the highlight for me, cooked to perfection. The sauce is nicely balanced with good tomato flavor. Perfect amount of cheese. Best Pie in town. The wings are exceptional. Do not skip the wings! Large, meaty, crispy with great sauces.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Cheese Pizza
Heather Bush
After going back and visiting my old hometown I was desperate for a mustard pie which no one had heard of as of yet down here. I went and ask Salvatore who not only knew of them but 5 different ways to make them. He graciously (on the spot!!) called my favorite old pizza shop and said “I happen to have a broken half of gluten free crust, if you want to wait I’ll try and make one for you” (which was amazing on all counts plus I’m gluten free and it’s so hard to find good GF pizza). Needless to say Salvatore nailed it on the first shot!!!!
He didn’t charge me because it was a test and was explaining how we could adjust it more to my liking if need be. I surprised my mom with it this morning and she was over the moon thrilled as were the two very lucky coworkers she shared a bit with.
The customer service, his authenticity and knowledge, everything was amazing. 5,000 gold star rating!!!! Now we have our mustard pie for Friday nights and English mysteries again!! He was such a joy and so passionate about his ingredients only using the best and even telling me how to order this if I want it as a dipping sauce too!!
I just had THE MOST AMAZING experience asking if they made a certain type of food that I haven’t found since moving down here.
I had the name and number of the restaurant I used to always order it from and Salvatore (the owner) actually called and asked right then about it. I won’t give it away yet until my next review when I surprise my mom with how he nailed it on the first shot and it’s gluten free!!!!
Can’t wait to fill you all in!!!
Bill Collins
Best pizza around
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Remodeling Revolution
A+++ Best food in town. Great service and very friendly atmosphere!!!
Devin Tutela
I love Sal he is so funny and welcoming and friendly. I have never had a bad experience here. Atmosphere is incredible food is amazing and the staff is always extremely kind and friendly.
Devanie Shirley
My family has been getting pizza here for years and they never disappoint. Much better pizza than nearby places and worth the price. Their wings are super crispy and really good too. The staff is nice and accommodating.
I love this place. The owner is always very nice, the staff is great and the food is amazing. It’s also right in the heart of downtown Pitman, which makes it a perfect atmosphere too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place should be ashamed calling what they served a cheesesteak. Definitely way over priced for such a horrible sandwich. The fries had no seasoning at all, just a patatoe cut up and fried. Pizza was just ok but not enough for us to visit again. What a waste of money
Food: 1
Service: 2
Nice ppl
Food: 4
Service: 5
I thought to myself, I’ve lived in pitman so long. Let me try out a place on the over hyped street! I ordered chicken fingers/fries with a side of honey mustard (which it comes with) and a CHEESE steak. I walk back home open the boxes. The honey mustard is SPLATTERED all over the box and chicken fingers/fries. It was disgusting. Then I say at least I have a cheesesteak. I open it, NO CHEESE. halfway filled with steak. No. The price of food these days, my order should at least be correct. Very disappointed and got an instant refund. Will not be a returning customer. Off to McDonald’s I go.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
It’s wild that I am just now reviewing Attilio’s Pizza! They are truly a staple piece in Pitman. Just a classic pizzeria! I love getting slices or candy to go as well dining in with my boyfriend. We can enjoy great food and people watch. It’s cozy as hell. I would choose Attilio’s any day over the “fancier” restaurants in town. Prices are totally affordable. Food is so good. I could go on & on about how amazing the sicillian pizza is, oh my god I’m actually obsessed. I also appreciate seeing kids have a place to go & grab a bite. What a dream, I would’ve killed to have a pizza place within walking distance that I could hit up with my friends as a kid/teen. Awesome place, awesome ownership, awesome workers, awesome food. Well done!
Went here while on vacation. Food was amazing just lime I remembered it to be.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love this place! Grew up eating here a big comfort place with lots of good food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best cheesesteak I’ve ever had! Grew up here, but currently visiting my from FL and this is exactly what I’ve been missing! Super fast delivery & great customer service!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Pizza! The crust is thin and crispy and is the highlight for me, cooked to perfection. The sauce is nicely balanced with good tomato flavor. Perfect amount of cheese. Best Pie in town. The wings are exceptional. Do not skip the wings! Large, meaty, crispy with great sauces.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Cheese Pizza
After going back and visiting my old hometown I was desperate for a mustard pie which no one had heard of as of yet down here. I went and ask Salvatore who not only knew of them but 5 different ways to make them. He graciously (on the spot!!) called my favorite old pizza shop and said “I happen to have a broken half of gluten free crust, if you want to wait I’ll try and make one for you” (which was amazing on all counts plus I’m gluten free and it’s so hard to find good GF pizza). Needless to say Salvatore nailed it on the first shot!!!!
He didn’t charge me because it was a test and was explaining how we could adjust it more to my liking if need be. I surprised my mom with it this morning and she was over the moon thrilled as were the two very lucky coworkers she shared a bit with.
The customer service, his authenticity and knowledge, everything was amazing. 5,000 gold star rating!!!! Now we have our mustard pie for Friday nights and English mysteries again!! He was such a joy and so passionate about his ingredients only using the best and even telling me how to order this if I want it as a dipping sauce too!!
Sold!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
I just had THE MOST AMAZING experience asking if they made a certain type of food that I haven’t found since moving down here. I had the name and number of the restaurant I used to always order it from and Salvatore (the owner) actually called and asked right then about it. I won’t give it away yet until my next review when I surprise my mom with how he nailed it on the first shot and it’s gluten free!!!! Can’t wait to fill you all in!!!
Best pizza around
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A+++ Best food in town. Great service and very friendly atmosphere!!!
I love Sal he is so funny and welcoming and friendly. I have never had a bad experience here. Atmosphere is incredible food is amazing and the staff is always extremely kind and friendly.
My family has been getting pizza here for years and they never disappoint. Much better pizza than nearby places and worth the price. Their wings are super crispy and really good too. The staff is nice and accommodating.
Loading...