Prime rib was cold and ask to be heated and was brought back two minutes later still cold horrible food and service ,waiter did not even care.margaritas was made with vodka instead of tequila what a joke. Avoid this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 2
Theresa Waterhouse
always have a great meal, great company and great service
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Patty Robinson
It was my birthday dinner. I ordered filet mignon. Had it before and it was great. This time it was soo tough the waitress said a lot were sent back. The owner told me they got the wrong kind of meat. Didn't offer any apology and walked away. Could have taken it off the menu. Don't know if I will go back. Spent a lot of money there many times.
STACEY LYTLE
The big room is very noisy. The nachos looked really good, but underneath it all, they were all almost plain. Too noisy service lacking. But it always draws a crowd.It's a great place for appetizers and cocktails. Had to wait to get seated while we literally stood next to the bye. That was seating us He never said I'll be right with you. Nothing. We just stood there like dummies. For ten minutes.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Dylan Hutt
Today was my first time at this restaurant our waitress name was Mel she was absolutely rude to me my mom my dad and my aunt and uncle she threw the plates on the table I felt like she was taking her anger out on us
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Howard Ruzzo
Usually good.Yeah , bad service and cold food tonight.
Me Me
Soup is good.I ordered a burger medium and it was overcooked and dry. Didn't get a chance to tell the waitress cuz she never came to ask.The cheese steak sandwich was no big deal.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Diane DeCarolis
Very nice lunch spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Colton Lambert
From start to finish it almost seemed like we were an inconvenience. Drinks took forever, so long that we ordered them, waited, received out apps, and then drinks came. We were not given any bread or specials menus. Instead of getting what we ordered I was given a steak sandwich instead of the French Dip Sandwich and someone else at my table was given onion rings instead of fries. The steak sandwich was so bad I didn’t realize it wasn’t what I ordered until half way through. I just thought everything was horrible already why wouldn’t the food. The only thing I was happy about was the refills for my water! Great job team! It was freezing out with a waiting room barely big enough for 5 people as people walk in and out. No room next to the concierge because it’s in top of the bar. 1 star seems cruel so I give 2 because at least the place had some personality.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Linda Saggat
Terrible experience. To summarize, reservations for 6 people for 5:30, there until 7:15, waited forever for food, when arrived, all dishes were lukewarm to cold. Had to ask a busboy for bread while waiting to place our order while waitress was chit-chatting at another table. Minimum 20% tip for a group of 6 for a bill over $300. No manager on duty, was offered a free dessert after a cold meal, not eaten. We hadn't been to Plumstead for years, and do not plan on returning. Overall disappointing.
Food was ok. Service was good. Attentive server. Atmosphere was what it was. Rustic. Nice. I was on a date and I hate day dates. If we sat at the bar it probably would have gotten 5 stars across the board. The date was regrettable, so….I’d go back and try it again with someone else and sit at the bar next time. It wasn’t the restaurants fault. Popular place. Get there early.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
thomas burgess
Say something nice or nothing at all. Sorry, but this review is for the owner. Everyone else can ignore. Every time I go there, I see you sitting in a chair and (at least as I have noticed for as long as I have been going) you never make any attempt to walk the bar area or dining area talking with guests and inquiring about their experience. Sad. Also, try getting "hot", repeat "hot" fries with your undercooked (almost raw) hamburger. Why is that so hard? I guess I am crazy expecting different results every time I go back. I must be crazy. Luckily, I really enjoy the "Screamin' Hill" pale ale. It is the one thing that makes it enjoyable. (It's not made there!) Again, I apologize for the poor review, but hopefully, now, the 1) fries will be served "hot", 2) the burger will be cooked (to my liking), and finally 3) the waitress will come back at least one (1) time to see if everything is satisfactory and possibly be cordial instead of having an attitude. I just hate bothering her by asking (nicely, please!) for some more water or another beer! This is not rocket science, just food I should probably be making at home. That way it will be to my liking at not wasting sixty ($60) dollars, tip and all. I hope you will stop by my table and chat with us next time we come for dinner. We really are nice people with money ($$) in our pockets to spend and a smile on our faces. Might drive further and stick with the Yardville Inn. You never go wrong there. p.s. I served tables for years in some "fine dining" restaurants and can write a book on everything that is wrong at the "Plumsted Grill"! i.e. Servers: please do not put your fingers in used water glasses when clearing tables!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Lindsay Koch
Absolutely love it here! Just had my baby shower at the Plumsted Grill yesterday and it was perfect! We had just over 50 guests attend and we used the closed in patio for the party! The servers were INCREDIBLE and the food (as always) was delicious!
Debra Schaefer
Rustic cabin type atmosphere. Cold in the dining room. Food met our expectations
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, Onion Rings, French Fries
Renee Winter
Was very loud and busy, but was a Saturday. Our waitress was forgetting everything, walking by our table fast looking away so she didn't have to stop... was obvious. Food portions were huge abs very good. Mistakes were made on orders and mixed drinks were horrible.
