Horrible, bad service, workers are disrespectful, food isn’t worth it. Highly recommend you go somewhere else on boardwalk or travel like 5 minutes for something that’s 100 times better. Waste of time at that place and worst service on the shore.
Gerard Chidichimo
The best pizza by far, Joey and Doreen are wonderful people and truly care about the customer. They make you feel like family and not just a customer..Love them
Tim Atwood
“Jersey Shore Pzza… it’s part of the experience.
Yung Bunk
Me and my wife came and each had a pepperoni slice....not the best pizza but its still pretty decent for boardwalk pizza....
what bugs me out is the reviews that complain about the price....of course $6.75 for a pepperoni slice is expensive but what do u expect when the properties that surround the boardwalk are million dollar average properties, an amusment park, arcades...this is a touristy place. Expect the prices to be expensive...This place during peak season is filled with plenty of demand for a slice and plenty of people are going to pay it....its unfortunate that people will drive the ratings down because they compare the price to pizzarias that aren't on the boardwalk. Make it make sense people.
What I would suggest is for them to use pepperoni cups instead, but if it works for them, whats broke dont need to be fixed.
Also if you want your pizza hot, tell them to heat it up because they may not automatically heat them up due to the long lines.
Christian Mairone
Overall the pizza was good the place was clean, and the staff was friendly. The prices were a little on the high side, but I didn’t feel cheated.
Jamsed Naser
Highly recommended you don’t eat here. 3 slices charged 2 drinks came out to $30 and they didn’t even warm it up. First time I went they forgot my order and I waited 20 min before I realized . This is a tourist trap with high prices ran by teenagers . There is no integrity in this shop. It’s just made to rip off beach goers and maximize profits. Walk up the board walk and just get your slice by the games area. Your welcome.
Cattie B.
The owner was extremely rude towards my wife and I. Stared at us and spoke rudely to us. Pizza was also disgusting.
Haley Raduj
Very delicious pizza and nice size slices! Definitely a new favorite on the boardwalk!
Vintage New Jersey
Great Boardwalk slice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Grilled Chicken w Vodka Sauce, Regular Toppings, Cheese Slice, Parma of Pollo, Sweet and Spicy, Sauce, Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Cheese Pizza, Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza, Sicilian Pizza Pie, Whole Cheese Pie
Kristen M
The pizzas alright, not amazing but not terrible. Used to go there every time we went to point pleasant but with the new prices I don’t think it’s worth it.
I honestly don’t know what the bad reviews are about. Maybe the prices? Two slices and an apple juice was $17. But it is the shore so I guess I get it. The pizza was really good. Could have used a bit more cheese but it did the job.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Haleyne Gilmore
Hello, so I am coming on here to report an experience I had at this restaurant. One of the workers was being disrespectful to a 14 year old child. My daughter had sat at the table and didn’t realize she wasn’t able to sit there because she had ice cream. The worker walked out and told my daughter she couldn’t sit there, my daughter said okay and got up, and the worker said fix your face.
Kid-friendliness: Not FRIENDLY AT ALL!!
Recommended dishes: Sauce
Nick Locurto
Amazing pizza, even better people! Love coming here everytime I’m on the boardwalk!
It's not a trip to Point Pleasant unless we have a slice of Joey Tomato's.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt
Never heard that a pizza place is not allowed to put pepperoni on a slice … but you have plastic straws out for the customers to take which is against NJ state law .
Horrible, bad service, workers are disrespectful, food isn’t worth it. Highly recommend you go somewhere else on boardwalk or travel like 5 minutes for something that’s 100 times better. Waste of time at that place and worst service on the shore.
The best pizza by far, Joey and Doreen are wonderful people and truly care about the customer. They make you feel like family and not just a customer..Love them
“Jersey Shore Pzza… it’s part of the experience.
Me and my wife came and each had a pepperoni slice....not the best pizza but its still pretty decent for boardwalk pizza....
what bugs me out is the reviews that complain about the price....of course $6.75 for a pepperoni slice is expensive but what do u expect when the properties that surround the boardwalk are million dollar average properties, an amusment park, arcades...this is a touristy place. Expect the prices to be expensive...This place during peak season is filled with plenty of demand for a slice and plenty of people are going to pay it....its unfortunate that people will drive the ratings down because they compare the price to pizzarias that aren't on the boardwalk. Make it make sense people.
What I would suggest is for them to use pepperoni cups instead, but if it works for them, whats broke dont need to be fixed.
Also if you want your pizza hot, tell them to heat it up because they may not automatically heat them up due to the long lines.
Overall the pizza was good the place was clean, and the staff was friendly. The prices were a little on the high side, but I didn’t feel cheated.
Highly recommended you don’t eat here. 3 slices charged 2 drinks came out to $30 and they didn’t even warm it up. First time I went they forgot my order and I waited 20 min before I realized . This is a tourist trap with high prices ran by teenagers . There is no integrity in this shop. It’s just made to rip off beach goers and maximize profits. Walk up the board walk and just get your slice by the games area. Your welcome.
The owner was extremely rude towards my wife and I. Stared at us and spoke rudely to us. Pizza was also disgusting.
Very delicious pizza and nice size slices! Definitely a new favorite on the boardwalk!
Great Boardwalk slice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Grilled Chicken w Vodka Sauce, Regular Toppings, Cheese Slice, Parma of Pollo, Sweet and Spicy, Sauce, Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Cheese Pizza, Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza, Sicilian Pizza Pie, Whole Cheese Pie
The pizzas alright, not amazing but not terrible. Used to go there every time we went to point pleasant but with the new prices I don’t think it’s worth it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
I honestly don’t know what the bad reviews are about. Maybe the prices? Two slices and an apple juice was $17. But it is the shore so I guess I get it. The pizza was really good. Could have used a bit more cheese but it did the job.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Hello, so I am coming on here to report an experience I had at this restaurant. One of the workers was being disrespectful to a 14 year old child. My daughter had sat at the table and didn’t realize she wasn’t able to sit there because she had ice cream. The worker walked out and told my daughter she couldn’t sit there, my daughter said okay and got up, and the worker said fix your face.
Kid-friendliness: Not FRIENDLY AT ALL!!
Recommended dishes: Sauce
Amazing pizza, even better people! Love coming here everytime I’m on the boardwalk!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Cheese Pizza, Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza
It's not a trip to Point Pleasant unless we have a slice of Joey Tomato's.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Never heard that a pizza place is not allowed to put pepperoni on a slice … but you have plastic straws out for the customers to take which is against NJ state law .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Loading...