Prime rib was cold and ask to be heated and was brought back two minutes later still cold horrible food and service ,waiter did not even care.margaritas was made with vodka instead of tequila what a joke.
Avoid this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 2
always have a great meal, great company and great service
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
It was my birthday dinner. I ordered filet mignon. Had it before and it was great. This time it was soo tough the waitress said a lot were sent back. The owner told me they got the wrong kind of meat. Didn't offer any apology and walked away. Could have taken it off the menu. Don't know if I will go back. Spent a lot of money there many times.
The big room is very noisy. The nachos looked really good, but underneath it all, they were all almost plain. Too noisy service lacking. But it always draws a crowd.It's a great place for appetizers and cocktails. Had to wait to get seated while we literally stood next to the bye. That was seating us He never said I'll be right with you. Nothing. We just stood there like dummies. For ten minutes.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Today was my first time at this restaurant our waitress name was Mel she was absolutely rude to me my mom my dad and my aunt and uncle she threw the plates on the table I felt like she was taking her anger out on us
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Usually good.Yeah , bad service and cold food tonight.
Soup is good.I ordered a burger medium and it was overcooked and dry.
Didn't get a chance to tell the waitress cuz she never came to ask.The cheese steak sandwich was no big deal.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Very nice lunch spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
From start to finish it almost seemed like we were an inconvenience.
Drinks took forever, so long that we ordered them, waited, received out apps, and then drinks came.
We were not given any bread or specials menus.
Instead of getting what we ordered I was given a steak sandwich instead of the French Dip Sandwich and someone else at my table was given onion rings instead of fries. The steak sandwich was so bad I didn’t realize it wasn’t what I ordered until half way through. I just thought everything was horrible already why wouldn’t the food.
The only thing I was happy about was the refills for my water! Great job team!
It was freezing out with a waiting room barely big enough for 5 people as people walk in and out. No room next to the concierge because it’s in top of the bar.
1 star seems cruel so I give 2 because at least the place had some personality.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Terrible experience. To summarize, reservations for 6 people for 5:30, there until 7:15, waited forever for food, when arrived, all dishes were lukewarm to cold. Had to ask a busboy for bread while waiting to place our order while waitress was chit-chatting at another table. Minimum 20% tip for a group of 6 for a bill over $300. No manager on duty, was offered a free dessert after a cold meal, not eaten. We hadn't been to Plumstead for years, and do not plan on returning. Overall disappointing.
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was ok.
Service was good. Attentive server.
Atmosphere was what it was. Rustic. Nice.
I was on a date and I hate day dates. If we sat at the bar it probably would have gotten 5 stars across the board.
The date was regrettable, so….I’d go back and try it again with someone else and sit at the bar next time.
It wasn’t the restaurants fault. Popular place. Get there early.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Say something nice or nothing at all. Sorry, but this review is for the owner. Everyone else can ignore. Every time I go there, I see you sitting in a chair and (at least as I have noticed for as long as I have been going) you never make any attempt to walk the bar area or dining area talking with guests and inquiring about their experience. Sad. Also, try getting "hot", repeat "hot" fries with your undercooked (almost raw) hamburger. Why is that so hard? I guess I am crazy expecting different results every time I go back. I must be crazy. Luckily, I really enjoy the "Screamin' Hill" pale ale. It is the one thing that makes it enjoyable. (It's not made there!) Again, I apologize for the poor review, but hopefully, now, the 1) fries will be served "hot", 2) the burger will be cooked (to my liking), and finally 3) the waitress will come back at least one (1) time to see if everything is satisfactory and possibly be cordial instead of having an attitude. I just hate bothering her by asking (nicely, please!) for some more water or another beer! This is not rocket science, just food I should probably be making at home. That way it will be to my liking at not wasting sixty ($60) dollars, tip and all. I hope you will stop by my table and chat with us next time we come for dinner. We really are nice people with money ($$) in our pockets to spend and a smile on our faces.
Might drive further and stick with the Yardville Inn. You never go wrong there.
p.s. I served tables for years in some "fine dining" restaurants and can write a book on everything that is wrong at the "Plumsted Grill"! i.e. Servers: please do not put your fingers in used water glasses when clearing tables!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Absolutely love it here! Just had my baby shower at the Plumsted Grill yesterday and it was perfect! We had just over 50 guests attend and we used the closed in patio for the party! The servers were INCREDIBLE and the food (as always) was delicious!
Rustic cabin type atmosphere. Cold in the dining room. Food met our expectations
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, Onion Rings, French Fries
Was very loud and busy, but was a Saturday. Our waitress was forgetting everything, walking by our table fast looking away so she didn't have to stop... was obvious. Food portions were huge abs very good. Mistakes were made on orders and mixed drinks were horrible.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Loading...